51. Diminishing returns from statistical analysis: Detecting discrimination in public employment.
- Author
-
Daniel, Christopher
- Subjects
EMPLOYMENT discrimination ,ASIAN Americans ,ETHNOLOGY ,PUBLIC officers ,PUBLIC administration ,CIVIL service - Abstract
This article comments on the article "Asian Americans in the Public Service: Success, Diversity, and Discrimination," by Pan Suk Kim and Gregory Lewis, published in one of the 1994 issue of the periodical "Public Administration Review," where in the authors noted that Asian Americans experience discrimination within the federal service, suggested that the problem is pervasive and serious and proposed remedies. This writer has personally witnessed at least two incidents of employment discrimination against Asian Americans. Neither of these episodes involved federal personnel, but it seems reasonable that the federal service is not totally immune to prejudices evident elsewhere in society. However, Kim and Lewis's statistics shed little light on such discrimination's pervasiveness. Anti-Asian discrimination may not be as important a federal phenomena as their article concludes. Kim and Lewis's lucidly presented statistics can be interpreted in varying ways. Thee alternative interpretation which follows may also have implications for identification of discrimination against other groups, such as women, Hispanics and African Americans. Using 1990 and 1992 statistics, Kim and Lewis describe differences between Asian Americans and nonminority whites. Asian Americans make up 2.6 percent of the civilian work force but constitute less than 1 percent of municipal officials.
- Published
- 1997
- Full Text
- View/download PDF