33 results on '"Discourse ethics"'
Search Results
2. Technological Progress in Light of Habermas’ Discourse Ethics
- Author
-
Rok Gregorčič
- Subjects
ürgen habermas ,technological progress ,public sphere ,discourse ethics ,mass media ,the internet. ,Doctrinal Theology ,BT10-1480 - Abstract
The purpose of this article is to thoroughly research Habermas’ view of technology with regard to his discourse ethics. In the first part of the article, Habermas’ theoretical starting points concerning the question of technology are presented. In the next segment, findings are presented, which can be traced mainly in an indirect way from Habermas’ discussions on media theory and from his theory of the colonization of the lifeworld. In the next step, Habermas’ relation to the phenomenon of mass media is addressed. The mass media are understood as a concrete expression of modern progress and are closely linked to technological development. In the last part of the article, Habermas’ relation to the internet is presented. The internet is widely considered an alternative to the mass media in modern times. The article presents a holistic analysis of Habermas’ relation to technology. It also presents some interesting findings regarding Habermas’ positioning towards the mass media and the internet.
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
3. Reflections on Habermas’s discourse ethics
- Author
-
Pieter N.J. Duvenage
- Subjects
habermas ,karel-otto apel ,public sphere ,communicative reason ,discourse ethics ,deliberative politics. ,Practical Theology ,BV1-5099 - Abstract
In this article Habermas’s discourse ethics is critically interpreted. The article starts with a brief intellectual biography of Habermas (section 1), showing that his life and work has always had a strong ethical and political dimension – leading to the concept of discourse ethics. Next, it is indicated how Habermas’s work in the 1970s culminated via four steps in his major philosophical work – the Theory of Communicative Action (section 2) published in 1981. In the next two sections Habermas Theory of Communicative Action is applied to ethics and morality in the form of his discourse ethics – the heart of this contribution (section 3). In this process the following four aspects of Habermas’s discourse ethics are discussed: Its qualified Kantian deontological dimension, as well as its universalist, cognitivist, and formalist dimensions. In the following section (4) the discussion of discourse ethics is shifted to Habermas’s theory of law, deliberative politics, and democracy which is a further application of ideas developed in his Theory of Communicative Action. The contribution then ends with some critical remarks on Habermas discourse ethics and sketch of law and politics (section 5) Three arguments are presented in this regard. First, Habermas argument is judged to be too closely related to abstract rationality. Secondly the distinction that Habermas makes between morality and ethics is critically investigated. Finally, the Habermasian use of justification in his argument is critically compared with the concept of application. These points of criticism, though, indicate that the debate on Habermas’s discourse ethics is ongoing. Intradisciplinary and/or interdisciplinary implications: This article deals with the concept of discourse ethics (in the Kantian tradition of ethics) as developed firstly by Karel Otto Apel and later refined by Jurgen Habermas for his own purposes. The line of argumentation developed here has significant relevance for philosophy, moral theory, law, and theology. Discourse ethics can be considered as a contemporary version of Kantian deontological ethics after the linguistic turn.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
4. Broken Facets of Ethical Universalism. Commentary on the Book Universality in Morality
- Author
-
Anastasia V. Ugleva
- Subjects
ethical universalism ,kant ,universal law of nature ,categorical imperative ,pragmatic universal ,discourse ethics ,сontractarianism ,rational bargain ,Philosophy (General) ,B1-5802 - Abstract
