38 results
Search Results
2. Humanities on Demand and the Demands on the Humanities: Between Technological and Lived Time.
- Author
-
Atkinson, Paul and Flanagan, Tim
- Subjects
- *
HUMANITIES , *CONCERTS , *DIGITAL technology , *THEORY of knowledge - Abstract
The digital humanities have developed in concert with online systems that increase the accessibility and speed of learning. Whereas previously students were immersed in the fluidity of campus life, they have become suspended and drawn-into various streams and currents of digital pedagogy, which articulate new forms of epistemological movement, often operating at speeds outside the lived time and rhythm of human thought. When assessing learning technologies, we have to consider the degree to which they complement the rhythms immanent to human thought, knowledge, investigation, and experimentation. In this paper, we examine learning from a humanities perspective, arguing that reading, writing, and thinking are ways of learning underscored by various genres of movement that segue with or diverge from the movements inherent to digital technologies, especially those deployed in learning systems. Using the work of thinkers such as John Dewey and Michel Serres, we examine the importance of movement in dialogue, where to truly learn involves embedding oneself in the flow of thought, accepting the flexibility of concepts, and aligning oneself with a community of thinkers. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
3. The 'two cultures' in Australia.
- Author
-
Barnes, Joel
- Subjects
- *
HISTORY of science , *THEORY of knowledge , *HUMANITIES , *HIGHER education - Abstract
This article considers Australian receptions of C. P. Snow's The Two Cultures and the Scientific Revolution (1959), and of the controversy over the literary critic F. R. Leavis's combative 1962 response to it. Taking a lead from conceptual insights in global histories of science and the history of knowledge, the paper considers the ways knowledge claims iterate differently in different geographic and cultural contexts. Elements of the Snow–Leavis dispute resonated among Australian scientists, cultural critics, journalists and poets, while others did not. Snow's diagnosis of a disciplinary antagonism between the humanities and the sciences was central to Australian receptions of the controversy, but wider political issues, emphasised in much of the more sophisticated historiography of the 'two cultures' as a British-American controversy, were largely ignored. This reception reflected the post-war expansion of Australian higher education, and the shifting relations within it between the humanities and the sciences. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
4. From Information to Knowledge Creation in the Archive: Observing Humanities Researchers' Information Activities.
- Author
-
Leigh, Alexandra, Makri, Stephann, Taylor, Alex, Mulinder, Alec, and Hamdi, Sarra
- Subjects
- *
INFORMATION resources , *HUMANITIES , *THEORY of knowledge , *EMPIRICAL research , *SCHOLARS - Abstract
As primary sources, archival records are a unique information source at the very heart of humanities research. However, how humanities researchers move from information to knowledge creation by making meaning from archival records has not been the focus of previous empirical research. This is surprising, as creating new knowledge through (re)interpretation of records is a core motivation and outcome of humanities research; as representations of historical and social occurrences, archival records rely on researchers' interpretation of content, context, and structure to establish an 'archival' meaning of the record, before applying this meaning within their own work. Therefore, constructing knowledge from archival materials necessitates a dual process of knowledge creation to create novel insights from a hybrid interpretation of archival meaning and the researcher's own interests. This paper presents findings from a naturalistic empirical observation of 11 humanities researchers engaging in research at a national archive, centring on key information activities that facilitate knowledge creation from archival records: Scanning, Relating, Capturing and Organising. Through these activities, scholars integrate their research aims and objectives with archival meaning to generate new insights. Deeper understanding of the nature of knowledge creation in archives can benefit archivists, archive users and systems designers alike. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
5. The conceptual ecology of digital humanities.
- Author
-
Poole, Alex H.
- Subjects
- *
DIGITAL humanities , *DEBATE , *THEORY of knowledge , *STAKEHOLDERS , *SUSTAINABILITY , *CYBERINFRASTRUCTURE - Abstract
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to dissect key issues and debates in digital humanities, an emerging field of theory and practice. Digital humanities stands greatly to impact the Information and Library Science (ILS) professions (and vice versa) as well as the traditional humanities disciplines.Design/methodology/approach This paper explores the contours of digital humanities as a field, touching upon fundamental issues related to the field’s coalescence and thus to its structure and epistemology. It looks at the ways in which digital humanities brings new approaches and sheds new light on manifold humanities foci.Findings Digital humanities work represents a vital new current of interdisciplinary, collaborative intellectual activity both in- and outside the academy; it merits particular attention from ILS.Research limitations/implications This paper helps potential stakeholders understand the intellectual and practical framework of the digital humanities and “its relationship” to their own intellectual and professional work.Originality/value This paper critically synthesizes previous scholarly work in digital humanities. It has particular value for those in ILS, a community that has proven especially receptive to the field, as well as to scholars working in many humanities disciplines. Digital humanities has already made an important impact on both LIS and the humanities; its impact is sure to grow. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2017
