Search

A new and very promising approach in vaccine development is the application of naked DNA. In comparison to conventional vaccines it offers several advantages, especially if there is a need for the development of low cost vaccines. Infection with high-risk human papillomaviruses (hr-HPVs) is the major risk factor for the development of cervical cancer (cc), the third most common cancer in women worldwide. The HPV E7 oncogene is constitutively expressed in HPV-infected cells and represents an excellent target for immune therapy of HPV-related disease. Therefore, we chose the HPV-16 E7 as model antigen in the development of a therapeutic DNA vaccine candidate. For safety reasons the use of a transforming gene like the HPV-16 E7 for DNA vaccination is not feasible in humans. In consequence we have generated an artificial ("shuffled") HPV-16 E7-gene (HPV-16 E7SH), containing all putative cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTLs) epitopes and exhibiting high safety features. Here, we show the induction of a strong E7-wildtype (E7WT) directed cellular and humoral immune response including tumor protection and regression after in vivo immunization in the murine system. Moreover, the vaccine candidate demonstrated immunogenicity in humans, demonstrated by priming of antigen-specific T cells in vitro. Importantly, the artificial HPV-gene has completely lost its transforming properties as measured in soft agar transformation assays. These results may be of importance for the development of vaccines based on oncogenes or oncoproteins.

Immunization with a codon-optimized HPV 16 E7 gene was shown to yield higher levels of E7-specific cytotoxic T cells [Liu WJ, Gao F, Zhao KN, Zhao W, Fernando GJ, Thomas R, et al. Codon modified human papillomavirus type 16 E7 DNA vaccine enhances cytotoxic T-lymphocyte induction and anti-tumour activity. Virology 2002;301:43]. Here, we sought to verify the hypothesis that there is a direct correlation between the level of protein expression and immunogenicity in mice. We generated HPV 16 E7 expression plasmids where the genes were inserted either as authentic sequence (wt) or after optimizing the codons for use in mammalian cells (opt). For enhancement of translation of the E7 gene a 5' Kozak sequence (K) was added. Transfection experiments revealed the strength of expression in the order of E7opt+K, E7opt-K, E7wt+K and E7wt-K. After immunization of C57/B6 mice we observed an equally strong CD8+T-cell response with the E7opt plasmids (+ or -K), followed by the E7wt+K and E7wt-K DNAs. The same difference in efficiency was obtained in tumor protection experiments. Regression of pre-existing tumors and CTL activity was observed only with the E7opt+K plasmid. From these data, we conclude that the level of protein expression correlates with the efficiency of CTL response and hence testing by transfection of cells in culture may allow a pre-selection of expression plasmids prior to DNA immunization.

Vaccination with oncogene-derived DNA for anti-cancer treatment carries a risk of de-novo tumor induction triggered by the persisting recombinant DNA. We hypothesized that an oncoprotein whose primary sequence has been rearranged (‘shuffled’) to maintain all possible T cell epitopes still induces cytotoxic T cells against the authentic protein but is devoid of transforming properties. As a model antigen, we used the E7 oncoprotein of the human papillomavirus (HPV) type 16, the major cause of cervical cancer. We have generated an artificial E7 molecule in which four domains were rearranged and, in order to maintain all possible T cell epitopes, certain sequences were duplicated. Upon transfection of this shuffled E7 gene (E7SH) into RMA cells, presentation of an E7 Db-restricted T cell epitope was shown by an E7-specific CTL line in vitro. Immunization of C57BL/6 mice with E7SH DNA induced E7-specific CTL and also conveyed protection against E7-positive syngeneic tumor cells. No transforming activity of E7SH DNA in NIH3T3 cells was detected, as determined by focus formation, induction of S-phase under conditions of serum deprivation and degradation of endogenous pRB. Our results suggest that DNA shuffling may become a promising concept for DNA-based anti-cancer vaccines.