Search

A retrospective study was carried out on a series of 154 patients affected with vocal cord cancer in stage T1 treated with definitive radiotherapy April, 1979, to November, 1991. According to the 1992 TNM classification (UICC), 121 patients were classified as stage T1a and 33 patients as stage T1b. All patients were treated using parallel opposed fields of a 60 cobalt unit. Field size ranged from 16 to 30 square centimeters and the dose from 4400 to 7000 cGy, but only 15 patients received less than 6400 cGy. All patients were treated with once-daily fractionation (200 cGy/day). Follow-up ranges from 25 to 123 months; the median is 63 months. We observed 14 local recurrences (9.0%), all but one within 36 months from the end of treatment. Ten of 14 patients (71.4%) were rescued by surgery (8 patients underwent total laryngectomy and 2 conservative surgery); 13 patients were lost for intercurrent deaths. The incidence of recurrences is 7.4% for T1a patients (9/121) and 15.1% for T1b patients (5/33). The total dose does not seem to be related to relapse rate since recurrences were found in 6.6% of patients after a dose < 6400 cGy and in 9.3% of patients who had received higher doses. In our experience, field size did not affect, treatment results (< 25 cm2: 7.5% recurrences, > 25 cm2: 10.7%). Besides lesion volume, the main prognostic factor was overall treatment time. The incidence of failure was 3 times lower (5.8%) in the patients who completed the treatment within 7 weeks than in the patients whose treatment lasted more than 8 weeks (16.6%).

From 1981 to 1991, fifty-three patients with primary gastric lymphoma were referred to our Institute and submitted to a complete pathologic staging followed by gastric resection, i.e., total or partial gastrectomy. According to the Working Formulation criteria, 14 patients (26.4%) were affected with high grade lymphomas, 22 (41.5%) with intermediate lymphomas and 17 (32.1%) with low grade lymphomas. MALT (mucosa associated lymphoid tissue) lymphomas were observed in > 50% of cases. At the pathologic examination of the surgical specimens, infiltration depth was assessed, according to TNM criteria, in the patients whose disease was limited to the muscular gastric wall (T1-T2) and in those whose disease spread to the serosa or beyond it (T3-T4). Twenty-five patients were classified as stage I and 28 as stage II (9 of them in stage II E1 and 19 in stage II E2 according to Musshoff's classification). The treatment protocol of these patients was as follows: stage I patients (T1-T2) with normal surgical resection margins underwent no adjuvant treatment (10 patients); stage I patients (T1-T2) with resection margins infiltrated by the disease were submitted to local irradiation; stage I (T3-T4) and stage II E1 patients underwent large-field postoperative irradiation (14 patients); stage II E2 patients (n = 19) received conventional chemotherapy (CHOP, F-CVP, N-CVP): the ones who failed to reach complete remission or presented with bulky disease at diagnosis completed the treatment with large-field irradiation (10 patients). The disease-free survival (86.5%) and the overall survival (96%) rates of stage I patients exhibited no significant difference relative to stage II patients (DFS: 87% and OS: 90%). The analysis of relapses relative to disease extent demonstrated that this parameter is more significant to prognosis than nodal involvement (T1-T2: 2/39 relapses, 5.1%; T3-T4: 4/14 relapses, 28.6%).

The control of early glottic cancer is equally satisfactory with either surgical resection or radiation therapy; this last method gives the patient good functional results. During the period from 1/1978 to 12/1985, 73 patients with early glottic carcinoma (T1 N0 M0) were treated in the Institute of Radiotherapy L. Galvani, University of Bologna; 45 were stage T1a (tumour limited to one vocal cord) and 28 were stage T1b (tumour of both vocal cords or involving anterior commissure); radiation treatment utilised a 60Co machine and 5 x 5 cm fields; the median dose was 67.2 Gy (range 50-76) with conventional fractionation. Ten patients had local recurrence; the median time of recurrence was 13.4 months; 9/10 were treated by surgery and 2/10 died, so the overall control by radiotherapy with surgery in reserve was 100% in T1a tumours and 90.6% in T1b ones. The 5-years disease free survival rate was 93.1% in T1a tumours and 69% in T1b; lesions involving anterior commissure had the worst prognosis, independent of the dose and time-dose factor (3/10 recurrences in the group treated with TDF less than 110 and 4/18 recurrences in the group with TDF more than 110).

The results of megavoltage irradiation at different doses in 188 patients with carcinoma of the nasopharynx treated at the Institute of Radiotherapy "L. Galvani", University of Bologna, from 1960 to 1978, are analyzed. Dose-control relationship is investigated. The incidence of failures at the primary site and in the neck is a function of dose and neoplastic volume: 5,000 rad/5 weeks for sub-clinical disease and 7,000 rad/7 weeks for massive disease appears to eradicate the tumor in a high number of cases. Prognosis of patients with extensive disease in the neck is nevertheless unfavourable, since a great number of them dies for distant metastases. It seems therefore necessary to institute clinical trials testing adjuvant chemotherapy in patients with neck stages N2-N3.

The incidence of pathological neck nodes metastases in a group of 60 patients with a diagnosis of oral squamous carcinoma is reviewed. Risk factors are a size of primary more than 4 cm and tumors of the anterior two-third of the tongue. Carcinomas of oral tongue, also of a size less than 4 cm (T1,T2), have a high incidence of subclinical metastases.

The combination of radiotherapy and surgery in the treatment of advanced oral carcinoma (T3 and T4 lesions) yields good possibilities of recovery; whether radiotherapy should be given before or after surgery is still debated. Fifty patients with advanced oral carcinomas were analyzed: 24 of them were irradiated before and 26 after surgery; doses ranged from 40 to 56 Gy for the first group of patients, and from 50 to 68 Gy for the second one. The disease-free survival 48 months after the diagnosis was 36% in patients who received preoperative irradiation, and 53.6% in patients who received postoperative radiotherapy; the latter allowed local control of the disease to be significantly improved (chi 2 3.99, 0.01 less than p less than 0.05). The quality of survival was worse in the group receiving preoperative irradiation, because of radiation-induced surgical complications, which were especially observed in patients with diffuse disease. Our findings suggest that postoperative radiotherapy may be advisable if the tumor is resectable, since tolerance and local control rate were acceptable. On the contrary, nearly inoperable masses and massive neck diseases often require preoperative irradiation.

A series of 106 patients affected with nasopharyngeal carcinomas and treated by definitive external irradiation from January 1975 to December 1986 was retrospectively reviewed. The median follow-up, from the end of the treatment, was 43 months (range 24-90). The nasopharynx received not less than 60 Gy to the midplane: the clinically negative neck (N0) was treated with a total dose of 50 Gy and the patients who had N1-3 disease received not less than 60 Gy. Thirty-eight patients had a recurrence in the irradiated areas (31 in the nasopharynx, and 7 in the neck); 17 patients developed distant metastases. Disease-free survival at 60 months was 42%. The most significant prognostic factor (p less than 0.05) was the presence of advanced neck involvement (N2-3), since most of the lymphatic and distant recurrences were observed in this group of patients. The overall results did not reveal but slight differences in the survival according to histology, even though patients with undifferentiated carcinomas had a local recurrence rate significantly lower than those with squamous cell carcinomas. Our findings suggest that patients with N2-3 neck diseases or with locally advanced involvement (T3-4) be treated by adjuvant chemotherapy in order to decrease the risk of local and distant relapses.