Search

The article offers a commentary on the ideas raised by Patchen Markell in his book "Bound by Recognition." The author points out that Markell's book provides a commanding critique of the ontological basis on which much of the debate has rested. He notes that Markell offers a compelling critique of the discourse of recognition in its initial formulation.

Focuses on the influences in the works of political scientist Friedrich Nietzsche. Exploration of Nietzsche's admiration for Thucydides; Nietzsche's reliance upon the artistry of the history for relief from Platonism; Consideration of three key terms in Nietzsche's praise of Thucydides.

Focuses on political scientist Alexis de Tocqueville's works on race and slavery. Analysis of the coexistence of liberal democracy and racism; Examination of Tocqueville's fascination with bourgeois democracy; Tocqueville's claim of the extension of equality.

Examines the relationship between scientific political philosopher David Hume's skepticism and political thought. Hume's understanding of political skepticism; Belief in a life devoted to skeptical philosophy; Hume's political maxims; Efforts to quell party strife; Fondness for liberal commercial republics.

Comments on the role of political scientists in the profession and activities of political actors in the United States. Generation of knowledge for assisting politicians and policymakers; Development of historical institutionalist analyses to provide contexts for choice; Benefits of historical analyses to politicians, policymakers and voters.

Relates an experience of a political scientist involved in formulating a foreign policy in the United States. Participation in the formulation of policies regarding the 1991 Middle East conflict; Discussion on the factors influencing foreign policy making; Suggestion for academics involved in delivering expert opinion or information to policymakers.

Characterizes external public intellectuals in the United States. Relevance and use of political science in society; Analogy between the character of a lion and a political actor; Need for political leaders to develop and sustain intelligence on adequate levels; Description of dissenters; Consideration on political scientists as prophets.

The article comments on a forum about the ideas raised by Patchen Markell in his book "Bound by Recognition." The panel was organized by Antonio Y. Vazquez-Arroyo for the 2004 Annual Meeting of the Northeastern Political Science Association. It is noted that Markell's ideas marked a significant and productive shift in the literature on the politics of recognition.