Some ideas expressed in the collective monograph Universality in Morality (2020), edited by Ruben Apressyan, are here critically examined. The book is based on the results of a large-scale study by professional ethical philosophers devoted to the question of the nature of universality in morality and the mechanisms of universalisation of individual maxims and norms from antiquity to modern ethical theories, represented above all by the analytical tradition in philosophy. Of great interest is the analysis of related phenomena in morality, which makes it possible to determine the causes and nature of the transformation of morality in different eras and the accompanying change in the terminological apparatus of absolute ethical universalism, considered to be the starting point in the analysis of key modern concepts of moral universality. The article also suggests possible avenues for continued research in this area which could prompt modifications not only to the history of the concept of universality in morality, but also to our assessment of the contribution of individual authors and entire eras to the progress of human civilisation. This concerns above all the moral theory of contractarianism and the Enlightenment. Focus on their ideas goes a long way to determining the direction of current historical-philosophical research that reconstructs the history of ethical teachings and individual concepts. The importance attached today to a new view of the theory of the social contract, considered not only from socio-political but also from moral positions, forces us to approach in a new way the question concerning the universality of the key philosophical categories developed within this theory throughout its history. Elaborating the ideas set forth in the monograph, the author also stresses the relevance of the problem of justifying the thesis about the moral law as an analogue of the universal law of nature in the modern context.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
5. Normativität und Geschichte : Zur Auseinandersetzung zwischen Apel und Habermas
- Author
-
Smail Rapic and Smail Rapic
- Subjects
- Discourse ethics, Normativity (Ethics)--History, Norm (Philosophy)
- Abstract
Karl-Otto Apel und Jürgen Habermas haben die Diskursethik gemeinsam als neues Paradigma der praktischen Philosophie konzipiert. Es blieb Work in Progress. Beide Autoren setzten von Anfang an unterschiedliche Akzente und erhoben gegen die diskursethischen Entwürfe des jeweils anderen weitreichende Einwände. Habermas hält Apels Anspruch auf Letztbegründung ethischer Grundnormen für uneinlösbar. Er stellt Apels starkem Apriorismus seine Konzeption der'detranszendentalierten'Vernunft gegenüber, die in historisch-kulturellen Lebensformen situiert ist. Habermas vertrat bis zum Ende der 1980er Jahre die These, dass in der Gattungsgeschichte eine Entwicklungslogik der Normativität wirksam sei, die zum Moral- und Rechtsverständnis der neuzeitlichen Aufklärung hinführe. Apel hat sich dieser Position angeschlossen. Habermas selbst problematisiert sie jedoch in seinem diskursethischen Hauptwerk'Faktizität und Geltung'(1992) mit dem Argument, sie gerate in die Nähe geschichtsphilosophischer Spekulation. Seine diskursethische Rechtstheorie in Faktizität und Geltung versteht sich als'Bedeutungsexplikation'der Institutionen und Diskursformen moderner Demokratien. Nach Apel läuft dies auf die Preisgabe universalistischer Begründungsansprüche der Diskursethik hinaus. Die Monographie zeichnet die vielschichtige Auseinandersetzung zwischen Apel und Habermas mit dem Ziel nach, eine vermittelnde Position herauszuarbeiten, die die Idee einer normativen Entwicklungslogik rehabilitiert und in dieser Perspektive die historische Genese normativer Geltung rekonstruiert.
- Published
- 2020
6. Karl-Otto Apel und die Diskursethik : Eine Einführung
- Author
-
Walter Reese-Schäfer and Walter Reese-Schäfer
- Subjects
- Philosophy, Modern--20th century, Discourse ethics, Philosophy, Modern
- Abstract
Dieses Buch führt in die zentralen Thesen von Karl-Otto Apels Philosophie ein, die oft über viele Texte seines Werkes verstreut sind. Sein Werk wird transparent gemacht im Spannungsfeld der Großdebatten zwischen der kritischen Theorie von Habermas und der Philosophie des Kritischen Rationalismus. Walter Reese-Schäfer macht Apels oft schwierige Sprache verständlich, benennt die Voraussetzungen der Diskursethik und steckt ihren Geltungsbereich ab. Damit bietet diese Einführung eine unentbehrliche Hilfe für alle, die einen ersten, aber auch vertiefenden Zugang zu seinem Werk und zur Diskursethik suchen.