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
6. Recovering Early Modern Women Writers.
- Author
-
Gordon‐Roth, Jessica and Kendrick, Nancy
- Subjects
- *
WOMEN philosophers , *PHILOSOPHERS , *THEORY of knowledge , *FEMINISM , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
Feminist work in the history of philosophy has been going on for several decades. Some scholars have focused on the ways philosophical concepts are themselves gendered. Others have recovered women writers who were well known in their own time but forgotten in ours, while still others have firmly placed into a philosophical context the works of women writers long celebrated within other disciplines in the humanities. The recovery of women writers has challenged the myth that there are no women in the history of philosophy, but it has not eradicated it. What, we may ask, is impeding our progress? This paper argues that so often we treat early modern women philosophers' texts in ways that are different from, or inconsistent with, the explicit commitments of the analytic tradition, and in so doing, we may be triggering our audiences to reject these women as philosophers, and their texts as philosophical. Moreover, this is the case despite our intention to achieve precisely the opposite effect. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
7. Is narrative an endangered species in schools’? Secondary pupils’ understanding of ‘storyknowing’.
- Author
-
Heinemeyer, Catherine and Durham, Sally
- Subjects
- *
STORYTELLING , *NARRATIVES , *NATIONAL Curriculum (Great Britain) , *LEARNING , *THEORY of knowledge , *CREATIVE ability , *SECONDARY education , *SCHOOL children - Abstract
This paper argues that narrative knowledge (or ‘storyknowing’) is marginalized within the English school system, because it is misunderstood and often not recognized as knowledge. We track the changing status of storytelling through some key moments in recent educational history, particularly focusing on its gradual erosion during the progressive era, the onset of the National Curriculum (despite the impact of the National Oracy Project), and the post-2000 period with its conflicting drives towards compliance and creativity. To understand the consequences of this marginalization, we build up a picture of the value of narrative knowledge, drawing firstly on the body of theorists who have investigated narrative. We then look to our long-term practice research with three groups of ‘low-ability’ 11–14-year-old pupils, in particular their own observations on storytelling made during a focus group. Both sources lead us to challenge the currently dominant perception that pupils listening to a whole narrative are in a passive role. Indeed, we provide evidence that reasserting the value of storyknowing may restore aspects of agency, autonomy and knowledge creation to both teachers and pupils which may not be afforded by overtly ‘active’ learning strategies. We conclude by considering the conditions in which storyknowing, as characterized by the pupils and theorists, might flourish within schools. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2017
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
8. Bourdieu’s sociology: A post-positivist science.
- Author
-
Jain, Sheena
- Subjects
- *
SOCIOLOGY , *THEORY of knowledge , *POSITIVISM , *SOCIAL sciences , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
This paper takes as its starting point the fact that Bourdieu’s views on sociology as a science have not been sufficiently and adequately understood and discussed. It traces the links between his conception and that of the French tradition of historical epistemology which is critical of positivism. How Bourdieu extends their views, and those of Bachelard especially, beyond the realm of the natural sciences, to the social sciences and sociology in particular, is discussed. In the process he introduces new concepts and methods, such as that of participant objectivation. His perspective reveals a convergence between the natural sciences and the social sciences as human endeavours striving for universal truths. This is reinforced and widened to include the humanities as well as demonstrated by his analysis of the literary field. The paper concludes with the observation that Bourdieu’s post-positivist science is a salutary alternative to the postmodern critique of science. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2013
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
9. ON LOGICAL AND METHODOLOGICAL FEATURES OF SOCIAL SCIENCES AND THE HUMANITIES: WHAT INFORMAL LOGIC HAS TO OFFER.
- Author
-
Griftsova, Irina and Sorina, Galina
- Subjects
- *
SOCIAL sciences , *HUMANITIES , *SCIENTIFIC knowledge , *THEORY of knowledge , *CULTURE - Abstract
The authors start from the assumption that social sciences and the humanities constitute an independent type of scientific knowledge. This assumption increases the relevance of examining the features of its ontology, epistemology, and methodology. It also necessitates the development of new logical means suitable for studying the reasoning, features of cognitive operations, and justification and argumentation procedures characteristic of this type of knowledge. The paper suggests considering informal logic and a number of approaches to developing the logic of scientific research, which are presented in Russian logic and methodology of science, from this perspective. It also addresses the possibility of their application in the methodology of social sciences and the humanities, which will make it possible to identify the logical and methodological features of sciences of society and culture. It is proposed to interpret reasoning as a discursive act comprising logical, cognitive, and rhetorical aspects. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2016
