Search

Background: Blood group ABO-incompatible live donor (LD) renal transplantation may provide a significant source of organs. We report the results of our first 14 cases of ABO-incompatible LD renal transplantation using specific anti-A/B antibody (Ab) immunoadsorption (IA) and anti-CD20 monoclonal Ab (mAb) treatment. PATIENTS AND TREATMENT PROTOCOL: Recipients were blood group O (n = 12), A (n = 1) and B (n = 1). Donors were A1 (n = 2), A2 (n = 3), A2B (n = 1) and B (n = 8), and all were secretor positive. Anti-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) Ab panel reactivity was negative in all recipients except one. All recipients were pre-treated with 3 to 6 IA sessions, using A or B carbohydrate antigen columns, until their anti-A1/B RBC panel indirect antiglobulin test (IAT) titers were < or =8. CDC crossmatch was negative in all cases. Recipients received preoperative mycophenolic acid, and steroids/tacrolimus were started at transplantation. No splenectomy was performed. Eight recipients received one dose of anti-CD20 mAb (rituximab, 375 mg/m2) pre-operatively and 11 recipients had postoperative protocol IA., Results: In the initial protocol, anti-CD20 mAbs were used only for recipients receiving A1 grafts. One B graft (HLA-identical donor, 84% panel reactivity) was lost in a severe anti-B Ab-mediated acute rejection. Subsequently, the protocol included anti-CD20 for recipients of both A1 and B grafts and postoperative protocol IA to all recipients. The subsequent 10 grafts had excellent function, giving a total graft survival of 13/14 (observation range 2 to 41 months). At 1 yr, mean serum creatinine was 113 micromol/l (n = 8) and mean glomerular filtration rate was 55 ml/min/1.73 m2 (range 24 to 77). In the remaining five cases, with less than 1 yr follow up, mean serum creatinine was 145 micromol/l at 2 to 9 months follow up. Pre-IA anti-A/B titers were in the range of 2 to 32 (NaCl technique) and 16 to 512 (IAT). More than 90 IA sessions were performed in 14 recipients without any significant side effects. Recipient anti-A/B titers returned after transplantation to pre-IA levels or slightly lower. Postoperative renal biopsies were performed in 10 patients. In the 13 patients with long-term function, one patient experienced cellular rejection (Banff IIB) at 3 months without anti-B titer rise. This rejection was concomitant with low tacrolimus plasma levels and was easily reversed by steroids. In 8 of 10 cases, C4d staining was positive in peritubular capillaries., Conclusion: Blood group ABO-incompatible LD renal transplantation using A and B carbohydrate-specific IA and anti-CD20 mAbs has excellent graft survival and function.

Background: The longer waiting time for a liver graft in patients with blood group O makes it necessary to expand the donor pool for these patients. This applies in both urgent situations and for elective patients. We report on our experience with ABO-incompatible liver transplantation using A2 and B non-secretor donors here., Patients and Methods: Between 1996 and 2005, 12 adult blood group O recipients (seven male/five female) received ABO-incompatible cadaveric liver grafts (10 A2 donors, two B non-secretor donors). The indications were either rapid deterioration of liver function or hepatocellular cancer, in blood group O recipients, where an ABO-identical/compatible graft was not available. Mean recipient age was 54+/-8 (mean+/-SD) yr. All pre-operative CDC crossmatches were negative. The initial immunosuppression was induction therapy with antithymocyte globulin (n = 3), interleukin 2 receptor antagonists (n = 3) or anti-CD20 antibody (rituximab) (n = 1), followed by a tacrolimus-based protocol. Three patients underwent plasmapheresis post-transplantation. Baseline biopsies were taken before or immediately after reperfusion of the graft and after grafting when clinically indicated. No pre-operative plasmapheresis, immunoadsorption or splenectomies were performed., Results: Patient and graft survival was 10/12 (83%) and 8/12 (67%), respectively, with a 6.5-month median follow-up (range 10 days to 109 months). Two patients (B non-secretor grafts) died of multiorgan failure probably because of a poor condition before transplantation. Three patients were retransplanted. Causes of graft loss were bacterial arteritis (n = 1), death with a functioning graft (n = 1) and portal vein thrombosis (n = 2). In one of the patients with portal vein thrombosis, an anti-A titer increase occurred concomitantly, and ABO incompatibility as the cause of the thrombosis cannot be excluded. Seven acute rejections occurred in five patients and all were reversed by steroids or increased tacrolimus dosage. The pre-transplant anti-A titers tested against A1 red blood cells were 1 to 128 (NaCl technique) and 4 to 1024 (indirect antiglobulin technique, IAT); the maximum postoperative titers were 16 to 2048 (NaCl) and 256 to 32,000 (IAT)., Conclusion: The favorable outcome of A2 to O grafting, with a patient survival of 10/10 and a graft survival of 8/10, makes it possible to also consider this blood group combination in non-urgent situations. The use of non-secretor donor grafts is interesting but has to be further documented. There was no hyperacute rejection or increased rate of rejection. Anti-A/B titer changes seem not to play a significant role in the monitoring of ABO-incompatible liver transplantation.