- Published
- 2017
7. RECEPTION OF ETHICS OF DISCOURSE IN MODERN PHILOSOPHY
- Author
-
L. I. Tetyuev
- Subjects
ethics ,discourse ethics ,Kant's critical ethics ,neo-Kantianism ,ought ,universal and transcendental pragmatics ,Philosophy. Psychology. Religion - Abstract
The article analyzes the theoretical foundations of the modern project of rational ethics, in which the ethics of discourse is interpreted as a critical theory of society and a critic of modern morality. I. Kant was one of the first to offer the possibility of generalizing the norms of morality and perception of ethics as a transcendental critique of morality. Neo-Kantianism develops ethics as the most important part of the philosophical system and fixes its scope by the idealistic theory of morality (H. Cohen, P. Natorp). In Russian philosophy, modern ethics is perceived as a normative theory that has to do with issues of self-determination, moral regulation, and freedom of choice. The origins of discourse ethics in the philosophy of the 20th century go back to the “pragmatic turn” and to vigorous discussions about hermeneutics of language and its a priori status in German philosophy, and in analytical philosophy regarding the understanding of metaetics. The modern program of ethics of discourse receives meaningful justification as the logic of moral argumentation in the social philosophy of J. Habermas and in the transcendental pragmatics K.-O. Apel. The ethics of discourse is born from the real need to justify moral requirements and norms. Ethics as a critique of moral argument is associated with the pre-reflexive horizon of the life world, why it is a deontological, formalistic and universal ethics. Two significant projects of discourse ethics, presented in the article as an analysis, should be defined as “weak and strong” variants of philosophical transcendental idealism in modern science.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
8. Verbindlichkeit aus dem Diskurs : Denken und Handeln nach der Wende zur kommunikativen Ethik - Orientierung in der ökologischen Dauerkrise
- Author
-
Dietrich Böhler and Dietrich Böhler
- Subjects
- Discourse ethics
- Abstract
Dietrich Böhler führt im Licht der Wende zur Sprache und zur kommunikativen Ethik zunächst durch die Problemgeschichte und gibt eine traditionskritische Einführung in die Philosophie. Im systematischen zweiten Teil zeigt der Autor, wie tief und fruchtbar die Idee des strikt argumentativen und partnerschaftlichen Diskurses - seit Sokrates - als Stachel im Fleisch der Gewohnheiten, der Konventionen und Institutionen, aber auch des Relativismus und Skeptizismus sitzt. Daraus ergibt sich die Frage: Besitzt diese Idee neben ihrer emanzipatorisch kritischen Funktion auch Verbindlichkeit für die Lösung moralischer Konflikte und Orientierungskraft für das neuartige ethische Grundproblem der technologischen Zivilisation: Zukunftsverantwortung?
- Published
- 2016
9. Diskurshandlungen : Theorie und Methode linguistischer Diskursanalyse am Beispiel der Bioethikdebatte
- Author
-
Constanze Spieß and Constanze Spieß
- Subjects
- Embryonic stem cells--Moral and ethical aspects, Bioethics, Discourse analysis--Germany, German language--Discourse analysis, Discourse ethics
- Abstract
Die vorliegende Arbeit stellt eine theoretische und methodische Auseinandersetzung mit der Diskurslinguistik sowie eine empirische Umsetzung dar. Diskurslinguistik im Anschluss an Foucault befasst sich mit textübergreifenden, sprachlichen Wirklichkeitskonstitutionsprozessen, die zugleich als kulturell und weltanschaulich bedingtes Wissen aufzufassen sind. Diskurslinguistik wird handlungstheoretisch fundiert und darauf aufbauend ein Mehrebenendiskursanalysemodell als methodisches Verfahren entwickelt, das sprachstrukturelle, semantische, funktionale sowie situativ-kontextuelle Analysedimensionen umfasst. Am Beispiel des öffentlich-politischen Bioethikdiskurses um Stammzellforschung wird gezeigt, wie Schlüsselwörter, Metaphern und Argumentationstopoi in den je eigenen weltanschaulichen Argumentationskontext gestellt und semantisch fixiert werden, was zu einer perspektivierten Konstruktion von Wirklichkeit führt. Kulturelle und weltanschauliche Voraussetzungen manifestieren sich dementsprechend immer schon in diskurstypischen Sprachgebräuchen, die als semantische Grundfiguren das diskursrelevante Hintergrundwissen bilden.
- Published
- 2011
10. Wittgenstein: od etyki do ślepego stosowania reguł i z powrotem
- Author
-
Ewa Nowak
- Subjects
Wittgenstein ,ethics ,pragmatism ,blind rule-following ,considered and deliberated judgment ,Discourse Ethics ,Ethics ,BJ1-1725 - Abstract
The paper discusses Wittgenstein’s approaches to ethics within two contrastive contexts, e.g., pragmatism and cooperative-discursive normative practice. The first section revisits the fiasco of his early “negative” ethics. The second section subsequently shows how Wittgenstein’s mature concept of blind rule-following displaces normativity but simultaneously becomes the key predictor for discourse ethics (or, rather, a specific kind of it). The final section discusses the pros and cons of finitism in the light of contemporary philosophy of mind. As a conclusion, the author provides evidence for her hypothesis that there is no normative (embodied) mind without a manifest normative competence, which includes moral judgment and discursive competence.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
11. Schwangerschaftskonfliktberatung heute - Teil 3.
- Author
-
Heidrich, Matthias
- Subjects
- *
DISCOURSE ethics , *PREGNANCY , *ABORTION laws , *UNWANTED pregnancy , *SEX education , *CONTRACEPTIVES - Abstract
The article provides information on the counseling of pregnancy conflict, focusing on abortion law for unwanted pregnancy, availability of material ethics and learning from discourse ethics. Topics include psychosocial counseling on prenatal diagnostics, sexual education prevention and correct use of contraceptives.