10. Thinking in Eigenbehaviors as a Transdisciplinary Approach.
- Author
-
Füllsack, Manfred and Riegler, Alexander
- Subjects
- *
SCIENTIFIC method , *PHILOSOPHY , *THEORY of knowledge , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
Context: By proposing to regard objects as "tokens for eigenbehavior," von Foerster's seminal paper opposes the intuitive subject-object dualism of traditional philosophy, which considers objects to be instances of an external world. Problem: We argue that this proposal has two implications, one for epistemology and one for the demarcation between the natural sciences and the humanities. Method: Our arguments are based on insights gained in computational models and from reviewing the contributions to this special issue. Results: Epistemologically, von Foerster's proposal suggests that what is called "reality" could be seen as an ensemble of eigenforms generated by the eigenbehavior that arises in the interaction of multiple dynamics. Regarding science, the contributions to this special issue demonstrate that the concept of eigenbehavior can be applied to a variety of disciplines from the formal and natural sciences to the humanities. Its universal applicability provides a strong argument for transdisciplinarity, and its emphasis on the observer points in the direction of an observer-inclusive science. Implications: Thinking in eigenbehavior may not only have implications for tearing down the barriers between sciences and humanities (although a common methodology based on von Foerster's transdisciplinary approach is still to crystalize), a better understanding of eigenbehaviors may also have profound effects on our understanding of ourselves. This also opens the way to innovative behavior design/modification technologies. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2017
11. PROJECTION OF KNOWLEDGE SOCIETIES TOWARDS THE PAST.
- Author
-
Felix Jr., Arnulfo
- Subjects
- *
THEORY of knowledge , *KNOWLEDGE management , *SCIENTIFIC knowledge , *HUMANITIES , *RATIONALISM - Abstract
This reflection paper examines the role of History in Knowledge Societies. It simultaneously follows two parallel premises. First, it discusses Knowledge Societies' reactions derived from the idea of a non-existent present as theorized by German writer and statesman Johann Wolfgang von Goethe. The fact that this unformed future, which cannot be reached until the future comes to fruition, has been overlooked in the development of Knowledge Society theories. It also looks at the dilemma that Knowledge Societies are not self-sufficient sciences, and thus they must be examined within the context of an already recognized science, such as History, to develop exact, stable and fully-explored procedures. My argument suggests that much of what we today call "Knowledge Societies" was not bred by a KS paradigm but rather by a projection towards the past that is understood by way of a historical approach. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2018
12. Envisioning the Archipelago.
- Author
-
Stratford, Elaine, Baldacchino, Godfrey, McMahon, Elizabeth, Farbotko, Carol, and Harwood, Andrew
- Subjects
- *
ARCHIPELAGOES , *HUMANITIES , *SOCIAL sciences , *THEORY of knowledge , *ONTOLOGY - Abstract
Certain limitations arise from the persistent consideration of two common relations of islands in the humanities and social sciences: land and sea, and island and continent/mainland. What remains largely absent or silent are ways of being, knowing and doing—ontologies, epistemologies and methods—that illuminate island spaces as inter-related, mutually constituted and co-constructed: as island and island. Therefore, this paper seeks to map out and justify a research agenda proposing a robust and comprehensive exploration of this third and comparatively neglected nexus of relations. In advancing these aims, the paper's goal is to (re)inscribe the theoretical, metaphorical, real and empirical power and potential of the archipelago: of seas studded with islands; island chains; relations that may embrace equivalence, mutual relation and difference in signification. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2011
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
13. On Keeping Logic in the Major.
- Author
-
DECKER, JASON
- Subjects
- *
PHILOSOPHY education , *LOGIC , *THEORY of knowledge , *HUMANITIES , *UNDERGRADUATES - Abstract
A course in symbolic logic belongs as a requirement in the undergraduate philosophy major. In this paper, which started life as a letter to my departmental colleagues, I consider and respond to several reasons one might have for excluding Logic from the core requirements. I then give several arguments in favor of keeping Logic. The central--and most important--argument is that the lack of a proper background in logic makes it very difficult to approach many relatively straightforward philosophical arguments, let alone the more technical subliteratures of philosophy. In developing this argument, I consider a few core texts and arguments (e.g., Gettier's classic paper on the analysis of knowledge) and bring out how a student with some background in formal logic would be able to approach the texts and arguments with much greater ease than a student who lacks such a background. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2011