Background: Biochemical studies of organ blood group antigen expression show a mixed pattern originating from both the organ tissue and remaining blood cells trapped in the organ despite in vitro perfusion of the vascular tree. The blood group A glycolipid expression was studied in a unique case in which a human liver had been in situ perfused by recipient blood., Case History: A blood group O recipient was re-transplanted with an ABO incompatible A1Le (a - b +) liver. Because of discrepancy in size, liver segments II and III were removed 2 h after re-vascularization. Thereafter, the removed A1 liver segment was physiologically in situ perfused with O blood, eliminating a major part of the donor blood cells/plasma., Experimental: Total neutral glycolipids were isolated from the liver tissue and separated by high-performance liquid chromatography. Purified glycolipid fractions were stained with anti-A monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and structurally characterized by mass spectrometry and proton nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy., Results: Two blood group A reactive glycolipid compounds were isolated. One component had a thin-layer chromatography (TLC) mobility as a six-sugar glycolipid and reacted with mAbs specific for A type 1 mono-fucosyl structures. The second glycolipid fraction migrated as seven-sugar components and reacted with mAbs specific for type 1 difucosyl (ALeb) as well as Leb determinants. Mass spectrometry of the six-sugar component showed a structure similar to a blood group A hexaglycosylceramide with one fucose. Mass spectrometry and proton NMR spectroscopy of the seven-sugar fraction revealed a mixture of blood group Leb hexa- and ALeb hepta-glycosylceramides, respectively. All fractions were non-reactive with antibodies specific for A antigens based on types 3 and 4 core chain structures. In addition, TLC immunostaining of glycolipids isolated from blood group A livers, harvested for organ transplantation but discarded for various reasons, revealed trace amounts of several A glycolipids with a complex pattern., Conclusion: The in situ perfused liver tissue contains blood group A glycolipids based exclusively on type 1 core chains. The secretor gene (Se) codes for a fucosyltransferase acting on all core chain precursors while the H-gene fucosyltransferase only utilizes the type 2 chain precursor. Whether this explains that only A type 1 chain compounds were found has to be established.