- Published
- 2018
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
12. Kollektive Autonomie als kommunikations- und medienethische Selbstbestimmung.
- Author
-
Krainer, Larissa
- Abstract
Copyright of Medien & Kommunikationswissenschaft is the property of Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft mbH & Co. KG and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)
- Published
- 2018
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
13. Die Ethik der herzlichen Vernunft aus ihren deutschen und spanischen Wurzeln
- Author
-
Adela Cortina
- Subjects
anthropology of values ,anthropology of knowledge ,discourse ethics ,communicative reason ,Psychology ,BF1-990 ,Philosophy (General) ,B1-5802 - Abstract
The Discourse Ethics, as a new type of procedural ethics, considers only the logical-formal dimension of reason, i.e., the capacity of the partner of discourse to make claims of validity on what is said and to resolve, through the discourse, the constraints present in in daily life. The communicative capacity presupposes, however, not only the ability to argue, then an anthropology of knowledge, but also an anthropology of values that allows to judge values, and which contains the conditions beforehand to understand what is right.
- Published
- 2013
14. Quale etica per quale futuro? Le vie dell’etica – uno sguardo retrospettivo
- Author
-
Francesca Caputo
- Subjects
norms ,language ,dialectical discursive ,discourse ethics ,universal consensus ,Psychology ,BF1-990 ,Philosophy (General) ,B1-5802 - Abstract
This paper, starting from the question “Which etichs for what future?”, retraces a few streets of ethical reflection, subdividing the exploration in moments of classical Greece (with Socrates, Plato and Aristotle), of modernity (with Kant, developments science, Hegel) and of the current globalized world (with Jürgen Habermas and Karl-Otto Apel). The problem of values, in particular, and of ethics, in general, arises today, as in the past, in a double sense: regards, on the one hand, their possible foundation or legitimation, on the other, their possible sharing and acceptance by all members of the community. Discourse ethics, especially in the version theorized by Karl-Otto Apel, appears more congenial in outlining the minimum basis of a common ethics shared, guaranteed by the universal consensus of ethics intrinsic to the discourse.
- Published
- 2013
15. La fondazione del vincolo etico in Karl-Otto Apel
- Author
-
MICHELE BORRELLI
- Subjects
Ethical Foundations ,Transcendental Philosophy ,Discourse Ethics ,Practical Reason ,Argumentation ,Psychology ,BF1-990 ,Philosophy (General) ,B1-5802 - Abstract
The debate concerning the validity and foundation of ethical behavior as opposed to that which is dictated by norms cannot be resolved in the field of methodical thought nor by using deductive procedures, its resolution lies rather in theoretical philosophy in general and concerns the same scenario as that of critical philosophy. What one is looking for is a way to organize communication on a social level and to implement discursive reasoning.The problem is twofold: on the one hand the problem of communication concerns the structure of society and the possibility of communicating freely independent of dominion, on the other hand it relates to transcendental thought relating to the possibility of creating a foundation for ethics.The latter (ethic foundation) is always a pre- requisite and is activated in discourse itself.
- Published
- 2009
16. Universalität und Priorität der Menschenrechte in diskursethischen Begründungsmodellen
- Author
-
Hoesch, M. (Matthias) and Universitäts- und Landesbibliothek Münster
- Subjects
ddc:172 ,Cluster of Excellence Religion and Politics ,human rights ,Rainer Forst ,Jürgen Habermas ,discourse ethics ,Exzellenzcluster Religion und Politik ,Menschenrechte ,Diskursethik ,Political ethics - Abstract
Menschenrechte gelten nach der gängigen Auffassung universal und haben Priorität vor anderen moralischen Zielen. Der Aufsatz diskutiert kritisch, wie verschiedene Autor*innen, die sich der Diskursethik zurechnen, diese beiden Merkmale von Menschenrechten rekonstruieren. Abschließend skizziert er eine Menschenrechtsbegründung, die beiden Merkmalen besser gerecht wird.
- Published
- 2021
17. Prinzipien und Diskurs - Ein Ansatz theoretischer Rechtfertigung der ethischen Fallbesprechung und Ethikkonsultation.
- Author
-
Mertz, Marcel, Albisser Schleger, Heidi, Meyer-Zehnder, Barbara, and Reiter-Theil, Stella
- Abstract
Copyright of Ethik in der Medizin is the property of Springer Nature and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)
- Published
- 2014
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
18. DER JOURNALIST ALS DISKURSANWALT. KOMMUNIKATIONSETHISCHE ÜBERLEGUNGEN FÜR JOURNALISTISCHES HANDELN IN DEMOKRATISCHEN GESELLSCHAFTEN.