14. Moving ideas and mobile researchers: Australia in the global context.
- Author
-
Fahey, Johannah and Kenway, Jane
- Subjects
- *
SOCIAL sciences , *HUMANITIES , *IDEA (Philosophy) , *THEORY of knowledge - Abstract
This paper draws from the ARC Discovery project called Moving Ideas: Mobile Policies, Researchers and Connections in the Social Sciences and Humanities - Australia in the Global Context (2006-2009). This project explored the ways that ideas travel and how knowledge transforms through travel. One aspect of the study was the critical examination of various research policies around the world that are associated with moving ideas and moving researchers. These are often coupled with notions of 'brain drain-gain/mobility' and diaspora. A second focus was on the mobility biographies of globally mobile intellectuals with various links to Australia and on the implications of their mobility for their ideas, politics and national and trans-national identifications. It is our view that the actual experiences and insights of such people have the potential to enhance researcher (academic) mobility policies. A third concern has been to address the question of what it means to globalise the research imagination. In addressing this question we have drawn on leading researchers from around the globe who undertake research on globalisation itself. The paper to follow draws from selected publications associated with this project. The book from the project, to be completed in 2010, is titled Moving Ideas and Mobile Intellectuals. It should be noted at the outset that our focus in the project and in this discussion paper is on researchers in the social sciences and humanities including but not exclusively educational researchers. We begin by asking what it means to globalise research and how is this related to the nation-state'? [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2010
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
15. A Place for Humanities Graduates on the Labour Market in the so-called Knowledge Society: The French Case.
- Author
-
Louvel, Séverine
- Subjects
- *
BUSINESS & education , *HUMANITIES , *GRADUATES , *THEORY of knowledge , *LABOR market , *OCCUPATIONAL training , *ACADEMIC degrees - Abstract
The emergence of the knowledge society and the development of knowledge-intensive employment functions do not seem to improve dramatically the situation of humanities graduates on national labour markets. This paper gives an overview of the employment situation of French humanities graduates and summarizes recent attempts to improve it. A description of how the employment for humanities graduates has developed in the course of the last decade is followed by an analysis of two complementary governmental initiatives: the development of Higher Vocational Education degrees and the professionalization of all curricula. The paper concludes with three propositions based on personal teaching experiences and a broader analysis of the French higher education system. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2007
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
16. Understanding Students' Practical Epistemologies and Their Influence on Learning Through Inquiry.
- Author
-
Sandoval, William A.
- Subjects
- *
THEORY of knowledge , *SCIENCE education , *METAPHYSICS , *PSYCHOLOGY , *HUMANITIES , *STUDENTS - Abstract
The article focuses on the understanding of student's practical epistemologies and their influence on learning through inquiry. Current standards argue that inquiry should be a central strategy of science instruction, for several reasons. These reasons include that students will learn science concepts more deeply as well as develop their skills of doing science. A major reason is that inquiry is presumed to be a way to help students develop a sophisticated understanding of the nature of science. Epistemology is a term used quite differently by philosophers and psychologists. It will be helpful to briefly introduce some definitions to clarify the argument to follow, although the definitions of formal and practical epistemologies that is mentioned here will be expanded upon at greater length throughout the paper. Epistemology is the branch of philosophy concerned with the study of knowledge. It is concluded by the authors that this paper has been successful to lay out an agenda for studying epistemology in science education in ways that can couple students' epistemological development to their practices of inquiry.
- Published
- 2005
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
17. Biblical Theology: Bridge Over Many Waters.
- Author
-
Helmer, Christine
- Subjects
- *
RELIGION , *THEOLOGY , *PHILOSOPHY , *THEORY , *THEORY of knowledge , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
Biblical theology's bridge-building capacities are studied in this paper by mapping out a historical trajectory of the discipline, and by addressing the possible novel directions the field might take in the future. An epistemological parameter and a structural parameter were set by Gabler that continue to inform the contemporary discussion. In order to open up the discussion to hermeneutical, philosophical and systematic theological questions, the paper offers a proposal for a text theory, and addresses its implications for some concrete questions posed recently in biblical theology. A final section sketches various currents in biblical studies and theology that are having an impact on the field. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2005
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
18. Metaphysics in Gaston Bachelard's `Reverie'
- Author
-
Picart, Caroline Joan ("Kay") S.
- Subjects
- *
IMAGINATION (Philosophy) , *METAPHYSICS , *HUMANITIES , *MENTAL imagery , *THEORY of knowledge - Abstract
This paper aims to trace the evolution of Bachelard‘s thought as he gropes toward a concrete formulation of a philosophy of the imagination. Reverie, the creative daydream, occupies the central position in Bachelard‘s emerging metaphysic, which becomes increasingly ’’phenomenological‘‘ in a manner reminiscent of Husserl. This means that although Bachelard does not use Husserlian terms, he appropriates the following features of (Husserlian) phenomenology: 1. a desire to ’’embracket‘‘ the initial (rationalistic) impulse; and 2. an aspiration to apprehend in its entirety, the creative epiphany of an image. Ultimately, this paper aims to show that there is a sense in which Bachelard‘s metaphysical concerns in his poetics are an outgrowth of (rather than radical break from) his earlier scientific and epistemological concerns. What results in reverie is an aesthetic intentionality providing a metaphysic of the imagination: the aesthetic object, such as fire or water, is an object only insofar as it enables/calls forth a subject to enter into a receptive, self-aware and cosmic state of being; subject-ness and object-ness are intimately and archetypally intertwined. Bachelard‘s ’’new poetics‘‘ results from his transplantation/cross-fertilization of the general epistemology of the ’’new scientific spirit‘‘ on to/across his aesthetics. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 1997
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
19. Ability-based objections to no-best-world arguments.
- Author
-
Kierland, Brian and Swenson, Philip
- Subjects
- *
EXPERTISE , *THEORY of knowledge , *ABILITY , *PHILOSOPHY , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
In the space of possible worlds, there might be a best possible world (a uniquely best world or a world tied for best with some other worlds). Or, instead, for every possible world, there might be a better possible world. Suppose that the latter is true, i.e., that there is no best world. Many have thought that there is then an argument against the existence of God, i.e., the existence of an omnipotent, omniscient and morally perfect being; we will call such arguments no-best-world arguments. In this paper, we discuss ability-based objections to such arguments; an ability-based objection to a no-best world argument claims that the argument fails because one or more of its premises conflict with a plausible principle connecting the applicability of some type of moral evaluation to the agent's possession of a relevant ability. In particular, we formulate and evaluate an important new ability-based objection to the most promising no-best world argument. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2013
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
20. The Enactive Approach to Education: The Crucial Role of the Humanities.
- Author
-
Ellis, Ralph D.
- Subjects
- *
HUMANITIES , *EDUCATION , *ACADEMIC motivation , *THEORY of knowledge - Abstract
If human motivation is "enactive" rather than merely a series of passive reactions to external stimuli, then a correspondingly "enactive" approach to education should be taken seriously. This paper argues that recent research on the emotional brain by such neuropsychologists as Jaak Panksepp, combined with a self-organizational approach to the concept of action, and the importance of the questioning process in human understanding of information, suggests that treating humanities education as intrinsically valuable, and not just as means toward other ends, is crucially important. The questioning process that appeals to students' natural exploratory tendencies, or what Hume called a "love of truth," is fostered by an approach that, rather than dumbing down, actually appeals to the "glamour of the complex." The glamour of the complex cannot stop with interesting application of memorized information; it must go all the way down to basic epistemology and the basic questioning of human nature itself that are encouraged by taking the humanities seriously and for their own sake. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2010
21. How to Value the Liberal Arts for Their Own Sake without Intrinsic Values.
- Author
-
Schmidt, Erik W.
- Subjects
- *
HUMANITIES , *HUMANISTIC education , *VALUES (Ethics) , *THEORY of knowledge , *CRITICAL pedagogy - Abstract
I argue that there is an important problem with framing the value of a liberal arts education through a contrast between intrinsic and instrumental value. The paper breaks down into three sections. First, I argue that the traditional divide between intrinsic and instrumental value conflates two pairs of related concepts and that distinguishing those concepts frees us from an important impasse found in contemporary discussions about the liberal arts. Second, I argue that a liberal arts education is only intelligible as a practice if we value it for its own sake. Third, I explain how we can value a liberal arts education as an end even if we reject the possibility of intrinsic value. I conclude with a brief statement of the practical implications my account has for the way we approach the liberal arts. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2010
22. Is experimental philosophy philosophically significant?
- Author
-
Alexander, Joshua
- Subjects
- *
PHILOSOPHY , *HUMANITIES , *INTUITION , *THEORY of knowledge - Abstract
Experimental philosophy has emerged as a very specific kind of response to an equally specific way of thinking about philosophy, one typically associated with philosophical analysis and according to which philosophical claims are measured, at least in part, by our intuitions. Since experimental philosophy has emerged as a response to this way of thinking about philosophy, its philosophical significance depends, in no small part, on how significant the practice of appealing to intuitions is to philosophy. In this paper, I defend the significance of experimental philosophy by defending the significance of intuitions—in particular, by defending their significance from a recent challenge advanced by Timothy Williamson. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2010
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
23. Philosophical methodology: The current debate.
- Author
-
Vaidya, Anand J.
- Subjects
- *
INTUITION , *HUMANITIES , *THEORY of knowledge , *PHILOSOPHY , *RATIONALISM - Abstract
In this paper I investigate current issues in the methodology of philosophy. In particular, the epistemology of intuition and the status of empirical work on the use of intuition in philosophy. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2010
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
24. Von ,Listenwissenschaft‘ und ,epistemischen Dingen‘. Konzeptuelle Annäherungen an altorientalische Wissenspraktiken.
- Author
-
Hilgert, Markus
- Subjects
- *
EPISTEMICS , *ASSYRIOLOGY , *HUMANITIES , *REASONING , *THEORY of knowledge , *THEORY - Abstract
Traditionally, Ancient Mesopotamian epistemic practices resulting in the vast corpus of cuneiform ‘lexical lists’ and other, similarly formatted treatises have been conceptualized as “ Listenwissenschaft” in Assyriology. Introduced by the German Assyriologist Wolfram v. Soden in , this concept has also been utilized in other disciplines of the Humanities as a terminological means to describe epistemic activity allegedly inferior to ‘Western’ modes of analytical and hypotactic scientific reasoning. Building on the exemplary evidence of a bilingual list of cuneiform compound graphemes from the early 2nd millennium BCE as well as on recent conceptualizations of ‘epistemic cultures’ and the instrumental function of material ‘representations’ in the context of epistemic practices, the present paper attempts to replace the essentialistic and teleological concept of an Ancient Mesopotamian “ Listenwissenschaft” with a new epistemological model describing the underlying epistemic practices as highly adaptive non-linear epistemic practices comparable to what has been described as ‘practices with »epistemic things«’ in recent epistemology and practice theory. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2009
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
25. EPISTEMOLOGICAL CONSIDERATIONS ON NEUROIMAGING – A CRUCIAL PREREQUISITE FOR NEUROETHICS.
- Author
-
HUBER, CHRISTIAN G. and HUBER, JOHANNES
- Subjects
- *
THEORY of knowledge , *BRAIN imaging , *NEUROSCIENTISTS , *LIFE sciences , *HUMANITIES , *HYPOTHESIS , *DETERMINANTS (Mathematics) , *DIAGNOSTIC imaging ,PSYCHIATRIC research - Abstract
Purpose: Whereas ethical considerations on imaging techniques and interpretations of neuroimaging results flourish, there is not much work on their preconditions. In this paper, therefore, we discuss epistemological considerations on neuroimaging and their implications for neuroethics. Results: Neuroimaging uses indirect methods to generate data about surrogate parameters for mental processes, and there are many determinants influencing the results, including current hypotheses and the state of knowledge. This leads to an interdependence between hypotheses and data. Additionally, different levels of description are involved, especially when experiments are designed to answer questions pertaining to broad concepts like the self, empathy or moral intentions. Interdisciplinary theoretical frameworks are needed to integrate findings from the life sciences and the humanities and to translate between them. While these epistemological issues are not specific for neuroimaging, there are some reasons why they are of special importance in this context: Due to their inferential proximity, ‘neuro-images’ seem to be self-evident, suggesting directness of observation and objectivity. This has to be critically discussed to prevent overinterpretation. Additionally, there is a high level of attention to neuroimaging, leading to a high frequency of presentation of neuroimaging data and making the critical examination of their epistemological properties even more pressing. Conclusions: Epistemological considerations are an important prerequisite for neuroethics. The presentation and communication of the results of neuroimaging studies, the potential generation of new phenomena and new ‘dysfunctions’ through neuroimaging, and the influence on central concepts at the foundations of ethics will be important future topics for this discipline. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2009
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
26. Towards an 'engineered epistemology'?
- Author
-
Doridot, Fernand
- Subjects
- *
ENGINEERING , *PHILOSOPHY , *THEORY of knowledge , *HUMANITIES , *TECHNOLOGY - Abstract
The objective of this paper is to consider the links between engineering and philosophy in order to understand what their synthesis, in a discipline we might call 'engineered epistemology', might be like. This article will attempt to defend the thesis that engineering and philosophy are complementary ways of approaching the same reality, distinct methodologically but not distinct in kind. I will do this by demonstrating internal, rather than external, links between these two disciplines. I will begin by investigating the types of external links different historical traditions have established, with particular attention to two recent attempts to define a philosophy of engineering. Then I will address the problem of characterising some possible internal links, first by trying to understand how engineering can be understood as a philosophical discipline, then secondly how philosophy itself can be interpreted as a discipline related to engineering. These sections will take the form of an investigation of some problems in established traditions. I will conclude by drawing together the consequences of these different approaches to the concept of 'engineered epistemology'. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2008
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
27. Does 'Peirce' Have a History? A Contribution to a History of the 'Moment of Theory'.
- Author
-
Freadman, Anne
- Subjects
- *
HISTORY , *THEORY of knowledge , *PRAGMATISM , *SOCIAL sciences , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
There is not yet, and perhaps never could be, a clear canonical history that makes sense of Charles Sanders Peirce. In this sense, despite the best efforts of Peirce scholarship, Peirce is not 'an author'. A highly technical philosopher who worked on several fronts, he appears to espouse positions that the standard traditions of philosophical debate find difficult to hold together. Partly because of the fragmentary nature of his oeuvre, and partly because of the diversity of his interests, he is often appropriated into projects, these appropriations contributing further to the difficulty of telling a single sense-making story. In this paper, I sketch five stories: 1. Peirce as sui generis, the founder of pragmatism; 2. Peirce as not sui generis - the influences in his work and the conversations of the philosophers in which he participated; 3. Peirce as a philosopher of science, and hence, not compatible with projects in the human sciences and the humanities; 4. Peirce as he was appropriated into the human sciences and the humanities, in the form of semiology and following that, into Derrida's critique of semiology; 5. Peirce retrieved by neo-pragmatism as a weapon against 'French theory'. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2008
