Search

Understanding the complex interaction between gametes or embryos and the maternal genital tract requires the use of experimental models. The selection of the right model is an important task to undertake, and despite many new developments in this area, an ideal model system has not yet been developed. In this review article, we focus on how the most appropriate model species and model system can be selected, each with its particular advantages and disadvantages. Selection criteria need to be based on the evaluation of the aim of the experiment, the tools that are available to the scientist, and the ethics that are involved in working with particular animal species and model systems. Society and politics direct scientists to "Refine, Reduce, and Replace" the use of experimental animals, which means that the use of in vivo models is increasingly being discouraged. An in vivo model allows experimentation in the full biological environment of a living organism. In contrast with in vivo models, in vitro models are less complex and are abstracts of in vivo systems, leading often to results that are different from the in vivo situation. If an investigator could understand all the components of a complex biological system and re-create them as individual smaller models in a computer, he or she could create in silico models that would completely represent the complexity of in vivo models. We predict that in the future, in silico modeling will be the natural departure from in vivo, in situ, and in vitro modeling approaches. In addition to numerous advantages that this modeling approach can bring to studying maternal interaction with gametes and embryo, it is perhaps the only true alternative method to animal experimentation., (2010 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)

Aim of our study was to clarify if the occurrence of apoptosis in oocytes and cumulus cells is correlated to bovine oocyte developmental competence. The cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs) were selected according to cumulus status: G1 with more than five layers of compact cumulus cells, G2 with one to five layers of compact cumulus cells and G3 with expanded cumulus cells. The degree of apoptosis in cumulus cells and oocytes measured by caspase staining and TUNEL assay before and after maturation, and 24 h post-insemination was compared to the cleavage, blastocyst formation and hatching rates of each group. Highest cleavage, blastocyst and hatching rates were found in cumulus-oocyte complexes with more than five layers of compact cumulus cells, but no apoptosis was detected in immature or in vitro matured oocytes, regardless of the cumulus status. Many cumulus cells contained active caspases before maturation, but caspase activity declined dramatically after maturation. TUNEL positive cells were rarely observed in each cumulus-oocyte complex upon oocyte recovery, but a huge increase of them was seen after in vitro maturation. Significantly more TUNEL and caspase positive cells were found in G2 cumulus-oocyte complexes. Our results suggest that: (i) oocyte apoptosis does not account for the inferior oocyte quality of G2 and G3; (ii) apoptosis occurs in cumulus cells regardless of the number and compactness of cumulus cells; and (iii) the degree of apoptosis in the compact cumulus-oocyte complexes (G1 and G2) is negatively correlated to the developmental competence of oocyte.

Various oxygen tensions are employed for in vitro embryo production. Since it is known that oxygen tension can influence the efficiency of embryo production and embryo quality, the aim of our study was to define an optimal oxygen concentration for bovine embryo production in vitro in synthetic oviduct fluid (SOF). Embryo quality criteria were hatching ability and the degree of apoptosis as assessed by TUNEL staining and Bax gene expression. In Experiment 1, the effects of 2, 5 and 20% O(2) tensions on embryo development were compared. The highest rate of eight-cell embryos (47%) at 72 hpi was obtained under 20% O(2). However, it seemed that 2 and 5% O(2) were also suitable as assessed by embryo survival rates at 144 hpi (29 and 30% at morula stage), 168 hpi (21 and 19% at blastocyst stage) and 216 hpi (14 and 17% at hatched blastocyst stage). In Experiment 2, comparisons were made between effects of 5, 20% and alternating O(2) (20% O(2) to 72 hpi and then changed to 5% O(2) up to 216 hpi) on embryo development. Alternating the O(2) tension significantly reduced the number of hatching blastocysts to 7%. Staining with TUNEL revealed that apoptosis occurred in all tested hatched blastocysts, but a significantly lower apoptotic cell ratio was found in embryos cultured under 5% O(2) (P<0.05). Total cell number of embryos cultured under 5% and alternating oxygen was significantly higher than that of other groups (P<0.05). Bax gene expression was detected by means of RT-PCR in only 2 of 66 hatched blastocysts. It can be concluded that 5% oxygen is optimal for bovine embryo culture in cell free media. Moreover, it is very likely that the apoptosis detected by TUNEL staining in this study is Bax-independent.

Supraphysiological oxygen tension during embryo culture can generate reactive oxygen species (ROS), which can induce apoptosis. Antioxidants such as thiol compounds (cysteine, cysteamine) can be used to prevent ROS damage to the embryo. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the prevalence of apoptosis during bovine embryo development and to evaluate the effect of the presence or absence of cysteine 0.6 mM in modified synthetic oviduct fluid (mSOF) on in vitro produced cattle embryos cultured under two different oxygen tensions (5% O2 versus 20% O2). Effects were assessed by checking embryo development at Days 7, 8 and 9 and by evaluating Day 9 hatched blastocysts for differentiation by means of differential staining and for apoptosis by means of TUNEL-assay. Apoptotic cells were present in 94% of Day 7 blastocysts and in 100% of Days 8 and 9 blastocysts. Cysteine addition affected Day 8 blastocyst rates in a negative way (P < 0.05) regardless of the oxygen tension. In fact, cysteine addition to the mSOF culture medium had a negative effect upon embryo development in terms of blastocyst rates, hatching rates and apoptotic cell ratio. Embryos cultured under 5% O2 in the presence of cysteine, however, possessed significantly higher numbers of ICM cells. This finding corroborates the theoretical assumption that antioxidants are beneficial for ICM development.