- Author
-
Burkart, Roland
- Subjects
- *
JOURNALISTIC ethics , *DISCOURSE ethics , *COMMUNICATIVE action , *PUBLIC sphere , *DEMOCRACY , *POLITICAL philosophy - Abstract
A central function of mass media in democracies is to make political processes public. In this paper, starting from the theory of communicative action by Jürgen Habermas, a communication ethical perspective for journalists is discussed. Based on this theory, the journalist is seen as a lawyer in the public discourse. As a lawyer he should — on behalf of the interested public - question critically the actions of politicians. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2014
19. VERBINDLICHKEIT DURCH METHODE: Warum der Schweizer Ethikkodex das Thema Whistleblowing methodisch zurecht nicht aufgreift.
- Author
-
Brasser, Martin
- Subjects
- *
WHISTLEBLOWING , *DECISION making in library science , *DISCOURSE ethics , *DEONTOLOGICAL ethics , *VIRTUE ethics , *UTILITARIANISM , *PROFESSIONAL ethics of librarians , *LIBRARIES - Abstract
In the Swiss version of IFLA 's Code of Ethics there is no mention about whistleblowing at all. This is where this article starts some considerations about methods of implementing stipulated guidelines (especially of ethical quality). In general, there are three methods which can be distinguished corresponding to three different types of ethics : firstly, focussing on prescribing procedures (procedural ethics such as discourse ethics or deontology), secondly, evaluating values and their collocation (virtue ethics), and thirdly, considering pros and cons by scenarios (utilitarianism). In praxis, these methodic guidelines should be amended by didactic methods in order to support adressees in adopting their Code of Ethics. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2014
20. INFORMATIONSETHIK ALS DISKURSETHIK.
- Author
-
Betz, Fritz
- Subjects
- *
INFORMATION ethics , *DISCOURSE ethics , *PROFESSIONAL ethics of librarians , *INFORMATION services , *FREEDOM of information , *RIGHT of privacy , *SITUATION ethics , *ETHICS - Abstract
The contribution presents information ethics as applied ethics in library and information science with some of its essential concerns. Thereby, it is proposed to elaborate and review norms for action in the professional field via the procedures of „situative discourse ethics“. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2014
21. Wiesel oder Hermelin? Strukturelle Gerechtigkeit als Fundament einer modernen Sozialen Marktwirtschaft.
- Author
-
FUCHS-GOLDSCHMIDT, INGA and GOLDSCHMIDT, NILS
- Subjects
SOCIAL attitudes ,COMMUNITIES ,MODERN society ,POLITICAL science ,CAPITALISM - Abstract
Copyright of Journal for Business, Economics & Ethics / Zeitschrift für Wirtschafts und Unternehmensethik is the property of Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft mbH & Co. KG and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)
- Published
- 2013
22. Die Öffentlichkeit der Buße: Eine theologische Kritik an einem Zentralbegriff der Diskursethik.
- Author
-
BARTH, GUNTHER
- Subjects
- *
REPENTANCE , *PUBLICITY , *PUBLIC relations , *PUBLIC theology , *GUILT (Psychology) , *DISCOURSE ethics , *ETHICS ,SOCIAL aspects - Abstract
This article develops an ethical approach to a concept of publicity, that enables to practice the liberation from guilt and injustice. The usual narrowing of repentance to the ritual of private confession is not adequate to Christian tradition. It also objects to the task of a theological ethics to call humans to the "liberating reversion into being a creature" (H.G. Ulrich). The concept of publicity against the usual contrast "public - private" is developed from the juxtaposition "public - hidden". On this way it shows theological criteria for public relations. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2013
23. Arzneimittel für neuartige Therapien umfassend bewerten.
- Author
-
Thanner, M. and Nagel, E.