Background: The use of thin easily revascularized cutaneous nerve autografts, which has been the gold standard, or the alternative use of nerve allografts or artificial grafts for nerve reconstructing have all their pros and cons. Nerve xenotransplantation may offer a potential alternative. In a potential pig to human nerve xenograft transplantation set-up several porcine antigen barriers have to be considered such as carbohydrate antigens system like the blood group A/O, the Galalpha1-3Gal (alphaGal) and the Hanganutziu-Deicher (HD) antigens. The swine leukocyte protein antigens system may also have to bee considered. The knowledge of the antigen expression on pig peripheral nerves is today limited. The present study describes the distribution of glycolipid based carbohydrate xenoantigens in ischiadicus nerve from blood group A and O pigs., Methods: Glycolipid fractions were separated on thin layer chromatography plates and immunostained with human AB sera, biotinylated Griffonia simplicifolia isolectin B4, monoclonal antibodies reacting with the HD antigen and with blood group A antigens based on different core saccharide structures. In addition, the subcellular distribution of alphaGal and HD antigens were studied by light- and electron-microscopical immunohistochemistry. The total amount of neutral glycolipids was 15 mg/g tissue for both blood group A and O nerves with mono-glycosylceramides as the dominating component., Results and Conclusions: The total amount of acidic glycolipids (gangliosides and sulpholipids) was 9 mg/g tissue for both the blood group O and A nerves with sulphatides as the dominating components. Analyses of the glycolipid fractions showed strong expression of both the alphaGal and the HD antigens in nerves from both blood group A and O pigs. In addition, small amounts of blood group A antigens were expressed in nerves from blood group A pigs. Staining of neutral glycolipids from blood group A pigs using monoclonal antibodies reacting with A antigen having different core structures suggested that the A epitope expressed on pig ischiadicus nerves is based on the type 1 core chain structure. Light and electron microscopical studies on the alphaGal and HD-antigen distribution revealed that the neural cells were alphaGal antigen negative. Endothelial cells of blood vessels, and lymphatic and perineural cells expressed alphaGal antigen. Both endothelial cells and myelinized axons revealed positively labelled for the HD antigen.

The Galalpha1-3Gal (alphaGal) antigen is considered the main xenoantigen in the pig to human species combination but other porcine antigens have to be considered such as the swine lymphocyte antigen (SLA), the blood group A/O and the Hanganutziu-Deicher (H-D) antigens. The H-D antigens are N-glycolyl-neuraminic acid (NeuGc) terminated gangliosides that are widely distributed in mammalian species but absent in humans. Upon exposure to a vascularized pig organ, the human recipient can be immunized by direct interaction with the pig tissue or/and by transfer of tissue/cells from the organ into the recipient. In the present work, we describe the release of cells from porcine kidneys upon perfusion and the expression of glycolipid based alphaGal, blood group A/O and H-D antigens in pig lymphocytes. Pig kidneys were flushed with 20 ml of NaCl or Lidocain containing 5000 U heparin, and thereafter perfused with 3000-ml perfusion solution and the cells released were counted and examined microscopically. Neutral glycolipid and ganglioside fractions were extracted from purified pig lymphocytes. The extracted components were characterized by thin layer chromatography, degradation and mass spectrometry. The expression of alphaGal and H-D epitopes on cells released from pig kidneys and purified pig lymphocytes were studied by immune electron microscopy. A total amount of about 300 x 106 leukocytes, mainly lymphocytes were released in the perfusate from the kidneys, of which about 100 x 106 cells were eluated in the 600 to 2400 ml perfusate fraction. Immunelectron microscopical analysis with Griffonia simplicifolia isolectin B4 showed staining of pig leukocytes and other cells, morphologically similar to endothelial cells, released in the perfusate. The purified porcine lymphocytes contained 930 microg neutral glycolipid (4.2 microg/mg cell protein) of which 95% was glycolipids with one to four sugar residues. Immunostaining of the neutral glycolipid fractions revealed alphaGal terminated compounds migrating in the five and 10 to 12 sugar regions and blood group A compounds in the six and eight sugar regions. Two major gangliosides NeuGc-GM3 and NeuGc-GD3 were found in the pig lymphocytes. In a patient extracorporeally xenoperfused with a pig kidney, an increased staining of both alphaGal terminated structures as well as the H-D reactive gangliosides were found in the post-perfusion serum samples. In summary, leukocytes, mainly lymphocytes are released from pig kidneys during perfusion which may contribute to immunization of human xenograft recipients.

