1. Value-addition of lateral cephalometric radiographs in orthodontic diagnosis and treatment planning
- Author
-
Anjali Dinesh, Sunil Mutalik, Aditya Tadinada, and Jonathan Feldman
- Subjects
Orthodontics ,business.industry ,Radiography ,Original Articles ,030206 dentistry ,03 medical and health sciences ,Inter-rater reliability ,0302 clinical medicine ,Cronbach's alpha ,030220 oncology & carcinogenesis ,Medicine ,business ,Radiation treatment planning ,Kappa ,Pediatric population ,Dental malocclusion - Abstract
Objective To investigate the value-addition of obtaining lateral cephalometric radiographs during the treatment planning phase of orthodontic treatment. Materials and Methods The records of 100 orthodontic patients were presented to seven scorers during two phases that were 6 weeks apart. In the first phase, scorers completed a seven-question survey with questions regarding treatment planning. They were given various diagnostic records that did not include a lateral cephalometric radiograph. Six weeks later, the same scorers completed the same survey for the same patient cases with the same diagnostic records that additionally included a lateral cephalometric radiograph. Correlation coefficients were used to calculate intrarater agreement and inter-rater agreement within the study. Results Cohen's kappa values showed moderate to almost perfect agreement for the majority of survey questions. Intrarater agreement ranged between 0.430 and 1. Cronbach's alpha reliability statistics showed good interrater agreement for all questions in the survey. Agreement ranged from 0.710 to 0.913 across the survey questions. Diagnosing Angle classification of occlusion had the highest level of agreement and differentiating between skeletal and dental malocclusion had the lowest level of agreement. Conclusions The lateral cephalometric radiograph is not a necessary diagnostic tool for most cases in orthodontic diagnosis and treatment planning. Weighing the usefulness of a lateral cephalometric on a case-by-case basis should be recommended to align with the principle of ALARA (as low as reasonably achievable), especially in a primarily pediatric population.
- Published
- 2020