- Abstract
Copyright of Bundesgesundheitsblatt - Gesundheitsforschung - Gesundheitsschutz is the property of Springer Nature and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)
- Published
- 2011
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
24. Zum Stellenwert von Betroffenheit, Öffentlichkeit und Deliberation im empirical turn der Medizinethik.
- Author
-
Schicktanz, Silke
- Abstract
Copyright of Ethik in der Medizin is the property of Springer Nature and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)
- Published
- 2009
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
25. Bolzanos Erklärung des Zeitbegriffs.
- Author
-
Schnieder, Benjamin
- Subjects
TIME ,RECONSTRUCTION (Linguistics) ,LOGIC ,PHILOSOPHICAL analysis ,DISCOURSE ethics ,INSIGHT ,CONCEPTION -- Religious aspects -- Catholic Church ,BELIEF, Problem of (Literature) - Abstract
Bernard Bolzano repeatedly tried to provide an analysis of the concept of time. This paper develops a detailed reconstruction of Bolzano's analysis. Thereby it clarifies the logical form of the analysis and thus discovers its principal problem:While the analysis may well incorporate an important insight on our conception of time, it cannot succeed as an analysis. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2009
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
26. Zeitschrift für Praktische Philosophie / Ethikberatung und Covid-19: Brauchen wir mehr Ethik, mehr als Ethik oder mehr Ethiker?
- Author
-
Hack, Caroline
- Subjects
Ethikberatung ,Diskursethik ,Ethics Consultation ,Ethics of Principles ,Prinzipienethik ,Public Health ,Covid-19 ,Discourse Ethics - Abstract
Bisher ist die Rolle von Ethikkomitees und Ethikberatenden als Ressource im Umgang mit der Covid-19-Pandemie ungeklärt. Im vorliegenden Beitrag wird diskutiert, worin spezifische Herausforderungen bei der ethischen Bewertung von Fragen an Ethikkomitees im Pandemiekontext bestehen und welche möglichen Aufgaben für Ethikberatende identifiziert werden könnten. Dabei wird die Ansicht vertreten, dass es für die kompetente, professionelle Bearbeitung dieser Fragen hilfreich wäre, (a) das theoretische Grundverständnis der Ethikberatung für den Pandemiekontext zu reflektieren, (b) die begründungstheoretischen, normativen Argumente aktueller Publikationen und Stellungnahmen der Fachgesellschaften zu diskutieren und (c) Weiterbildungspotenzial sowie Kompetenzgrenzen zu identifizieren. Für (c) werden zur Kompetenzerweiterung Public-Health-Ethik und Ethik der Menschenrechte vorgeschlagen, psychische Entlastung bei ‚moralischem Stress‘ wird als ethisch-psychologischer Kooperationsbereich diskutiert und die explizite Abgrenzung vom juristischen Bereich wird empfohlen. Ethikberatung könnte den konstruktiven Umgang mit ethischen Fragen im Pandemiekontext fördern, die Qualität von Entscheidungs- und Bewertungsprozessen verbessern und in der Versorgungspraxis pragmatische, konkrete Hilfestellung anbieten. Up to now, the role of ethics committees and ethics consultants as resource for dealing with the Covid-19-pandemic is undefined. This article examines specific challenges of the ethical assessment concerning the requests to ethics committees in connection with the pandemic as well as possible tasks for ethics consultants. For ensuring competent, professional answers to these kind of requests it could be helpful to (a) re-evaluate the theoretical premises of ethics consultation for the specifics of the pandemic, (b) to discuss the motivation-theoretical, normative arguments in recent publications and statements of professional societies and (c) to identify the potential for enhancement of skills and knowledge as well as limits of competencies. Concerning (c), Public-Health-Ethics and Ethics of Human Rights will be presented as possibilities for enhancement, providing psychological relief for ‘moral distress as area for ethical-psychological cooperation whereas the explicit distinction between ethical and legal fields of competencies will be recommended. Due to that, ethics consultation could promote a constructive approach to ethical questions in connection with the pandemic, enhance the quality of evaluation- and decision-making-processes and offer pragmatic and practical support in health care. (VLID)5807706
- Published
- 2020
27. Anmerkungen aus argumentationstheoretischer Perspektive.
- Author
-
Dietrich, Julia
- Subjects
HUMAN rights -- Philosophy ,CULTURAL relativism ,UNIVERSALISM (Political science) ,APPLIED ethics ,THEORY of knowledge ,MORAL relativism ,DISCOURSE ethics - Abstract
A critical response to the article “Relativismus und Menschenrechte” by Marie-Luisa Frick, published in this issue of the journal, is presented. Analyzing Frick's test through the lens of argumentation theory, the author addresses several issues, including the philosophy of human rights from the perspectives of cultural relativism and universalism, applied ethics, and the connection between epistemological universalism and ethical particularism.