The significance of non-alphagalactosyl antigens remains unclear in pig-to-primate xenotransplantation. Hanganutziu-Deicher (H-D) antigens with terminal N-glycolylneuraminic acid (NeuGc) are widely expressed on endothelial cells of mammalian species, with the exception of humans. As baboons and monkeys also express H-D antigens, a pig-to-non-human primate experimental model cannot resolve the question of whether H-D antigens can elicit a potent humoral response in human recipients. The purpose of this study was to elucidate the clinical significance of H-D antigens by examining the sera from patients who have been previously exposed to porcine tissue. After the digestion of porcine aortic endothelial cells (PAEC) by neuraminidase, NeuGc and N-acetylneuraminic acid (NeuAc) were quantitated by HPLC. IgG and IgM antibody levels against H-D antigens were measured by NeuGc-GM3-coated ELISA plates in the sera of patients who had undergone ex vivo kidney perfusion 1 to 3 weeks and 2 years previously (n=2) or had been injected with fetal porcine islets 2 months previously (n= 10). HPLC determined that 9.7x 10(7) NeuAc and 6.3x 10(7) NeuGc residues per cell were released from PAEC by neuraminidase, while 25.7x 10(7) NeuAc and an undetectable level of NeuGc were released from human aortic endothelial cells (HAEC). No significant elevation of IgG or IgM antibody levels against NeuGc-GM3 was observed in sera from patients with a history of porcine exposure. Considering the active production of antibody against the foreign galactosyl antigens after pig-to-human xenotransplantation, some production of antibodies against the equally foreign H-D antigens would be expected, because large amounts of NeuGc terminated saccharides are present in the pig endothelial cell surface. However, no production of antibodies directed to H-D antigens could be found in patients exposed to porcine tissue. Further studies are warranted to explain why H-D antigens do not elicit a significant antibody production.

The complement system is one of the important factors involved in the hyperacute rejection of xenografts. This report deals with the activation of the complement system in a clinical trial where pig kidneys were extracorporeally connected to two volunteer dialysis patients who were pretreated with plasmapheresis in order to substantially reduce anti-pig xenoantibodies. The clinical data of the perfusion experiments and the patients humoral immune response to pig xenoantigens have been reported in detail (Xenotransplantation 1996; 3:328-339, 340-353). Three consecutive daily plasmapheresis treatments of the patients reduced the plasma complement protein (C3, C4, and C5) concentrations to 8-27% of the baseline values. The perfusion of the pig kidney connected to patient 1 was terminated at 65 min due to graft rejection and this patient was not hemodynamically affected by the experiment. The second experiment was terminated at 15 min due to an anaphylactic like reaction of the patient. In patient 1 a slight reduction of plasma C3, C4, and C5 and an increase of C5a and SC5b-9 occurred, while C3a decreased during the perfusion. Patient 2 had an increase of all complement parameters, most prominent for C4d and SC5b-9, which occurred concomitant with the appearance of the anaphylactic like side effects. In general, plasma levels of PMN elastase, IL6 and IL8 increased in both patients during the perfusion. Immunohistochemical investigation of the kidney tissues revealed deposition of human complement factors C1q, C4c, and C3c in a congruent pattern with the vasculature of the kidney in patient 1. In kidney 2 only trace amounts of C1q and C3c were found. Both kidneys were negative for properdin. Therefore, in this experimental set up with extracorporeal connection of pig kidneys to the human circulation the human complement cascade is activated mainly through the classical pathway.

