1. Lower-class origin professionals in Canadian health and social service professions: "A different level of understanding".
- Author
-
Beagan, Brenda L., MacLeod, Anna, Owen, Michelle, Pride, Tara M., and Sibbald, Kaitlin R.
- Subjects
- *
SOCIAL capital , *PSYCHOLOGY of physicians , *OCCUPATIONAL therapy education , *MEDICAL personnel , *QUALITATIVE research , *SOCIAL workers , *PROFESSIONAL ethics , *SOCIAL justice , *MEDICAL education , *MEDICAL care , *SOCIAL services , *CULTURE , *INTERVIEWING , *OCCUPATIONAL therapists , *SOCIAL work education , *NURSING education , *EXPERIENCE , *CLIENT relations , *ATTITUDES of medical personnel , *PATIENT-professional relations , *PSYCHOSOCIAL factors , *SOCIAL classes , *PSYCHOLOGY of nurses - Abstract
As health and social service professions increasingly emphasize commitments to equity, advocacy and social justice, non-traditional entrants to the professions increasingly bring much-needed diversity of social backgrounds and locations. Long the domain of elite social classes, the professions are not always welcoming cultures for those from lower social class backgrounds. This paper draws on notions of material, social and cultural capital, along with habitus , to examine the experiences of professionals with lower-class backgrounds, in educational programs and in their professions. The critical interpretive qualitative study draws on interviews with 27 professionals across Canada in medicine, nursing, social work and occupational therapy. While participants were clearly set apart from their colleagues by class origins, which posed distinct struggles, they also brought valuable assets to their work: enhanced connection and rapport with clients/patients, approachability, structural analysis and advocacy, plus nuanced re-envisioning of professional ethics to minimize power dichotomies. Rather than helping lower-class entrants adapt to the professions, it may be more beneficial to alter normative professional cultures to better suit these practitioners. • People from lower-class backgrounds may struggle in the professions. • The material, social and cultural capitals expected cast them as cultural outsiders. • They may more readily enact the social justice and equity aims of the professions. • We need transformational change to professional cultures of elitism and exclusion. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF