1. Predodžbe studenata prirodoslovno-matematičkih fakulteta o ionskoj vezi
- Author
-
Roko Vladušić and Mia Ožić
- Subjects
alternativni koncepti ,ionske veze ,kemijske veze ,PMF ,alternative concepts ,ionic bonding ,chemical bonding ,Faculty of Science - Abstract
Kemijske se veze, kao imaginarni koncepti, mogu objašnjavati na različitim razinama složenosti. Prateći slijed od pojednostavljenih modela s nižih razina obrazovanja, preko znanstveno utemeljenih koncepata koji se uvode u srednjoškolskom obrazovanju pa sve do složenih kvantno-mehaničkih teorija s preddiplomske i diplomske razine, znanje o kemijskim vezama se kontinuirano restrukturira i nadograđuje. U takvom sustavu apstraktnih koncepata, ograničenih pravila i raznovrsnih modela, raznolikost stečenih (alternativnih) predodžbi uvriježena je pojava. Vođeni spoznajom o dihotomnom pogledu učenika i studenata na kemijske veze (Taber, 2002), odlučili smo steći dublje spoznaje o razumijevanju ionske veze. Istražili smo izgrađenost elektrostatskog (znanstvenog) i molekularnog (alternativnog) koncepta ionskog vezivanja u populaciji studenata preddiplomskih i diplomskih studija prirodoslovnomatematičkih fakulteta u RH. Posebnu smo pažnju posvetili potonjem. Podatke smo prikupili dijagnostičkim instrumentom s 20 tvrdnji (Taber, 2012). Kod dijela studenata su identificirane alternativne ideje o ionskim vezama. Iako su oni s diplomskih studija uspješniji, razlike u odnosu na studente s preddiplomske razine nisu značajne., Chemical bonding, as imaginary concepts, can be explained on different complexity levels. Following the sequence of simplified models from lower levels of education, through science-based concepts that are introduced in secondary education up to complex quantum-mechanical theory to undergraduate and graduate levels, knowledge of chemical bonding are continually restructured and upgrades. In such system of abstract concepts, rules and limited variety of models, alternative conceptions are ingrained phenomenon. Guided by knowledge of the dichotomous views of pupils and students on chemical bonding (Taber, 2002), we decided to acquire a deeper knowledge of understanding ion bonding. We investigated construction: electrostatic (scientific) and molecular (alternative) concept of ionic bonding in students population of undergraduate and graduate studies of Faculty of science in Croatia. We have taken a diagnostic instrument with 20 items (Taber, 2012) and strengthened by the addition of self-assessment of safety in the results. At some students we identified alternative ideas about ionic bonding. Although graduate students were more successful, differences compared to undergraduate level students, as a rule, are not significant. Certain alternative thinking elements are strongly related to students from specific institutions.
- Published
- 2016