- Published
- 2013
28. A Problematic Relationship, Seen from the Point of View of Discourse Ethics
- Author
-
Tettenborn, Oliver
- Subjects
the West ,rhetoric ,Invektiva ,resentment ,discourse ethics ,respect ,politische Korrektheit ,Postkoloniale Theorie ,the East ,Ossis ,invectives ,Diskursethik ,Achtung ,Wessis ,political correctness ,Ressentiment ,Rhetorik ,postcolonial theory - Abstract
„Ost“ und „West“ – das sind nicht nur Himmelsrichtungen, sondern tief eingewachsene kulturelle Komplexe, traumatische „topoi“ unserer inneren Europaischen Geisteslandschaft. Ich mochte diese von Hochmut, Ressentiment und Krankung gepragte Situation zunachst kurz historisch skizzieren, um zu einer diskursethischen Analyse nach den Ansatzen O. Apels und J. Habermas uberzugehen. Kernthese dabei ist, dass der individualistische „westliche“, Diskursbegriff diskursive Tugenden wie die gegenseitige Achtung der Teilnehmer systematisch unterschatzt. Indem wir uns auf die Wahrung einer gleichen Zulassung zum Diskurs konzentrieren, ignorieren wir krankende (invektive) Potentiale und scheitern dadurch an der adaquaten Analyse des Verhaltens von Teilnehmern, die sich im Diskurs als marginalisiert erleben. “East“ and “West“ – they are not just points on the compass but deeply rooted cultural complexes, traumatic “topoi“ of our inner European landscape. This essay starts with a short historic outline of this situation, marked by arrogance, resentment and insults and aims at an analysis from the point of view of the concept of discourse ethics by O. Apel and J. Habermas. Our central hypothesis is that the individualistic “Western“ point of view of the function of discourses and their ethical aspects systematically underestimates discoursive virtues, such as mutual respect of the participants. By considering only “fair and equal admission“ to discourses, we ignore potentials of discoursive disrespect (“invective“ behaviour) and misunderstand the discoursive behaviour of groups and individuals that feel “marginalized“ by the structure of the discourse.
- Published
- 2016
29. Liebe, Kommunikation und Ethik
- Author
-
Schiel, Andreas
- Subjects
normativity ,communication ,habermas ,discourse ethics ,ethics ,love ,watzlawick - Abstract
Ist im 21. Jahrhundert die Idee einer Liebesethik noch von Relevanz? Dieser in seinen Ursprüngen jüdisch-christliche bzw. platonische Gedanke einer radikalen Gesinnungsethik erscheint spätestens nach Auschwitz gründlich diskreditiert. Aber hält dieses Urteil einer eingehenden Analyse stand? Liegen der Idee einer Liebesethik nicht wichtige und richtige Annahmen über eine Fähigkeit des Menschen zur intrinsisch motivierten Lösung moralischer Probleme zu Grunde? Könnte nicht das auf eine basale und universelle Verständigung abzielende Konzept einer solchen Ethik in der heutigen Zeit fruchtbar werden, wenn wir überkommene Denkmuster aus Alltagsleben und Moralphilosophie hinterfragen und die bisher als christlich aufgefasste Liebesethik in einen säkularen Kontext stellen? Und wäre eine solche ‚Auffrischung‘ unseres Nachdenkens über Ethik nicht in höchstem Maße wünschenswert, ja geboten? Immerhin weisen die bis heute dominierenden Konzepte einer durch extrinsische Motivatoren, nämlich durch abstrakte Prinzipien und Gebote, durch Zwang und Sanktionen legitimierten Moralität eine recht unbefriedigende Wirksamkeit in der ethischen Praxis auf. Zielsetzung und wichtigstes Ergebnis dieser Arbeit ist daher eine Perspektiverweiterung der philosophischen Ethik. Diese stellt sich dar als eine Inblicknahme der Idee einer Gesinnungsethik im Kontext der Liebe aus einer sozial- und beziehungstheoretischen, im engeren Sinne kommunikationstheoretischen Perspektive. Dieser Blick auf eine sonst vor allem aus mythologisch und religiös geprägten Zusammenhängen bekannte Thematik eröffnet die Möglichkeit ihrer Verknüpfung mit moralphilosophischen Ansätzen unserer säkular geprägten, 'postmetaphysischen' Gegenwart – und so letztlich auch Perspektiven einer konkreten praktischen Anwendung. Vor allem die Verknüpfung mit der Diskursethik im Sinne Habermas' erscheint hier als fruchtbar. Die Deutung von Liebe als Prozesse auf existenzieller Ebene therapeutisch wirksamer Kommunikation, die eine interpersonale Verständigung von Menschen auf basaler Ebene ermöglichen, lässt es denkbar erscheinen, Vorgänge der rational-diskursiven Normenfindung zu fundieren und zu korrigieren, indem als Liebe apostrophierte Kommunikationsmethoden einen 'blinden Fleck' in der Diskurstheorie füllen: Vor und neben die normativen Übereinkünfte in abstrakter Sprache kommunizierender Subjekte träte dann die Suche nach Verständnis und Einigung mit dem Nächsten nicht nur auf 'kognitiver', sondern auch auf 'affektiver' Ebene. Solche dualistischen Denkfiguren sind indes wenig angemessen