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
28. I Just Don't Know What Got into Me: Where is the Subject?
- Author
-
Thrift, Nigel
- Subjects
- *
SUBJECTIVITY , *THEORY of knowledge , *PERFORMING arts , *ARTS , *HUMANITIES , *SOCIAL sciences - Abstract
This paper argues that subjectivity needs to be understood as a geography. The “psychotopical” analysis that is necessary in order to understand subjectivity requires that more emphasis be placed on arts of experiment drawn from the battery of performing arts that exist on the borderline between the humanities and the social sciences. Some examples are given.Subjectivity (2008) 22, 82–89. doi:10.1057/sub.2008.1 [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2008
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
29. Naming and the Analogy of Being: Mclnerny and the Denial of a Proper Analogy of Being.
- Subjects
- *
THEORY of knowledge , *ANALOGY , *MEANING (Philosophy) , *PHILOSOPHY , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
This paper addresses the question of whether there is a proper analogy of being according to both meaning and being. I disagree with Ralph Mclnerny's understanding of how things are named through concepts and argue that Mclnerny's account does not allow for the thing represented by the name to be known in itself. In his understanding of analogy, only ideas of things may be known. This results in a wholesale inability to name things at all and thereby forces Mclnerny to relegate naming to a purely logical concern. As a consequence, for Mclnerny, since naming becomes only a logical concern, being itself cannot be known as analogous according to being and meaning since naming only involves the naming of ideas, not of things. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2007
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
30. CROSSING BOUNDARIES.
- Author
-
Tilghman, Ben
- Subjects
- *
ARTS , *HUMANITIES , *AESTHETIC experience , *HANDICRAFT , *AESTHETICS , *THEORY of knowledge - Abstract
There is much talk in the ‘art world’ about boundaries and the blurring of boundaries between art and non-art, art and craft, and various forms within art. What is meant by a boundary is not always clear and this paper tries to make some sense of what may be at stake when deciding on which side of a line something falls. It is suggested that the important thing is how we deal with and react to particular examples rather than worrying about whether it is a this or a that. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2006
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
31. Kant, Wittgenstein, and Transcendental Chaos.
- Author
-
Westphal, Kenneth R.
- Subjects
- *
CONCEPTS , *THEORY of knowledge , *PHILOSOPHY , *HUMANITIES , *THOUGHT & thinking - Abstract
Wittgenstein sought to uphold ‘realism without empiricism’. This paper identifies in Wittgestein's and in Kant's philosophies a common line of argument that provides a genuinely transcendental argument for (not from) mental content externalism. This line of argument has not been previously recognized in either thinker's work. The common thesis defended by both Wittgenstein and Kant alike is that, if we human beings did not inhabit a natural world structured by a recognizable degree of similarity and variety among the objects or events we perceive, we could not so much as think, so we could not so much as be self-conscious. (This line of argument is independent of Kant's idealism, and ultimately shows that Kant's transcendental idealism is false and unsupportable.) [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2005
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
32. Predictivism for Pluralists.
- Author
-
Barnes, Eric Christian
- Subjects
- *
PLURALISM , *PHILOSOPHY , *JUDGMENT (Psychology) , *THEORY of knowledge , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
Predictivism asserts that novel confirmations carry special probative weight. Epistemic pluralism asserts that the judgments of agents (about, e.g., the probabilities of theories) carry epistemic import. In this paper, I propose a new theory of predictivism that is tailored to pluralistic evaluators of theories. I replace the orthodox notion of use-novelty with a notion of endorsement-novelty, and argue that the intuition that predictivism is true has two roots. I provide a detailed Bayesian rendering of this theory and argue that pluralistic theory evaluation pervades scientific practice. I compare my account of predictivism with those of Maher and Worrall. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2005
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
33. Hegel, Habermas and the Spirit of Critical Theory.
- Author
-
Grumley, John
- Subjects
- *
CRITICAL theory , *PHILOSOPHY , *HUMANITIES , *CRITICISM (Philosophy) , *THEORY of knowledge , *MODERN philosophy , *POLITICAL philosophy - Abstract
This paper explores the complex relation between Hegel and Habermas. Centring the discussion around the key themes of philosophy, modernity and political philosophy, it argues for a gradual re-approachment of Habermas towards Hegel. In the final section on critical theory, it takes up the question of the spirit of this theory to offer a more trenchant critique of Habermas' theoretical shortcoming from this perspective. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2005