A quantitative ELISA technique for determination of human anti-pig xenoantibody number in serum samples has been established using pig lymphocytes and pig/rabbit erythrocytes as target cells and a pool of serum from human blood group AB donors. The number of low affinity antibodies binding to the cells was determined by quantitation following the use of aqueous washing of the cells and separation of bound and unbound antibodies with the phthalate oil method. The efficiency of different soluble Gal(alpha)1-3Gal-terminating di- and tri-saccharides to inhibit antibody binding was tested and found to vary between 70-90% at a saccharide concentration of 10 mg/ml. The assay was used to evaluate the antibody changes in two patients who, after plasmapheresis treatments, had pig kidneys extracorporeally connected to their blood circulation. The number of anti-pig IgM/IgG antibodies bound to each pig lymphocyte were reduced from 5,600/13,200 to 1,300/3,100 in patient 1 and from 1,200/6,500 to 500/2,100 in patient 2 by three consecutive daily plasmapheresis treatments. Although the lymphocytotoxic titers were reduced to very low levels, the antibody numbers still present in the blood of patient 1 caused a hyperacute rejection of the pig kidney. However, the antibody levels in patient 2 did not cause rejection of this kidney during 15 min perfusion time. A strong anti-pig antibody response 3 weeks after the perfusion experiment was found in patient 1 as shown by 27,600/245,300 IgM/IgG molecules bound to pig lymphocytes corresponding to an increase of lymphocytotoxic titer from 8 to 512. The second patient showed a much weaker immune response with 1,400/19,800 IgM/IgG antibodies corresponding to a lymphocytotoxic titer increase from 8 to 32. The use of this quantitation technique enables more accurate investigation of antibody binding to xenogenic target cells than conventional titration techniques.

Currently, the pig species is regarded as the most likely organ donor for human xenotransplantation in the future. However, it cannot be granted that the pig will be the optimal species of choice. We have studied human anti-sheep antibodies in comparison with anti-pig antibodies. The anti-sheep lymphocytotoxic and hemagglutination titers were in the range 8 to 128 and 2 to 32, respectively, in single individuals, which were considerably lower than the anti-pig titers of these individuals. Perfusion of sheep kidneys with human blood reduced the anti-sheep xenoantibody titers to zero as measured by lymphocytotoxic, hemagglutination, and sheep aortic endothelial cell antibody binding assays. The perfused kidneys showed generalised depositions of human IgM and C3c in the vascular tree and focal depositions of C1q and fibrin. Obliteration of capillaries by human platelets and polymorphonuclear cells were observed. Total neutral glycolipid fractions were isolated from sheep intestinal, pancreatic, and kidney tissues. By using a chromatogram binding assay, a monoclonal anti-Forssman antibody identified a single compound with five sugar residues in all organs. Several glycolipid bands were stained in all organs by the Gal(alpha)1-specific lectin I-B4 from Griffonia (Bandeiraea) Simplicifolia. A human AB serum pool showed staining by both IgG and IgM antibodies of the Forssman and Gal(alpha)1-terminating components as well as some other, not structurally identified, components. The Forssman and Gal(alpha)1-reactivity in human sera could be eliminated by immunoadsorption using Forssman and Gal(alpha)1-3Gal-immunoadsorbent columns, respectively. Immunostaining of sheep kidney tissue sections showed the presence of Gal(alpha)1-terminating epitopes by immunoperoxidase and immunogold silver staining techniques. Proximal convoluted tubules showed a strong staining, while thin loops of Henle, collecting ducts, urothelium, and vessels showed a weaker staining. Distal convoluted tubules and thick loops of Henle were completely negative. In summary, human serum contains anti-sheep xenoantibodies reacting mainly with the Forssman and Gal(alpha)1-determinants in sheep tissues and the anti-sheep antibody titers are lower than the corresponding anti-pig titers.