das in dieser Arbeit entwickelte, hypothetische Zusammenwirken von Methoden der kommunikativen Fundierung von Moral zu umschreiben. Die Skizze einer solchen ganzheitlich kommunikativen 'Komplementärethik' versucht diese Untersuchung an Hand möglichst praxisnaher, konkreter Beispiele zu liefern. Eine Anknüpfung an die Überlegungen dieser Arbeit in zukünftigen Forschungsarbeiten könnte zum Einen auf die nachhaltige Revitalisierung der Idee einer 'Liebesethik' hinauslaufen. Vor Allem aber auf eine produktive Bearbeitung der Probleme umstrittener Legitimität, mangelnder Internalisierung und unzureichender Flexibilität rational-abstrakt begründeter Normativität., Is there any reason today to treat the idea of an ethics of love as one of value and concern? Based on Judeo-Christian and Platonic thought, the idea of a radical ethics of conviction appears thoroughly discredited after Auschwitz. But does this judgment persist when challenged by an in-depth analysis? Does the idea of love ethics not imply important and correct assumptions about a human ability to find intrinsically motivated solutions to moral problems? Could such an approach, aiming at a basal and universal understanding, proof as a helpful and sensible perspective?Given the disappointing practical outcome of those conceptions of morality, still prevailing today, that legitimate morals by extrinsic motivators, namely by abstract principles and commandments, by coercion and sanctions, there is a need of new and alternative perspectives on moral problems. This is why both the central aim of this thesis and its most important result is to be called the finding of a broader perspective on philosophical ethics. This broadened perspective presents itself as an 'Inblicknahme' of the idea of an ethics of love in the context of a social and relational theory, communication theory in the strict sense of perspective. This new perspective on a topic so far dominated by mythological and religious approaches opens up the possibility of an association of 'love ethics' with present approaches in moral philosophy that share today's secular and 'post-metaphysical' perspective on ethics. In this respect the most promising link seems to be the connection of Habermas' conception of discourse ethics with our interpretation of love as a process of therapeutically effective acts of communication that enable interpersonal understanding on an existential level. This way it seems possible to substantiate processes of rational-discursive norm construction and to correct regimes of abstract and static normativity by filling a blind spot in the discourse theory: Normative consensus would then not only be found by communicating in the abstract rational language of depersonalized subjects but also by striving for understanding and agreement with our next ones by 'affective' means. Such dualistic thought patterns are, however, of little use here, when we try to describe the hypothetical methods of communicative foundation of morality developed in this work. By drawing the sketch of such a holistic communicative 'complementary ethics' we have been trying to deliver practical and concrete examples of its possible implementation in 'real life'. Nevertheless, given the complexity of the treated problems, the considerations of this work must inevitably remain cursory and preliminary. In future research, however, one may expect a revitalization of the idea of an 'ethics of love' in the first place, but above all the finding of smarter solutions to the problems of contested legitimacy, lack of internalization and lack of flexibility in the field of rationally justified normativity.
- Published
- 2014
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
30. Genet(h)ik:: Das philosophische Konzept derDiskursethik und Konsequenz für dieForschungsgemeinschaft
- Author
-
Witte, K. and Blankenberg, S.
- Published
- 2004
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
31. Integrative Wirtschaftsethik besser ohne Diskursethik
- Author
-
Lumer, Christoph
- Subjects
Integrative Economic Ethics ,Discourse Ethics ,economics as political - Published
- 2000
32. Habermas' Diskursethik
- Author
-
Lumer, Christoph
- Subjects
discourse ethics ,Jürgen Habermas ,principle of discourse ethics ,universalisation principle ,epistemic consensus ,contractual agreement - Published
- 1997
33. Motivation zu moralischem Handeln und Diskursethik
- Author
-
Lumer, Christoph
- Subjects
discourse ethics ,adequacy conditions for justifications of morals ,motivation requirement ,Habermas' rejection of the motivation requirement ,discourse ethics' problems with the motivation requirement - Published
- 1997
Catalog
Discovery Service for Jio Institute Digital Library
For full access to our library's resources, please sign in.