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
34. Drifting down the Gulf Stream: navigating the cultures of disability studies.
- Author
-
Meekosha *, Helen
- Subjects
- *
LEARNING disabilities , *THEORY of knowledge , *HEALTH , *CULTURE , *HUMANITIES , *GULF Stream - Abstract
This paper explores the divergent theoretical developments in the UK and US disability studies and posits some explanations for these differing trajectories. History, politics, space, place and the search for identity have all played important roles. These emergent and hotly debated developments add a wealth of material to the epistemological project. The recent collections by Barnes et al. (2002) Disability studies today, and Snyder et al. (2002) Disability studies: enabling the humanities, wall be used as pivotal works. However, the question remains as to what explanatory power discourses developed within western metropolitan national cultures have for exploring the experience of disability in cultures on the peripheries. This analysis is being undertaken by an English bom academic, who has been living in Australia for over 20 years and has been keenly watching and participating in the transatlantic battles over the past decade. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2004
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
35. BODILY KNOWING.
- Author
-
Young, Garry
- Subjects
- *
THEORY of knowledge , *EXPERIENCE , *BEHAVIOR , *PHILOSOPHY , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
This paper questions the view that knowledge must be articulable or at least experiential. It asserts that what distinguishes habitual yet intentional action from a mechanistic response is its grounding in a suitable claim to knowledge. However, it denies that a necessary condition for knowing how to perform an action is the ability of the subject to either articulate the particulars of that act, or experience it as appropriate. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2004
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
36. Ernest Sosa, Knowledge, and Understanding.
- Author
-
Grimm, S.R.
- Subjects
- *
VIRTUE epistemology , *THEORY of knowledge , *PHILOSOPHY , *HUMANITIES , *CONSCIOUSNESS - Abstract
This paper offers and analysis of Ernest Sosa's Virtue Perspectivism. Although Sosa has been credited with fathering the influential contemporary movement known as Virtue Epistemology, I argue that Sosa imprudently abandons the reliabilist-based insights of Virtue Epistemology in favor of a reflection-based, ``perspectival'' view. Sosa's mixed allegiance to reliabilist-based and reflection-based views of knowledge, in fact, leads to an unwelcome tension in his thought which can be relieved by recognizing that his reflection-based view is in fact an account of the cognitive state of understanding, rather than an account of knowledge. Sosa makes matters difficult for himself because he expects too much, as it were, from the concept of knowledge, and in the process burdens his view with elements of reflection it does not require. To solve the problem, I suggest that Sosa needs to develop a two-tiered epistemology which recognizes that knowledge, on the one hand, and understanding, on the other, both have necessary and sufficient conditions unique to themselves. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2001
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
37. Three Major Originators of the Concept of Verstehen: Vico, Herder, Schleiermacher.
- Author
-
HAUSHEER, ROGER
- Subjects
- *
VERSTEHEN , *SOCIAL theory , *THEORY of knowledge , *PHILOSOPHY , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
It is generally agreed by historians of modern thought that, at the end of the nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth, philosophers in the German-speaking world identified and defined a type or species of knowledge whose peculiar independent status had hitherto been largely overlooked. It was developed, clarified, and, with a sharpened awareness of its unique possibilities, made to work in practice above all by Dilthey, Windelband, Rickert and their numerous followers; and, to a degree, also by Max Weber. The general name by which it was, and is, most often referred to is ‘Verstehen’—understanding. It has to be admitted that it was from the first, and remains to this day, a highly problematic and hotly disputed concept. Positivists, materialists, behaviourists and monists of all kinds—all those whose ideal is a single structure of organized systematic knowledge—have tended to view it with deep suspicion, and even to deny its existence altogether, claiming that it is wholly illusory and doomed to disappear before the inevitable advance of positive scientific method. However that may be, it will not be my purpose in this paper to enter into these difficult controversies. It may indeed be that no watertight definition of it is possible; that its putative boundaries with other forms or types of knowledge are vague and shifting; and even that there is no ultimate discontinuity in principle between it and the knowledge we gain from other spheres of research and investigation. [ABSTRACT FROM PUBLISHER]
- Published
- 1996
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
38. Modesty as a Nietzschean Virtue.
- Author
-
Van Boxel, Lise
- Subjects
- *
THEORY of knowledge , *PHILOSOPHY , *THOUGHT & thinking , *PSYCHOLOGY , *HUMANITIES - Abstract
Nietzsche argues philosophy cannot provide us with a content-rich account of the good. Rather, it provides only a formal good. Nietzsche thereby reminds us of the limited character of human knowledge. ..PAT.-Conference Proceeding [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2006
Discovery Service for Jio Institute Digital Library
For full access to our library's resources, please sign in.