The pioneering experiment by Welsh et al. (Immunological Lett 1991:29:167-170) connecting a pig kidney to the human circulation has been repeated in a modified manner. Two volunteer dialysis patients were pretreated by daily plasmapheresis on days -2,-1, and 0 to remove the naturally occurring anti-pig xenoantibodies. The anti-pig lymphocytotoxic liters were reduced from 1:8 to 1:2 in patient 1 and from 1:8 to 1:1 in patient 2. No steroids or immunosuppressive drugs were administrated before or during the experiments. A sterile pig kidney was extracorporeally ("ex vivo") connected to the patients a/v fistula using an arterial and a venous pump similar to a dialysis. The two experiments gave different results. In the first experiment the perfusion pressure was kept at 100 mmHg for the initial 25 min by reducing the pump speed until the minimum blood flow of 30 ml/min was reached. Thereafter, the pressure rose continuously and the experiment was terminated at 65 min at a perfusion pressure of 200 mmHg. The patient did not feel any discomfort during the perfusion. In the second experiment, a stable blood flow of 200 ml/min was reached at a pressure of 100 mmHg after a few minutes. The perfusion was terminated at 15 min when the patient developed chest and abdominal pain, hypotension, and electrocardiographic signs of myocardial ischemia. The patient recovered quickly. In the first experiment, small volumes of clear urine was produced until the pressure rose above 100 mmHg, which resulted in hematuria. In the second experiment clear urine (4 ml/min) was produced. (51)Chromium clearance values were after 15 min <1 ml/min for kidney 1 and 12 ml/min (8 ml/min/100 g) for kidney 2. A drastic reduction in platelet count (128 to 48 and 64 to 8 × 10(9)/1, respectively) during the passage through the kidney was found in blood samples collected simultaneously before and after the organ. No change in hemoglobin values and leucocyte counts were found. Light- and electron-microscopical analysis of the kidney tissues revealed for kidney 1 focal areas with obliteration of the glomerular and peritubular capillaries by platelets and PMN cells and severe damage of the endothelial cells comparable to a picture of a hyperacute rejection. In kidney 2, all vessels were patent but in the capillaries large amount of membrane fragments were detected by electron microscopy and a discrete damage of the endothelial cells were seen in some segments. No intact platelets were present in the vascular tree. These human experiments support the hypothesis that hyperacute rejection of pig to human xenografts is delayed in time by removal of the preformed anti-pig xenoantibodies. A new finding was a very rapid destruction of platelets occurring in the kidney of patient 2 who had very low liters of xenoantibodies. The humoral immune response is described in detail in an accompanying paper (Rydberg et al., this issue)., (© 1996 Munksgaard.)

Pig kidneys were extracorporeally "ex vivo" connected to the circulation of two volunteer male dialysis patients (Breimer et al., this issue). The patients were pretreated by daily plasmapheresis for 3 consecutive days, which reduced the anti-pig lymphocytotoxic titer from 8 to 2 in the first patient and from 8 to 1 in the second patient. The anti-pig hemagglutinating titers were reduced from 32 to 4 in the first patient and from 2 to 1 in the second patient. No drugs, except heparin, were given. The perfusion lasted for 65 min in patient 1 and the experiment was terminated due to increased vascular resistance in the pig kidney. Ultrastructural investigation showed a picture similar to a hyperacute vascular rejection. Immunohistochemical studies showed a weak staining of IgM antibodies, but no IgG in the small arteries and glomeruli. The pig kidney of patient 2 was perfused for 15 min and the experiment terminated due to serious side effects of the patient. Light and electron microscopical investigation showed virtually no structural changes of the kidney tissue and immunostaining for human antibodies was negative. In both patients, serum samples collected 2-5 weeks postperfusion showed a strong anti-pig antibody titer rise (up to 512) which thereafter declined but stabilized on a higher level than before the experiment. The antibody response in the two patients was different. In patient 1, the major anti-pig antibodies directed to carbohydrate antigens were of IgG (IgG1 and IgG2 subclasses) type, while the IgM response was less prominent and virtually no IgA antibodies were produced. Despite the short duration of the perfusion in patient 2, a humoral immune response was seen that was mainly confined to the IgA immunoglobulin class (IgA1 subclass). Blood group glycospingolipid fractions, prepared from the contralateral kidney of the donor pigs, were used for immunostaining with patient serum samples. In both patients, the antibodies produced after the perfusion, mainly recognized the Galα1-3Gal epitope both as part of the "linear B" pentasaccharide but also on more complex carbohydrate structures. Patient 1 was HLA-immunized before the experiment due to a kidney allograft and had a panel reactivity of 85% before the perfusion. No change in the panel reactivity of HLA-antibodies was found after the perfusion experiments. Patient 2 had no HLA antibodies before and remained negative after the perfusion. Patient serum samples collected before and after the perfusion were tested for reactivity against human endothelial cell lines. No antibodies were generated., (© 1996 Munksgaard.)