714 results on '"Humans"'
Search Results
2. Feedback as dialogue for faculty: From peer review to peer‐to‐peer coaching
- Author
-
Margalit, Noam and Pincavage, Amber T
- Subjects
Curriculum and Pedagogy ,Education ,Specialist Studies In Education ,Humans ,Feedback ,Mentoring ,Faculty ,Peer Group ,Peer Review ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics ,Curriculum and pedagogy ,Specialist studies in education - Abstract
Drawing on the themes identified by Watling et al. regarding feedback in peer review, the authors consider how their findings could be applied more broadly to faculty feedback.
- Published
- 2023
3. Exploring how feedback reflects entrustment decisions using artificial intelligence.
- Author
-
Gin, Brian C, Ten Cate, Olle, O'Sullivan, Patricia S, Hauer, Karen E, and Boscardin, Christy
- Subjects
Humans ,Learning ,Competency-Based Education ,Internship and Residency ,Clinical Competence ,Students ,Medical ,Feedback ,Artificial Intelligence ,Clinical Research ,Quality Education ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Education ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics - Abstract
ContextClinical supervisors make judgements about how much to trust learners with critical activities in patient care. Such decisions mediate trainees' opportunities for learning and competency development and thus are a critical component of education. As educators apply entrustment frameworks to assessment, it is important to determine how narrative feedback reflecting entrustment may also address learners' educational needs.MethodsIn this study, we used artificial intelligence (AI) and natural language processing (NLP) to identify characteristics of feedback tied to supervisors' entrustment decisions during direct observation encounters of clerkship medical students (3328 unique observations). Supervisors conducted observations of students and collaborated with them to complete an entrustment-based assessment in which they documented narrative feedback and assigned an entrustment rating. We trained a deep neural network (DNN) to predict entrustment levels from the narrative data and developed an explainable AI protocol to uncover the latent thematic features the DNN used to make its prediction.ResultsWe found that entrustment levels were associated with level of detail (specific steps for performing clinical tasks), feedback type (constructive versus reinforcing) and task type (procedural versus cognitive). In justifying both high and low levels of entrustment, supervisors detailed concrete steps that trainees performed (or did not yet perform) competently.ConclusionsFraming our results in the factors previously identified as influencing entrustment, we find a focus on performance details related to trainees' clinical competency as opposed to nonspecific feedback on trainee qualities. The entrustment framework reflected in feedback appeared to guide specific goal-setting, combined with details necessary to reach those goals. Our NLP methodology can also serve as a starting point for future work on entrustment and feedback as similar assessment datasets accumulate.
- Published
- 2022
4. When I say…attitude.
- Author
-
Valbuena, Gustavo, van der Schaaf, Marieke, O'Sullivan, Patricia, and O'Brien, Bridget
- Subjects
Humans ,Attitude ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Education ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics - Published
- 2021
5. Virtual bedside teaching rounds with patients with COVID‐19
- Author
-
Hofmann, Heather, Harding, Cameron, Youm, Julie, and Wiechmann, Warren
- Subjects
Curriculum and Pedagogy ,Education ,Specialist Studies In Education ,COVID-19 ,Humans ,Pandemics ,SARS-CoV-2 ,Teaching Rounds ,Telemedicine ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics ,Curriculum and pedagogy ,Specialist studies in education - Published
- 2020
6. Professional identity formation in disorienting times
- Author
-
Stetson, Geoffrey V, Kryzhanovskaya, Irina V, Lomen‐Hoerth, Catherine, and Hauer, Karen E
- Subjects
Curriculum and Pedagogy ,Education ,Specialist Studies In Education ,Good Health and Well Being ,COVID-19 ,Humans ,Learning ,Professionalism ,Social Identification ,Students ,Medical ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics ,Curriculum and pedagogy ,Specialist studies in education - Published
- 2020
7. Transformative learning as pedagogy for the health professions: a scoping review
- Author
-
Van Schalkwyk, Susan C, Hafler, Janet, Brewer, Timothy F, Maley, Moira A, Margolis, Carmi, McNamee, Lakshini, Meyer, Ilse, Peluso, Michael J, Schmutz, Ana MS, Spak, Judy M, Davies, David, and Initiative, the Bellagio Global Health Education
- Subjects
Faculty ,Health Occupations ,Humans ,Problem-Based Learning ,Qualitative Research ,Bellagio Global Health Education Initiative ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Education ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics - Abstract
ContextTransformative learning (TL) has been described as learning that challenges established perspectives, leading to new ways of being in the world. As a learning theory it has resonated with educators globally, including those in the health professions. Described as a complex metatheory, TL has evolved over time, eliciting divergent interpretations of the construct. This scoping review provides a comprehensive synthesis of how TL is currently represented in the health professions education literature, including how it influences curricular activities, to inform its future application in the field.MethodsArksey and O'Malley's six-step framework was adopted to review the period from 2006 to May 2018. A total of 10 bibliographic databases were searched, generating 1532 potential studies. After several rounds of review, first of abstracts and then of full texts, 99 studies were mapped by two independent reviewers onto the internally developed data extraction sheet. Descriptive information about included studies was aggregated. Discursive data were subjected to content analysis.ResultsA mix of conceptual and empirical research papers, which used a range of qualitative methodologies, were included. Studies from the USA, the UK and Australia were most prevalent. Insights relating to how opportunities for TL were created, how it manifests and influences behaviour, as well as how it is experienced, demonstrated much congruency. Conceptions of TL were seen to be clustered around the work of key theorists.ConclusionsThe training of health professionals often takes place in unfamiliar settings where students are encouraged to be active participants in providing care. This increases the opportunity for exposure to learning experiences that are potentially transformative, allowing for a pedagogy of uncertainty that acknowledges the complexity of the world we live in and questions what we believe we know about it. TL provides educators in the health professions with a theoretical lens through which they can view such student learning.
- Published
- 2019
8. Chart stalking, list making, and physicians’ efforts to track patients’ outcomes after transitioning responsibility
- Author
-
Bowen, Judith L, O'Brien, Bridget C, Ilgen, Jonathan S, Irby, David M, and Cate, Olle ten
- Subjects
Curriculum and Pedagogy ,Education ,Specialist Studies In Education ,Behavioral and Social Science ,Clinical Research ,Basic Behavioral and Social Science ,Management of diseases and conditions ,7.3 Management and decision making ,Generic health relevance ,Aftercare ,Decision Making ,Electronic Health Records ,Female ,Grounded Theory ,Hospitalists ,Humans ,Internal Medicine ,Interviews as Topic ,Male ,Patient Transfer ,Physicians ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics ,Curriculum and pedagogy ,Specialist studies in education - Abstract
ContextTransitions of patient care responsibility occur frequently between physicians. Resultant discontinuities make it difficult for physicians to observe clinical outcomes. Little is known about what physicians do to overcome the practical challenges to learning these discontinuities create. This study explored physicians' activities in practice as they sought follow-up information about patients.MethodsUsing a constructivist grounded theory approach, semi-structured interviews with 18 internal medicine hospitalist and resident physicians at a single tertiary care academic medical center explored participants' strategies when deliberately conducting follow-up after they transitioned responsibility for patients to other physicians. Following open coding, the authors used activity theory (AT) to explore interactions among the social, cultural and material influences related to follow-up.ResultsThe authors identified three themes related to follow-up: (i) keeping lists to track patients, (ii) learning to create tracking systems and (iii) conducting follow-up. Analysis of participants' follow-up processes as an activity system highlighted key tensions in the system and participants' work adaptations. Tension within functionality of electronic health records for keeping lists (tools) to find information about patients' outcomes (object) resulted in using paper lists as workarounds. Tension between paper lists (tools) and protecting patients' health information (rules) led to rule-breaking or abandoning activities of locating information. Finding time to conduct desired follow-up produced tension between this and other activity systems.ConclusionIn clinical environments characterised by discontinuity, lists of patients served as tools for guiding patient care follow-up. The authors offer four recommendations to address the tensions identified through AT: (i) optimise electronic health record tracking systems to eliminate the need for paper lists; (ii) support physicians' skill development in developing and maintaining tracking systems for follow-up; (iii) dedicate time in physicians' work schedules for conducting follow-up; and (iv) engage physicians and patients in determining guidelines for longitudinal tracking that optimise physicians' learning and respect patients' privacy.
- Published
- 2018
9. Does source matter? Nurses' and Physicians' perceptions of interprofessional feedback
- Author
-
van Schaik, Sandrijn M, O'Sullivan, Patricia S, Eva, Kevin W, Irby, David M, and Regehr, Glenn
- Subjects
Curriculum and Pedagogy ,Education ,Specialist Studies In Education ,Clinical Research ,Clinical Trials and Supportive Activities ,Attitude of Health Personnel ,Feedback ,Humans ,Internship and Residency ,Interprofessional Relations ,Nurses ,Pediatrics ,Perception ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics ,Curriculum and pedagogy ,Specialist studies in education - Abstract
ObjectiveReceptiveness to interprofessional feedback, which is important for optimal collaboration, may be influenced by 'in-group or out-group' categorisation, as suggested by social identity theory. We used an experimental design to explore how nurses and resident physicians perceive feedback from people within and outside their own professional group.MethodsPaediatric residents and nurses participated in a simulation-based team exercise. Two nurses and two physicians wrote anonymous performance feedback for each participant. Participants each received a survey containing these feedback comments with prompts to rate (i) the usefulness (ii) the positivity and (iii) their agreement with each comment. Half of the participants received feedback labelled with the feedback provider's profession (two comments correctly labelled and two incorrectly labelled). Half received unlabelled feedback and were asked to guess the provider's profession. For each group, we performed separate three-way anovas on usefulness, positivity and agreement ratings to examine interactions between the recipient's profession, actual provider profession and perceived provider profession.ResultsForty-five out of 50 participants completed the survey. There were no significant interactions between profession of the recipient and the actual profession of the feedback provider for any of the 3 variables. Among participants who guessed the source of the feedback, we found significant interactions between the profession of the feedback recipient and the guessed source of the feedback for both usefulness (F1,48 = 25.6; p < 0.001; η(2) = 0.35) and agreement ratings (F1,48 = 8.49; p < 0.01; η(2) = 0.15). Nurses' ratings of feedback they guessed to be from nurses were higher than ratings of feedback they guessed to be from physicians, and vice versa. Among participants who received labelled feedback, we noted a similar interaction between the profession of the feedback recipient and labelled source of feedback for usefulness ratings (F1,92 = 4.72; p < 0.05; η(2) = 0.05).ConclusionOur data suggest that physicians and nurses are more likely to attribute favourably perceived feedback to the in-group than to the out-group. This finding has potential implications for interprofessional feedback practices.
- Published
- 2016
10. Does trainee confidence influence acceptance of feedback?
- Author
-
Curtis, Donald A and O'Sullivan, Patricia
- Subjects
Clinical Clerkship ,Clinical Competence ,Education ,Medical ,Educational Measurement ,Female ,Goals ,Humans ,Male ,Needs Assessment ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Education ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics - Published
- 2014
11. Does student confidence on multiple‐choice question assessments provide useful information?
- Author
-
Curtis, Donald A, Lind, Samuel L, Boscardin, Christy K, and Dellinges, Mark
- Subjects
Curriculum and Pedagogy ,Education ,Specialist Studies In Education ,Attitude of Health Personnel ,Choice Behavior ,Clinical Competence ,Cross-Sectional Studies ,Dental Implantation ,Educational Measurement ,Female ,Humans ,Logistic Models ,Male ,Odds Ratio ,Students ,Dental ,Medical and Health Sciences ,Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Medical Informatics ,Curriculum and pedagogy ,Specialist studies in education - Abstract
ContextFeedback from multiple-choice question (MCQ) assessments is typically limited to a percentage correct score, from which estimates of student competence are inferred. The students' confidence in their answers and the potential impact of incorrect answers on clinical care are seldom recorded. Our purpose was to evaluate student confidence in incorrect responses and to establish how confidence was influenced by the potential clinical impact of answers, question type and gender.MethodsThis was an exploratory, cross-sectional study conducted using a convenience sample of 104 Year 3 dental students completing 20 MCQs on implant dentistry. Students were asked to select the most correct response and to indicate their confidence in it for each question. Identifying both correctness and confidence allowed the designation of uninformed (incorrect and not confident) or misinformed (incorrect but confident) responses. In addition to recording correct/incorrect responses and student confidence, faculty staff designated incorrect responses as benign, inappropriate or potentially harmful if applied to clinical care. Question type was identified as factual or complex. Logistic regression was used to evaluate relationships between student confidence, and question type and gender.ResultsStudents were misinformed more often than uninformed (22% versus 8%), and misinformed responses were more common with complex than factual questions (p
- Published
- 2013
12. Disability inclusion in Medical Education: Towards a quality improvement approach
- Author
-
Siobhan Fitzpatrick and Darryl Barrett
- Subjects
Education, Medical ,Humans ,Disabled Persons ,General Medicine ,Quality Improvement ,Education - Published
- 2022
13. How argumentation theory can inform assessment validity: A critical review
- Author
-
Benjamin Kinnear, Daniel J. Schumacher, Erik W. Driessen, and Lara Varpio
- Subjects
AUDIENCE ,PROGRAMMATIC ASSESSMENT ,IMPACT ,Logic ,SKILLS ,Humans ,General Medicine ,COMPETENCE ,Dissent and Disputes ,VALIDATION ,Problem Solving ,Education - Abstract
Introduction Many health professions education (HPE) scholars frame assessment validity as a form of argumentation in which interpretations and uses of assessment scores must be supported by evidence. However, what are purported to be validity arguments are often merely clusters of evidence without a guiding framework to evaluate, prioritise, or debate their merits. Argumentation theory is a field of study dedicated to understanding the production, analysis, and evaluation of arguments (spoken or written). The aim of this study is to describe argumentation theory, articulating the unique insights it can offer to HPE assessment, and presenting how different argumentation orientations can help reconceptualize the nature of validity in generative ways. Methods The authors followed a five-step critical review process consisting of iterative cycles of focusing, searching, appraising, sampling, and analysing the argumentation theory literature. The authors generated and synthesised a corpus of manuscripts on argumentation orientations deemed to be most applicable to HPE. Results We selected two argumentation orientations that we considered particularly constructive for informing HPE assessment validity: New rhetoric and informal logic. In new rhetoric, the goal of argumentation is to persuade, with a focus on an audience's values and standards. Informal logic centres on identifying, structuring, and evaluating arguments in real-world settings, with a variety of normative standards used to evaluate argument validity. Discussion Both new rhetoric and informal logic provide philosophical, theoretical, or practical groundings that can advance HPE validity argumentation. New rhetoric's foregrounding of audience aligns with HPE's social imperative to be accountable to specific stakeholders such as the public and learners. Informal logic provides tools for identifying and structuring validity arguments for analysis and evaluation.
- Published
- 2022
14. Improving uncertainty tolerance in medical students: A scoping review
- Author
-
Priya Patel, Jason Hancock, Morwenna Rogers, and Samuel R. Pollard
- Subjects
Students, Medical ,Education, Medical ,Uncertainty ,Humans ,Curriculum ,General Medicine ,Delivery of Health Care ,Education - Abstract
Uncertainty is an inevitable part of medical practice. An ability to tolerate uncertainty is viewed as a key competency across many health-care systems. Poor uncertainty tolerance (UT) has been linked to negative outcomes including reduced psychological well-being in medical students. A variety of medical education interventions have been developed with the intention of increasing medical students' UT. However, there is no synthesis of these studies available to inform education and research practice. Our aim was to conduct a scoping review of medical education interventions that evaluate their impact on UT.Medline, PsycInfo, Embase and ERIC databases were searched for articles published from inception to December 2020. An extensive supplementary search was conducted and both quantitative and qualitative evaluations were included. For each intervention, we categorised the stimulus of uncertainty (ambiguity, complexity and/or probability) and mapped the students' reported cognitive, behavioural, and/or emotional response(s) to uncertainty onto an existing conceptual framework.Twenty-two of 24 included studies reported a positive impact on medical student UT in at least one domain (cognitive, behavioural or emotional). Interventions included problem based learning-based curricula, medical humanities, simulation, reflection and assessment. We found in four studies that a negative response in the emotional domain was reported despite positive responses also being reported in the cognitive and/or behavioural domains.We identified a range of medical education interventions which report a positive impact on medical student UT. Further research is required to understand why a single intervention may stimulate a negative emotional response alongside a positive cognitive or behavioural response. In turn, this could support stakeholders such as policymakers and institutions to adapt the medical curriculum to better prepare their medical students for practice by enhancing their UT.
- Published
- 2022
15. Training the clinical eye and mind: using the arts to develop medical students' observational and pattern recognition skills.
- Author
-
Shapiro, Johanna, Rucker, Lloyd, and Beck, Jill
- Subjects
Art ,Clinical Competence: standards ,Education ,Medical ,Undergraduate: methods ,Humans ,Observation: methods ,Pattern Recognition ,Visual ,Students ,Medical: psychology ,Teaching Materials ,article ,clinical competence ,clinical education ,controlled study ,human ,medical decision making ,medical education ,medical student ,pattern recognition ,photography ,skill ,teaching hospital ,Art ,Clinical Competence ,Education ,Medical ,Undergraduate ,Humans ,Observation ,Pattern Recognition ,Visual ,Students ,Medical ,Teaching Materials - Abstract
Observation, including identification of key pieces of data, pattern recognition, and interpretation of significance and meaning, is a key element in medical decision making. Clinical observation is taught primarily through preceptor modelling during the all-important clinical years. No single method exists for communicating these skills, and medical educators have periodically experimented with using arts-based training to hone observational acuity. The purpose of this qualitative study was to better understand the similarities and differences between arts-based and clinical teaching approaches to convey observation and pattern recognition skills.A total of 38 Year 3 students participated in either small group training with clinical photographs and paper cases (group 1), or small group training using art plus dance (group 2), both consisting of 3 2-hour sessions over a 6-month period.Students in both conditions found value in the training they received and, by both self- and instructor-report, appeared to hone observation skills and improve pattern recognition. The clinically based condition appeared to have been particularly successful in conveying pattern recognition concepts to students, probably because patterns presented in this condition had specific correspondence with actual clinical situations, whereas patterns in art could not be generalised so easily to patients. In the arts-based conditions, students also developed skills in emotional recognition, cultivation of empathy, identification of story and narrative, and awareness of multiple perspectives.The interventions studied were naturally complementary and, taken together, can bring greater texture to the process of teaching clinical medicine by helping us see a more complete 'picture' of the patient.
- Published
- 2006
16. Resident doctors' understanding of their roles as clinical teachers.
- Author
-
Morrison, Elizabeth H, Shapiro, Johanna F, and Harthill, Miriam
- Subjects
Attitude of Health Personnel ,Clinical Competence: standards ,Education ,Medical ,Undergraduate: methods ,Humans ,Internship and Residency ,Physician's Role ,Teaching ,clinical education ,interview ,resident ,review ,self concept ,skill ,teaching ,university hospital ,Attitude of Health Personnel ,Clinical Competence ,Education ,Medical ,Undergraduate ,Humans ,Internship and Residency ,Physician's Role ,Teaching - Abstract
Limited data illuminate how resident doctors view their important roles as teachers, supervisors and role models. Analysing qualitative data about resident teachers' self-perceptions can offer helpful insights.One year after a randomised trial of a residents-as-teachers curriculum at a university medical centre, we invited its 23 resident participants to participate in semistructured interviews. We interviewed 21 third year residents from internal medicine, family medicine and paediatrics, including 12 intervention residents who had been randomly assigned to receive a 13-hour teacher training programme and 9 control residents who had received no training. We used grounded theory techniques. Two investigators independently content-analysed the transcribed interviews for emerging themes and we then developed a schema for a third investigator to code the transcripts.Three key themes consistently emerged: enthusiasm for teaching (current and future), learner-centredness, and self-knowledge about teaching. Compared with control residents, the intervention residents expressed greater enthusiasm for teaching, more learner-centred and empathic approaches, and a richer understanding of teaching principles and skills. Most intervention residents wanted to continue teaching during and after training. Fewer control residents enjoyed their current teaching, and fewer still wanted to teach in the future. The control residents seemed easily frustrated by time constraints and they often expressed cynicism and blame toward learners.One year after participating in a randomised trial of a residents-as-teachers curriculum, generalist residents revealed fairly consistent perceptions of their teaching roles. Teacher training may offer residents lasting benefits, including improved teaching skills and satisfaction.
- Published
- 2005
17. All the world's a stage: the use of theatrical performance in medical education.
- Author
-
Shapiro, Johanna and Hunt, Lynn
- Subjects
Attitude of Health Personnel ,Drama ,Education ,Medical ,Undergraduate: methods ,Empathy ,Humans ,acquired immune deficiency syndrome ,article ,community care ,empathy ,experience ,human ,medical education ,medical school ,medical staff ,medical student ,ovary cancer ,performance ,physician attitude ,role playing ,Attitude of Health Personnel ,Drama ,Education ,Medical ,Undergraduate ,Empathy ,Humans - Abstract
Student exposure to illness-related theatrical performances holds intriguing educational possibilities. This project explored uses of theatrical performance within the context of medical education.Two 1-person shows, dramatically addressing AIDS and ovarian cancer, were presented to audiences totalling approximately 150 medical students, faculty, community doctors, staff and patients.Evaluations for both performances indicated increased understanding of the illness experience and greater empathy for patients. They also showed that respondents obtained additional insights into patient care issues, and developed new ways of thinking about their situations.Presenting illness-related dramatic performances as an adjunct method of enhancing empathy and insight toward patients in a self-selected group of students, doctors, staff and patients was successful. Although this approach might not be effective with all learners, those who participated felt they gained important insights into the nature of the patient experience.
- Published
- 2003
18. Primary care resident, faculty, and patient views of barriers to cultural competence, and the skills needed to overcome them.
- Author
-
Shapiro, Johanna, Hollingshead, Judy, and Morrison, Elizabeth H
- Subjects
Clinical Competence: standards ,Communication Barriers ,Cultural Diversity ,Curriculum ,Delivery of Health Care: standards ,Faculty ,Focus Groups: methods ,Humans ,Physician-Patient Relations ,Primary Health Care ,article ,controlled study ,cultural factor ,doctor patient relation ,female ,human ,interpersonal communication ,male ,medical school ,patient ,patient attitude ,physician attitude ,primary medical care ,resident ,social psychology ,socioeconomics ,Clinical Competence ,Communication Barriers ,Cultural Diversity ,Curriculum ,Delivery of Health Care ,Faculty ,Focus Groups ,Humans ,Physician-Patient Relations ,Primary Health Care - Abstract
Primary care residencies are expected to provide training in cultural competence. However, we have insufficient information about the perceptions of stakeholders actually involved in healthcare (i.e. residents, faculty and patients) regarding commonly encountered cross-cultural barriers and the skills required to overcome them.This study used a total of 10 focus groups to explore resident, faculty and patient attitudes and beliefs about what culturally competent doctor-patient communication means, what obstacles impede or prevent culturally competent communication, and what kinds of skills are helpful in achieving cultural competence. A content analysis was performed to identify major themes.Residents and faculty defined culturally competent communication in terms of both generic and culture-specific elements, however, patients tended to emphasize only generic attitudes and skills. Residents and patients were liable to blame each other in explaining barriers; faculty were more likely to consider systemic influences contributing to resident-patient difficulties. All groups emphasized appropriate skill and attitude development in learners as the key to successful communication. However, residents were sceptical of sensitivity and communication skills training, and worried that didactic presentations would result in cultural stereotyping.All stakeholders recognized the importance of effective doctor-patient communication. Of concern was the tendency of various stakeholders to engage in person-blame models.
- Published
- 2002
19. Entrustable professional activities in longitudinal clinical programmes
- Author
-
Linda H. A. Bonnie, General practice, APH - Personalized Medicine, and APH - Quality of Care
- Subjects
Education, Medical, Graduate ,Humans ,Internship and Residency ,General Medicine ,Clinical Competence ,Competency-Based Education ,Education - Published
- 2022
20. Fate and future of the medical students in Ukraine: A silently bubbling educational crisis
- Author
-
Nityanand Jain, Deepkanwar Singh Panag, Mahek Srivastava, Srinithi Mohan, Swarali Yatin Chodnekar, Amir Reza Akbari, Divyam Raj, Dionysia Kravarioti, Dorota Świątek, Emilia Platos, Ketevani Khetsuriani, Kitija Lucija Gristina, Kyriacos Evangelou, Marinela Lica, Revathi Sairaj Thirumushi, Sofia Rozani, Shivani Jain, Pavlo Fedirko, Aigars Reinis, and Mara Pilmane
- Subjects
Students, Medical ,Education, Medical ,Educational Status ,Humans ,General Medicine ,Ukraine ,Education - Published
- 2022
21. Student perspectives on programmatic assessment in a large medical programme: A critical realist analysis
- Author
-
Chris Roberts, Priya Khanna, Jane Bleasel, Stuart Lane, Annette Burgess, Kellie Charles, Rosa Howard, Deborah O'Mara, Inam Haq, and Timothy Rutzou
- Subjects
Humans ,Learning ,Curriculum ,General Medicine ,Students ,Faculty ,Education - Abstract
Fundamental challenges exist in researching complex changes of assessment practice from traditional objective-focused 'assessments of learning' towards programmatic 'assessment for learning'. The latter emphasise both the subjective and social in collective judgements of student progress. Our context was a purposively designed programmatic assessment system implemented in the first year of a new graduate entry curriculum. We applied critical realist perspectives to unpack the underlying causes (mechanisms) that explained student experiences of programmatic assessment, to optimise assessment practice for future iterations.Data came from 14 in-depth focus groups (N = 112/261 students). We applied a critical realist lens drawn from Bhasker's three domains of reality (the actual, empirical and real) and Archer's concept of structure and agency to understand the student experience of programmatic assessment. Analysis involved induction (pattern identification), abduction (theoretical interpretation) and retroduction (causal explanation).As a complex educational and social change, the assessment structures and culture systems within programmatic assessment provided conditions (constraints and enablements) and conditioning (acceptance or rejection of new 'non-traditional' assessment processes) for the actions of agents (students) to exercise their learning choices. The emergent underlying mechanism that most influenced students' experience of programmatic assessment was one of balancing the complex relationships between learner agency, assessment structures and the cultural system.Our study adds to debates on programmatic assessment by emphasising how the achievement of balance between learner agency, structure and culture suggests strategies to underpin sustained changes (elaboration) in assessment practice. These include; faculty and student learning development to promote collective reflexivity and agency, optimising assessment structures by enhancing integration of theory with practice, and changing learning culture by both enhancing existing and developing new social structures between faculty and the student body to gain acceptance and trust related to the new norms, beliefs and behaviours in assessing for and of learning.
- Published
- 2022
22. Maintaining health professional education during war: A scoping review
- Author
-
Valerie A. Dobiesz, Madeline Schwid, Roger D. Dias, Benjamin Aiwonodagbon, Baraa Tayeb, Adrienne Fricke, Phuong Pham, and Timothy B. Erickson
- Subjects
Education, Medical ,Health Personnel ,Humans ,Internship and Residency ,Students, Nursing ,Curriculum ,General Medicine ,Education - Abstract
War negatively impacts health professional education when health care is needed most. The aims of this scoping review are to describe the scope of barriers and targeted interventions to maintaining health professional education during war and summarise the research.We conducted a scoping review between 20 June 2018 and 2 August 2018. The search was restricted to English publications including peer-reviewed publications without date ranges involving war and health professional education (medical school, residency training and nursing school), with interventions described to maintain educational activities. Two independent reviewers completed inclusion determinations and data abstraction. Thematic coding was performed using an inductive approach allowing dominant themes to emerge. The frequency of barrier and intervention themes and illustrative quotes were extracted. Articles were divided into modern/postmodern categories to permit temporal and historical analysis of thematic differences.Screening identified 3271 articles, with 56 studies meeting inclusion criteria. Publication dates ranged from 1914-2018 with 17 unique wars involving 17 countries. The studies concerned medical students (61.4%), residents (28.6%) and nursing students (10%). Half involved the modern era and half the postmodern era. Thematic coding identified five categories of barriers and targeted interventions in maintaining health professions education during war: curriculum, personnel, wellness, resources, and oversight, with most involving curriculum and personnel. The distribution of themes among various health professional trainees was similar. The frequency and specifics changed temporally reflecting innovations in medical education and war, with increased focus on oversight and personnel during the modern era and greater emphasis on wellness, curriculum, and resources during the postmodern era.There are overarching categories of barriers and targeted interventions in maintaining health professional education during war which evolve over time. These may serve as a useful framework to strategically support future research and policy efforts.
- Published
- 2022
23. Preparing for selection success: Socio‐demographic differences in opportunities and obstacles
- Author
-
Dawn Jackson, Derek Ward, Juliana Chizo Agwu, and Austen Spruce
- Subjects
Students, Medical ,Humans ,School Admission Criteria ,General Medicine ,Family Practice ,Students ,Schools, Medical ,Demography ,Education - Abstract
There is a growing drive to improve the heterogeneity of medical school cohorts. However, those from lower socio-economic groups remain under-represented. Understanding the methods used by applicants to prepare for medical school selection, and the challenges they face with respect to opportunities and access, may provide important insights to this lack of diversity. This research considered the influence of socio-demographic background on preparation for medical school selection and on the successful offer of a place.All eligible applicants to a large UK medical school were invited to complete an anonymous online survey (international and mature applicants excluded), detailing demographic data and experiences of preparing for selection and challenges faced (n = 1885). Selection outcomes across all UK medical schools were examined for consenting students (n = 955). Univariate and multivariate analyses explored the associations of preparatory activities and demographic data with subsequent offer of a place at a UK medical school.The survey response rate was 66.4%. Clinical work experience (hospital or general practice), fee-based courses for admissions tests and school preparation courses for interview were activities significantly associated with the offer of a place (P .05). Those attending independent (private) schools most frequently reported school support and fee-based courses to support preparation (P .01). Applicants from state non-selective (SNS) schools and lower socio-economic groups more frequently reported challenges in accessing fee-based support, school interview courses and clinical work experience (P ≤ .02).Clinical work experience, commercial courses for admissions tests and school-based support for interview represent areas of preparation that are associated with success. However, they also represent areas that are more challenging to access for demographic groups traditionally under-represented in medicine. Addressing complex issues of fairness in highly selective higher education settings can appear an insurmountable task. These preparatory activities represent key areas for applicants, schools and institutions to explore and address.
- Published
- 2022
24. Medical student engagement in small‐group active learning: A stimulated recall study
- Author
-
Anne De la Croix, Jan Willem Grijpma, Marianne Mak-van der Vossen, Rashmi Kusurkar, Martijn Meeter, Team Higher Education, Educational and Family Studies, LEARN! - Learning sciences, IOO, General practice, Other Research, APH - Quality of Care, and APH - Methodology
- Subjects
Students, Medical ,Emotions ,ComputingMilieux_COMPUTERSANDEDUCATION ,Humans ,Problem-Based Learning ,General Medicine ,SDG 4 - Quality Education ,Education - Abstract
BackgroundActive learning relies on students' engagement with teachers, study materials and/or each other. Although medical education has adopted active learning as a core component of medical training, teachers have difficulties recognising when and why their students engage or disengage and how to teach in ways that optimise engagement. With a better understanding of the dynamics of student engagement in small-group active learning settings, teachers could be facilitated in effectively engaging their students.MethodsWe conducted a video-stimulated recall study to explore medical students' engagement during small-group learning activities. We recorded one teaching session of two different groups and selected critical moments of apparent (dis)engagement. These moments served as prompts for the 15 individual semi-structured interviews we held. Interview data were analysed using Template Analysis style of thematic analysis. To guide the analysis, we used a framework that describes student engagement as a dynamic and multidimensional concept, consisting of behavioural, cognitive and emotional components.ResultsThe analysis uncovered three main findings: (1) In-class student engagement followed a spiral-like pattern. Once students were engaged or disengaged on one dimension, other dimensions were likely to follow suit. (2) Students' willingness to engage in class was decided before class, depending on their perception of a number of personal, social and educational antecedents of engagement. (3) Distinguishing engagement from disengagement appeared to be difficult for teachers, because the intention behind student behaviour was not always identifiable.DiscussionThis study adds to the literature by illuminating the dynamic process of student engagement and explaining the difficulty of recognising and influencing this process in practice. Based on the importance of discerning the intentions behind student behaviour, we advise teachers to use their observations of student (dis)engagement to initiate interaction with students with open and inviting prompts. This can help teachers to (re-)engage students in their classrooms.
- Published
- 2022
25. I, we and they: A linguistic and narrative exploration of the authorship process
- Author
-
Erik W. Driessen, Anthony R. Artino, Christopher Watling, Abigail Konopasky, Lauren A. Maggio, Bridget C. O’Brien, RS: SHE - R1 - Research (OvO), and Onderwijsontw & Onderwijsresearch
- Subjects
Male ,Canada ,IMPACT ,media_common.quotation_subject ,Verb ,Space (commercial competition) ,CREDIT ,INQUIRY ,Education ,Narrative inquiry ,PHYSICIANS ,Pedagogy ,Agency (sociology) ,Humans ,Narrative ,Sociology ,media_common ,Dialectic ,ISSUES ,Descriptive statistics ,Publications ,Linguistics ,General Medicine ,Authorship ,Research Personnel ,Negotiation ,Female ,HONORARY AUTHORSHIP - Abstract
Introduction While authorship plays a powerful role in the academy, research indicates many authors engage in questionable practices like honorary authorship. This suggests that authorship may be a contested space where individuals must exercise agency-a dynamic and emergent process, embedded in context-to negotiate potentially conflicting norms among published criteria, disciplines and informal practices. This study explores how authors narrate their own and others' agency in making authorship decisions. Method We conducted a mixed-methods analysis of 24 first authors' accounts of authorship decisions on a recent multi-author paper. Authors included 14 females and 10 males in health professions education (HPE) from U.S. and Canadian institutions (10 assistant, 6 associate and 8 full professors). Analysis took place in three phases: (1) linguistic analysis of grammatical structures shown to be associated with agency (coding for main clause subjects and verb types); (2) narrative analysis to create a 'moral' and 'title' for each account; and (3) dialectic integration of (1) and (2). Results Descriptive statistics suggested that female participants used we subjects and material verbs (of doing) more than men and that full professors used relational verbs (of being and having) more than assistant and associate. Three broad types of agency were narrated: distributed (n = 15 participants), focusing on how resources and work were spread across team members; individual (n = 6), focusing on the first author's action; and collaborative (n = 3), focusing on group actions. These three types of agency contained four subtypes, e.g. supported, contested, task-based and negotiated. Discussion This study highlights the complex and emergent nature of agency narrated by authors when making authorship decisions. Published criteria offer us starting point-the stated rules of the authorship game; this paper offers us a next step-the enacted and narrated approach to the game.
- Published
- 2022
26. How does multisource feedback influence residency training? A qualitative case study
- Author
-
Eva K. Hennel, Andrea Trachsel, Ulrike Subotic, Andrea C. Lörwald, Sigrid Harendza, and Sören Huwendiek
- Subjects
Education, Medical, Graduate ,Humans ,Internship and Residency ,Clinical Competence ,General Medicine ,Child ,Qualitative Research ,Feedback ,Education - Abstract
Multisource feedback (MSF), also called 360-degree assessment, is one form of assessment used in postgraduate training. However, there is an ongoing discussion on its value, because the factors that influence the impact of MSF and the main impact of MSF are not fully understood. In this study, we investigated both the influencing factors and the impact of MSF on residency training.We conducted a qualitative case study within the boundaries of the residency training for paediatricians and paediatric surgeons at a University Hospital. We collected data from seven focus group interviews with stakeholders of MSF (residents, raters and supervisors). By performing a reflexive thematic analysis, we extracted the influencing factors and the impact of MSF.We found seven influencing factors: MSF is facilitated by the announcement of a clear goal of MSF, the training of raters on the MSF instrument, a longitudinal approach of observation, timing not too early and not too late during the rotation, narrative comments as part of the ratings, the residents' self-assessment and a supervisor from the same department. We found three themes on the impact of MSF: MSF supports the professional development of residents, enhances interprofessional teamwork and increases the raters' commitment to the training of residents.This study illuminates the influencing factors and impact of MSF on residency training. We offer novel recommendations on the continuity of observation, the timing during rotations and the role of the supervisor. Moreover, by discussing our results through the lens of identity formation theory, this work advances our conceptual understanding of MSF. We propose identity formation theory as a framework for future research on MSF to leverage the potential of MSF in residency training.
- Published
- 2022
27. ‘Poorly relaxed women’: A situational analysis of pelvic examination learning materials for medical students
- Author
-
Sarah Towle
- Subjects
Canada ,Students, Medical ,Humans ,Learning ,Female ,Curriculum ,Gynecological Examination ,General Medicine ,Education, Medical, Undergraduate ,Education - Abstract
Certain clinical pelvic examination (PE) teaching methods have been critiqued for prioritising student learning over patient autonomy and for not accurately representing diverse patient communities. As such, patient-centred and culturally competent approaches to the PE may need further emphasis in the medical curriculum-in particular, in content delivered to students before patient interaction. Classroom materials serve as students' first exposure to the sensitive procedure. This research explores how patients are represented in these materials.A situational analysis was conducted on 10 purposively sampled PE learning materials for the 2019/20 academic year from five undergraduate medical schools in Canada. Situational analysis focuses on analysing discourse but is epistemically aligned with post-structuralism (most notably Foucault's theories involving discursive power) and allows for specific consideration of 'silences' in the data. Collected data were analysed using cartographic approaches according to this methodology, with particular attention paid to the tenets and frameworks of patient-centred and culturally competent care.Overall, content in these materials misrepresented and under-represented patients. Materials contained both outdated and unnecessarily sexualised language, in addition to a lack of patient diversity. Clinical authority was often centred over patient agency, and several updated PE techniques known to improve patient experience were absent. Patient-centred and culturally competent approaches were therefore inadequately highlighted in most of the materials.Depictions contained in these materials may be perpetuating stereotypes and biases in medicine and may be working to maintain teaching practices that cause harm to patients (standardised and regular) who students interact with in both clinical and educational settings. Efforts may be needed to improve classroom materials on the PE so that they more adequately centre patients and provide opportunities to discuss culturally competent approaches to the procedure that (i) may not be covered in other parts of the PE curriculum and (ii) can reduce known health disparities.
- Published
- 2022
28. An Interpretive Phenomenological Analysis of paediatric cardiology trainee experiences during COVID‐19
- Author
-
Sadia Quyam and Mohammad Abumehdi
- Subjects
Surveys and Questionnaires ,Cardiology ,COVID-19 ,Humans ,General Medicine ,Empathy ,Child ,Pandemics ,Education - Abstract
Medical training during the COVID-19 pandemic has placed extra-ordinary demands on individuals within a context of rapid and iterative systems changes. The contemporaneous lived experience of trainees during this time has mainly been examined with surveys. Our study aims to provide a rich account of the experience of being a trainee during the pandemic to deepen our conceptual understanding of wellness. This holds relevance as we move away from examining the immediate innovations of the pandemic and towards long-term adjustments.We used Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) to explore the experiences of trainees in paediatric cardiology during the pandemic. Five trainees were purposively recruited. Initial semi-structured interviews were held during the first wave of the pandemic with follow-up interviews held during the second wave.Three superordinate paradoxical themes were recognised in the data: connectedness and isolation, disruption and stasis and vulnerability and strength.Disruption to routine activities of service delivery, training and home-life pervaded the pandemic and was experienced as stasis. Technology maintained the trainee's connection to the content of work but left them feeling isolated from its context. Vulnerability arose from interplay between illness, uncertainty and perception of risk, contrasted against strength drawn from compassion and the discovery of resilience. Supporting trainees as we emerge from the initial phase of the pandemic requires us to review how we understand and address wellness, including the contribution of organisational and systemic factors to its protection. Participants described varying states of impaired wellness and experienced a normalisation of aspects of vulnerability. We theorise that trainees were able to find opportunities for growth and the development of resilience within the space that this created.
- Published
- 2022
29. Explicit teaching in the operating room
- Author
-
Mike Huiskes, Sjoerd K. Bulstra, Martin Stevens, Fokie Cnossen, Debbie Jaarsma, Patrick Nieboer, Artificial Intelligence, Public Health Research (PHR), Restoring Organ Function by Means of Regenerative Medicine (REGENERATE), and Lifelong Learning, Education & Assessment Research Network (LEARN)
- Subjects
Motivation ,Operating Rooms ,Medical education ,Structured analysis ,Process (engineering) ,Communication ,Teaching ,media_common.quotation_subject ,Internship and Residency ,Videotape Recording ,Context (language use) ,General Medicine ,Outcome (game theory) ,Preference ,Education ,Conversation analysis ,Humans ,Observational study ,Quality (business) ,Psychology ,media_common - Abstract
CONTEXT: Residents need their supervisors in the operating room to inform them on how to use their expertise in present and future occasions. A few studies hint at such explicit teaching behaviour, however without explaining its underlying mechanisms. Understanding and improving explicit teaching becomes more salient nowadays, as access of residents to relevant procedures is decreasing, while end-terms of training programs remain unchanged: high quality patient care.OBJECTIVES: A structured analysis of 1. The practices supervisors use for explicit teaching and 2. How supervisors introduce explicit teaching in real time during surgical procedures.METHODS: An observational qualitative collection study in which all actions of nine supervisor-resident dyads during a total hip replacement procedure were videotaped. Interactions in which supervisors explicitly or implicitly inform residents how to use their expertise now and in future occasions were included for further analysis, using the iterative inductive process of conversation analysis.RESULTS: 1. Supervisors used a basic template of if/then rules for explicit teaching, which they regularly customized by adding metaphors, motivations, and information about preference, prevalence and consequence. 2. If/then rules are introduced by supervisors to solve a (potential) problem in outcome for the present patient in reaction to local circumstances, e.g. what residents said, did or were about to do.CONCLUSIONS: If/then rules add the why to the what. Supervisors upgrade residents' insights in surgical procedures (professional vision) and teach the degree of individual freedom and variation of their expert standards for future occasions. These insights can be beneficial in improving supervisors' teaching skills.
- Published
- 2022
30. Determining influence, interaction and causality of contrast and sequence effects in objective structured clinical exams
- Author
-
Peter Yeates, Alice Moult, Natalie Cope, Gareth McCray, Richard Fuller, and Robert McKinley
- Subjects
Humans ,Clinical Competence ,Educational Measurement ,General Medicine ,Education - Abstract
Differential rater function over time (DRIFT) and contrast effects (examiners' scores biased away from the standard of preceding performances) both challenge the fairness of scoring in objective structured clinical exams (OSCEs). This is important as, under some circumstances, these effects could alter whether some candidates pass or fail assessments. Benefitting from experimental control, this study investigated the causality, operation and interaction of both effects simultaneously for the first time in an OSCE setting.We used secondary analysis of data from an OSCE in which examiners scored embedded videos of student performances interspersed between live students. Embedded video position varied between examiners (early vs. late) whilst the standard of preceding performances naturally varied (previous high or low). We examined linear relationships suggestive of DRIFT and contrast effects in all within-OSCE data before comparing the influence and interaction of 'early' versus 'late' and 'previous high' versus 'previous low' conditions on embedded video scores.Linear relationships data did not support the presence of DRIFT or contrast effects. Embedded videos were scored higher early (19.9 [19.4-20.5]) versus late (18.6 [18.1-19.1], p 0.001), but scores did not differ between previous high and previous low conditions. The interaction term was non-significant.In this instance, the small DRIFT effect we observed on embedded videos can be causally attributed to examiner behaviour. Contrast effects appear less ubiquitous than some prior research suggests. Possible mediators of these finding include the following: OSCE context, detail of task specification, examiners' cognitive load and the distribution of learners' ability. As the operation of these effects appears to vary across contexts, further research is needed to determine the prevalence and mechanisms of contrast and DRIFT effects, so that assessments may be designed in ways that are likely to avoid their occurrence. Quality assurance should monitor for these contextually variable effects in order to ensure OSCE equivalence.
- Published
- 2022
31. International medical graduates' experiences before and after migration: A meta‐ethnography of qualitative studies
- Author
-
Evi Germeni, Susan Jamieson, and Mo Al-Haddad
- Subjects
Medical education ,education ,MEDLINE ,Conceptual model (computer science) ,Psychological intervention ,General Medicine ,PsycINFO ,Education ,Argument ,Physicians ,Humans ,Foreign Medical Graduates ,Psychology ,Inclusion (education) ,Anthropology, Cultural ,Qualitative Research ,Disadvantage ,Qualitative research - Abstract
Introduction: \ud International Medical Graduates (IMGs) represent a large portion of practicing doctors in many countries. Many experience difficulties, including higher rates of complaints against them and lower exam pass rates. The UK’s General Medical Council (GMC) recently set targets to ‘eliminate disproportionate complaints’ and ‘eradicate disadvantage and discrimination in medical education’. Our timely meta-ethnography aimed to synthesise existing qualitative literature on the wider personal and professional experiences of IMGs, to identify factors affecting IMGs’ professional practice (either directly or indirectly).\ud \ud Methods: \ud In September 2019 we systematically searched Medline, Embase, Cochrane, PsycINFO, ERIC and EdResearch for peer-reviewed qualitative and mixed-methods articles that described experiences of IMGs. We extracted participant quotes and authors’ themes from included articles and used the technique of meta-ethnography to synthesise the data and develop new overarching concepts.\ud \ud Results: \ud Of the 1613 articles identified, 57 met our inclusion criteria. In total, the articles corresponded to 46 studies that described the experiences of 1142 IMGs practicing in all 6 continents in a range of settings, including primary and secondary care. We developed 5 key concepts: Migration dimensions (issues considered by IMGs when migrating), a challenging start (the stressful early period), degree of dissonance (between the IMG and host country in relation to the 4 main barriers of language, culture, medical education and belonging), levelling the playing field (interventions to reduce the impact of the barriers) and survive then thrive (adjustments IMGs made). A conceptual model that brings these constructs together in a line of argument is presented.\ud \ud Conclusions: \ud This meta-ethnography, based on a large amount of diverse qualitative studies, is the first to provide a comprehensive picture of the experiences and challenges that IMGs face before and after migration. Our results should be used to guide the development of interventions aiming to support IMGs and meet the GMC targets.
- Published
- 2022
32. Longitudinal placements for trainee pharmacists: Learning whilst improving patient care
- Author
-
Jeremy Sokhi, David T. Wright, Hannah Kinsey, and Maria Christou
- Subjects
Medical education ,Health professionals ,education ,Professional development ,General Medicine ,Pharmacists ,Patient care ,Education ,Learning experience ,Practice learning ,Community of practice ,Qualitative longitudinal ,Humans ,Learning ,Clinical Competence ,Patient Care ,Psychology ,Hospital ward ,Education, Medical, Undergraduate - Abstract
Introduction: Longitudinal Integrated Clerkships (LICs) have demonstrated benefits for students' learning and development in medical education globally. The model emphasises importance with respect to continuity and time in the workplace for learners. There is a need to explore how LICs become a viable training model for learners. An amalgamative LIC model was drawn upon to inform the design of a placement for trainee pharmacists on a hospital ward. This study sought to determine the local viability of a longitudinal placement for trainee pharmacists, using communities of practice learning theory to interpret findings. Methods: A design-based research approach informed study design. A longitudinal placement was implemented on two hospital wards for 13 weeks. Trainees (n = 3) were interviewed four times over a 14-week period. Ward staff (n = 14) were interviewed at week 14. Interviews were transcribed verbatim. Qualitative longitudinal analysis, using the trajectory approach, was conducted using abductive analysis. The coded data were organised into a framework and subthemes were created. Results: Trainees acquired membership within the multi-disciplinary ward team over time. This led to an enriched learning experience and the trainee's professional development improved as they attained more responsibilities. This enabled them to make a greater contribution to patient care; more medication consultations occurred, and discharge times improved. Discussion: The local viability of the longitudinal placement appears to be linked to the trainee's ability to acquire membership within the ward community of practice. Membership gave trainee's access to learning opportunities, supporting their development, and they earnt the trust of staff, leading to more responsibilities for providing patient care. Further research into developing longitudinal placements that support trainee healthcare professionals to acquire membership within communities of practice is warranted.
- Published
- 2021
33. Dual and duelling purposes: An exploration of educators' perspectives on the use of reflective writing to remediate professionalism in residency
- Author
-
Andrew E. Warren, Tracy Moniz, Carolyn M. Melro, and Christopher Watling
- Subjects
Canada ,Medical education ,Students, Medical ,Data collection ,Writing ,media_common.quotation_subject ,Reflective writing ,Internship and Residency ,Sincerity ,Context (language use) ,General Medicine ,Ambivalence ,Education ,Professionalism ,Intervention (counseling) ,Humans ,Quality (business) ,Psychology ,Reflection (computer graphics) ,media_common - Abstract
Context Professionalism lapses have high stakes for learners and educators. Problems with professionalism, unless appropriately and effectively remediated, may portend serious problems in practice. Yet, remediation for unprofessional behaviour is particularly challenging-and understudied. Increasingly, educators are turning to reflective writing as a remediation strategy in residency, yet little is known about what educators expect reflective writing to accomplish, how they choose reflective writing tasks, why they use reflective writing, or how they evaluate whether a learner has met expectations. We aimed to understand why and how postgraduate medical educators use reflective writing as an educational intervention to remediate professionalism. Method In this constructivist grounded theory study, we interviewed 13 medical education professionals with experience using reflective writing to remediate professionalism across five Canadian medical schools. Data collection and analysis occurred iteratively using constant comparison to identify themes and to understand the relationships among them. Results Medical educators reported using reflective writing as a learning tool to develop insight and as an assessment tool to unearth evidence of insight. The goal of learning may compete with the goal of assessment, creating tension that leads to uncertainty about the sincerity, quality, and effectiveness of reflective writing as well as concerns about learner safety. Educators reported uncertainty about whether learners write to pass or to introspect and about how to judge the effectiveness of reflective writing as a learning tool. They expressed concern about creating a safe environment for learners-one that enables the genuine reflection required for insight development-while meeting requirements of remediation. Conclusions Educators express ambivalence about using reflective writing to remediate professionalism in residency. Understanding the potential and pitfalls of reflective writing may inform more tailored and effective approaches to remediate professionalism.
- Published
- 2021
34. Inferring signs from purposeful samples: The role of context in competency assessment
- Author
-
Marise Ph. Born, Chantal E. E. van Andel, Karen M. Stegers-Jager, Work and Organizational Psychology, and Research & Education
- Subjects
Students, Medical ,Education, Medical ,education ,Perspective (graphical) ,Clinical performance ,Context (language use) ,General Medicine ,Problem of universals ,Education ,Generic competencies ,Competency assessment ,Selection (linguistics) ,Humans ,Clinical Competence ,Medical History Taking ,Psychology ,Competence (human resources) ,Schools, Medical ,Cognitive psychology - Abstract
Context: Medical students' clinical competencies are customarily assessed using convenience samples of performance from real practice. The question is how these convenience samples can be turned into purposeful samples to extrapolate students' overall competency profile at the end of medical school, particularly given the context specificity of clinical performance. In this paper, we will address this issue of inferring signs from samples using insights from the discipline of psychology. Theoretical perspective: We adapted Smith's theory of predictor validity of universals, occupationals and relationals to the context of clinical competency assessment. Universals are characteristics required by all working individuals and therefore not context dependent. Occupationals refer to characteristics required by certain jobs but not others and therefore are dependent on task-related features of an occupation. Relationals are required in a specific organisational context with habitual ways of working together. Application: Through seven propositions, we assert that generalising from samples of assessed clinical competencies during clerkships to generic competencies (i.e., signs) is dependent on whether characteristics are universals, occupationals and relationals, with universals most and relationals least generalisable. Conclusion: When determining what types of ratings to use to evaluate medical student competence, medical education has shown too little nuance in considering the degree to which particular characteristics are likely to be generalisable, approaching the issue in an all-or-none manner. Smith's distinction between universals, occupationals and relationals offers a promising way forward that has implications for assessment, student selection and career choice.
- Published
- 2021
35. The medical pause
- Author
-
Jeroen J. G. van Merriënboer, John Young, Joy Yeonjoo Lee, Jeroen Donkers, Halszka Jarodzka, Adam Szulewski, RS: SHE - R1 - Research (OvO), Onderwijsontw & Onderwijsresearch, RS-Research Line Online Learning and Instruction (part of ERA program), and Department of Online Learning and Instruction
- Subjects
REFLECTION ,Software_GENERAL ,Computer science ,media_common.quotation_subject ,ACCURACY ,Acknowledgement ,Control (management) ,pause ,Clinical Reasoning ,SLOWING-DOWN ,Education ,Patient safety ,InformationSystems_GENERAL ,SURGICAL SAFETY CHECKLIST ,Humans ,Learning ,TOOL ,Computer Simulation ,KNOWLEDGE ,Workplace ,Function (engineering) ,Curriculum ,media_common ,cognitive load ,Cognition ,General Medicine ,PERFORMANCE ,CARE ,TIME ,Educational Status ,timeout ,Timeout ,medical education ,COGNITIVE LOAD THEORY ,Cognitive load ,Cognitive psychology - Abstract
Research has shown that taking ‘timeouts’ in medical practice improves performance and patient safety. However, the benefits of taking timeouts, or pausing, are not sufficiently acknowledged in workplaces and training programmes. To promote this acknowledgement, we suggest a systematic conceptualisation of the medical pause, focusing on its importance, processes and implementation in training programmes. By employing insights from educational and cognitive psychology, we first identified pausing as an important skill to interrupt negative momentum and bolster learning. Subsequently, we categorised constituent cognitive processes for pausing skills into two phases: the decision‐making phase (determining when and how to take pauses) and the executive phase (applying relaxation or reflection during pauses). We present a model that describes how relaxation and reflection during pauses can optimise cognitive load in performance. Several strategies to implement pause training in medical curricula are proposed: intertwining pause training with training of primary skills, providing second‐order scaffolding through shared control and employing auxiliary tools such as computer‐based simulations with a pause function., Lee et al. suggest a systematic conceptualization of the medical pause, focusing on its importance, processes, and implementation in training programs.
- Published
- 2021
36. The chicken and the egg: Clinical reasoning and uncertainty tolerance
- Author
-
Anna Richmond
- Subjects
Uncertainty ,Animals ,Humans ,General Medicine ,Clinical Reasoning ,Chickens ,Education - Abstract
In this issue, Stephens et al. present their investigation into medical students' experiences of uncertainty.1 Although clinical uncertainty is ubiquitous in medical practice, development of uncertainty tolerance is too often left implicit, to the detriment of care and caregivers given that intolerance is associated with overuse of resources, burnout and psychological distress. Interestingly, Stephens et al. found that students reported greater experience of educational uncertainty (lack of clarity regarding how and what to learn), and professional uncertainty (who they would be as doctors), than clinical uncertainty (aspects of patient care). That clinical uncertainty was least often reported suggests a need for educators to broaden consideration of uncertainty. Educators should also consider whether the lack of reportage of clinical uncertainty is actually a reflection of students' reduced awareness, rather than reduced experience, of this common phenonenon. As students advance further in their training and develop their clinical reasoning skills, clinical uncertainty will be, as it is for practicing doctors, frequently encountered, leading me to agree with Stephens et al.,1 that greater attention should be paid to clinical uncertainty. In addition, an understanding of the relationship between tolerance of uncertainty and development of clinical reasoning is needed. In order to explore this further, I consider the age old dilemma of what came first, the chicken or the egg: that is, does tolerance of uncertainty derive from or cause improved clinical reasoning?
- Published
- 2022
37. Broadening perspectives about incorporating international medical graduates
- Author
-
Xiaoming Xu and Hongbin Wu
- Subjects
Humans ,General Medicine ,Foreign Medical Graduates ,Family Practice ,Education - Published
- 2022
38. Longitudinal training models for entrusting students with independent patient care?: A systematic review
- Author
-
Anneke W. M. Kramer, Linda Helena Anna Bonnie, Gaston R. Cremers, Nynke van Dijk, and Mana Nasori
- Subjects
Medical education ,Education, Medical ,business.industry ,Process (engineering) ,Learning environment ,media_common.quotation_subject ,education ,Professional development ,MEDLINE ,Preceptor ,General Medicine ,Training (civil) ,Education ,Health care ,Humans ,Learning ,Quality (business) ,Patient Care ,Students ,business ,Psychology ,Education, Medical, Undergraduate ,media_common - Abstract
Objective: The participation of students from both undergraduate medical education (UGME) and postgraduate medical education (PGME) in independent patient care contributes to the development of knowledge, skills and the professional identity of students. A continuing collaboration between students and their preceptor might contribute to opportunities for students to independently provide patient care. In this systematic review, we aim to evaluate whether longitudinal training models facilitate the independent practice of students and what characteristics of longitudinal training models contribute to this process. Method: This systematic review was performed according to the PRISMA guidelines. In May 2020, we performed a search in three databases. Articles evaluating the impact of longitudinal training models on the independent practice of students from both UGME and PGME programmes were eligible for the study. A total of 68 articles were included in the study. Quality of the included studies was assessed using the Quality Assessment Tool for Studies with Diverse Designs (QATSDD). Results: Both UGME and PGME students in longitudinal training models are more frequently allowed to provide patient care independently when compared with their block model peers, and they also feel better prepared for independent practice at the end of their training programme. Several factors related to longitudinal training models stimulate opportunities for students to work independently. The most important factors in this process are the longitudinal relationships with preceptors and with the health care team. Conclusion: Due to the ongoing collaboration between students and their preceptor, they develop an intensive and supportive mutual relationship, allowing for the development of a safe learning environment. As a result, the professional development of students is fostered, and students gradually become part of the health care team, allowing them the opportunity to engage in independent patient care.
- Published
- 2021
39. The potential of narrative analysis for HPE research: Highlighting five analytic lenses
- Author
-
Lara Varpio, Renée E. Stalmeijer, Abigail Konopasky, RS: SHE - R1 - Research (OvO), and Onderwijsontw & Onderwijsresearch
- Subjects
Value (ethics) ,MEDICAL-STUDENTS ,STORIES ,Context (language use) ,General Medicine ,Grounded theory ,Education ,Narrative inquiry ,Epistemology ,Scholarship ,Health Occupations ,Situated ,Humans ,Narrative ,Sociology ,Qualitative research - Abstract
Context Health professions education (HPE) has increasingly turned to qualitative methodology to address a number of the field's difficult research problems. While several different methodologies have been widely accepted and used in HPE research (e.g., Grounded Theory), others remain largely unknown. In this methodology paper, we discuss the value of narrative analysis (NA) as a set of analytic approaches that offer several lenses that can support HPE scholars' research. Methods After briefly discussing the 'narrative turn' in research, we highlight five NA lenses: holistic, situated, linguistic, agentive and sequential. We explore what each lens can offer HPE scholars-highlighting certain aspects of the data-and how each lens is limited-obscuring other aspects. To support these observations, we offer an example of each lens from contemporary HPE scholarship. The manuscript also describes methods that can be employed in NA research and offers two different typologies of NA methods that can be used to access these lenses. Conclusions We conclude with a discussion of how different analytic methods can be used to harness each of the lenses. We urge the deliberate selection and use of NA methods and point to the inherent partiality of any NA approach. Reflecting on our position as narrative scholars, we acknowledge how our own lenses illuminate some areas and conceal others as we tell the story of NA. In conclusion, we invite other researchers to benefit from the potential NA promises.
- Published
- 2021
40. Weighting admission scores to balance predictiveness‐diversity: The Pareto‐optimization approach
- Author
-
Wilfried De Corte, Filip Lievens, and Paul R. Sackett
- Subjects
Operations research ,Computer science ,Radiotherapy Planning, Computer-Assisted ,Context (language use) ,General Medicine ,Multi-objective optimization ,Outcome (game theory) ,Regression ,Education ,Weighting ,Harm ,Humans ,Algorithms ,Selection (genetic algorithm) ,Diversity (business) - Abstract
CONTEXT Although many medical schools seek to improve diversity, they grapple with the challenge of how to weight the scores of different admission methods to achieve a balance between obtaining high predictiveness and ensuring diversity in the selected student pool. Yet, in large-scale employment settings, substantial progress has been made on this front: Pareto-optimization has been introduced as an elegant statistical tool to assist decision makers in determining the weights assigned to selection methods in advance (before the selection has taken place) so that a selection system is designed to achieve an optimal balance as reflected by the trade-off that one outcome (e.g., predictiveness) cannot be improved without harm to the other outcome (e.g., diversity). AIMS This paper reviews the theory and research evidence about Pareto-optimization and explains how Pareto-optimization permits medical schools to better balance predictiveness and diversity in medical admission systems. METHODS After reviewing common weighting schemes (unit, regression-based and ad hoc weighting) and their drawbacks, we introduce the theory and logic of Pareto-optimization for better balancing predictiveness and diversity. To this end, we also offer an illustrative example. Next, we review the mathematical basis and available research evidence regarding Pareto-optimization. Finally, we discuss potential criticisms (i.e., complexity and legal concerns). CONCLUSIONS Compared to traditional unit weighting, regression-based weighting and ad hoc weighting, Pareto-optimization leads to substantial increases in diversity intake (up to three times more), while keeping the predictiveness of the selection methods at the same level. Moreover, the Pareto-optimization is robust to sampling variability and variability of the input selection parameters.
- Published
- 2021
41. Engaging high schools for the co-creation of hands-on teaching resources for medical programmes
- Author
-
Charlotte Phelps and Christian Moro
- Subjects
Surveys and Questionnaires ,Teaching ,Humans ,General Medicine ,Curriculum ,Schools, Medical ,Education ,Education, Medical, Undergraduate - Published
- 2022
42. Cultural historical activity and the complexity of health professions education
- Author
-
Tehmina Gladman and Rebecca Grainger
- Subjects
Health Occupations ,Humans ,General Medicine ,Cultural Diversity ,Education - Published
- 2022
43. Patient involvement in assessment: How useful is it?
- Author
-
Bunmi Malau-Aduli
- Subjects
Humans ,General Medicine ,Patient Participation ,Education - Published
- 2022
44. The F3 phenomenon: Early‐career training breaks in medical training. A scoping review
- Author
-
Steven Agius and Helen Church
- Subjects
Medical education ,Career Choice ,020205 medical informatics ,Attitude of Health Personnel ,Specialty ,Foundation (evidence) ,Context (language use) ,02 engineering and technology ,General Medicine ,Training (civil) ,Education ,03 medical and health sciences ,Equality and diversity ,0302 clinical medicine ,Physicians ,Phenomenon ,0202 electrical engineering, electronic engineering, information engineering ,Humans ,Medicine ,030212 general & internal medicine ,Postgraduate training ,Psychology ,Graduation - Abstract
Background Since 2017 more than 50% of UK doctors have undertaken a ‘Foundation 3 (F3) Year’ training break after completing their Foundation Programme (the first two years following graduation), rather than immediately enter specialty training. The reasons for, and consequences of, the growing F3 trend are largely unknown. This scoping review presents the current evidence and identifies future research in this field. Methods Following Arksey and O’Malley’s guidelines, 12 databases and three UK‐based national post‐graduate organisation websites were searched for articles published in English (final searches January 2020). Multiple search terms were used to capture articles relating to the ‘F3’ time‐period, including ‘post‐foundation’ or ‘pre‐specialty’ training. Title, abstract and full‐paper screening selected articles reporting any aspect of F3, including within a wider context (e.g., postgraduate training breaks), and then underwent mixed methods analysis . Results Of 4766 articles identified, 45 were included. All articles were published after 2009; 14/45 (31.1%) were published in 2019. 27 articles reported research, the remainder were opinion/commentaries. Specific personal (including demographic), professional and organisational factors, particularly the UK post‐graduate training structure, are associated with undertaking an F3. The majority of F3 training breaks last 1 year and involve working (clinically or non‐clinically) and/or travel. The decision to undertake an F3 is made either prior to, or during, foundation training. Evidence regarding the impact of F3 on healthcare service provision was limited but evenly balanced. Conclusions In summarising the existing F3 evidence, this review has highlighted important issues including healthcare workforce equality and diversity, training pathway inflexibility and the effect of negative early‐career experiences on subsequent career decisions. More research is needed to understand the financial impact of training‐breaks on healthcare service provision, how training programmes must adapt to retain more trainees, and the long‐term effects of training breaks, such as F3, on subsequent career progression.
- Published
- 2021
45. The curious case of case study research
- Author
-
Anna MacLeod, Rachel Ellaway, Jennifer Cleland, and Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine (LKCMedicine)
- Subjects
Value (ethics) ,Biomedical Research ,020205 medical informatics ,media_common.quotation_subject ,Context (language use) ,02 engineering and technology ,Education ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Reflexivity ,0202 electrical engineering, electronic engineering, information engineering ,Humans ,Medicine [Science] ,Quality (business) ,Conversation ,030212 general & internal medicine ,Sociology ,Sophistication ,media_common ,Education, Medical ,General Medicine ,Epistemology ,Medical Education ,Research Design ,Corporate social responsibility ,Emic and etic - Abstract
The conceptualisation of 'good' medical education research as hypothesis testing to identify universal truths that are generalisable across contexts has been challenged. Joining this conversation, the field of health professions education research is complex and contextual and there are ways of examining and reporting locally based activities and innovations, which can be of general value. This position leads to a focus on case study research (CSR), inquiry bound in time and place that generates thick descriptions and close interpretations to reach explanations. CSR has grown in sophistication in recent years and can inform practice and advance the science of medical and health professions education. The authors evaluated the current state of the science of CSR in the medical education literature by identifying and reviewing 160 papers. Most articles presented as 'case studies' were not in fact CSR. Moreover, most articles failed to go beyond a 'we did this' account. The authors explore definitions of CSR, and they examine dominant CSR methodologists, Yin, Stake and Merriam, and their respective approaches to CSR. They then set out some of the basic tenets of CSR (case definition, methods of data collection and analysis) and consider the logics of CSR (its structures, purposes, assumptions and symbols). CSR challenges are considered next (such as emic and etic perspectives; ethical complexities; generalisability; quality; and reporting and reflexivity). The authors conclude that context is a mechanism, which needs to be understood, and rigorous CSR provides the structures and criticality to do so, opening up new areas of understanding and inquiry.
- Published
- 2021
46. The wolf you feed: Challenging intraprofessional workplace‐based education norms
- Author
-
Renée E. Stalmeijer, Lara Varpio, RS: SHE - R1 - Research (OvO), and Onderwijsontw & Onderwijsresearch
- Subjects
020205 medical informatics ,Interprofessional Relations ,Context (language use) ,02 engineering and technology ,Education ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Health care ,Situated ,0202 electrical engineering, electronic engineering, information engineering ,Learning theory ,Animals ,Learning ,Humans ,030212 general & internal medicine ,Workplace ,Competence (human resources) ,Patient Care Team ,Medical education ,Wolves ,business.industry ,Interpretation (philosophy) ,Perspective (graphical) ,Citizen journalism ,General Medicine ,Interprofessional Education ,Cross‐cutting Edge ,Power, Psychological ,business ,Psychology - Abstract
Context The trajectory towards becoming a medical professional is strongly situated within the clinical workplace. Through participatory engagement, medical trainees learn to address complex health care issues through collaboration with the interprofessional health care team. To help explain learning and teaching dynamics within the clinical workplace, many scholars have relied on socio‐cultural learning theories. In the field of medical education, this research has largely adopted a limited interpretation of a crucial dimension within socio‐cultural learning theory: the expert who guides the trainee into the community is almost exclusively from the same profession. We contend that this narrow interpretation is not necessary. This limited focus is one we choose to maintain—be that choice intentional or implicit. In this cross‐cutting edge paper, we argue that choosing an interprofessional orientation towards workplace learning and guidance may better prepare medical trainees for their future role in health care practice. Methods By applying Communities of Practice and Landscapes of Practice , and supported by empirical examples, we demonstrate how medical trainees are not solely on a trajectory towards the Community of Physician Practice (CoPP) but also on a trajectory towards various Landscapes of Healthcare Practice (LoHCP). We discuss some of the barriers present within health care organisations and professions that have likely inhibited adoption of the broader LoHCP perspective. We suggest three perspectives that might help to deliberately and meaningfully incorporate the interprofessional learning and teaching dynamic within the medical education continuum. Conclusion Systematically incorporating Landscapes of Competence, Assessment, and Guidance in workplace‐based education—in addition to our current intraprofessional approach—can better prepare medical trainees for their roles within the LoHCP. By advocating and researching this interprofessional perspective, we can embark on a journey towards fully harnessing and empowering the health care team within workplace‐based education., Using a Landscapes of Health Care Practices perspective, the authors describe how medical education should be feeding both and intra‐ and interprofessional perspectives on effective workplace learning.
- Published
- 2021
47. Enhancing remediation by focusing on affective experience
- Author
-
Valentina Colonnello and Colonnello V.
- Subjects
Emotion ,Medical Education ,Environmental remediation ,Applied psychology ,ComputingMilieux_COMPUTERSANDEDUCATION ,Humans ,Remediation ,General Medicine ,Psychology ,Environmental Restoration and Remediation ,Human ,Education - Abstract
Colonnello offers the affective neuroscience view as a means for better understanding the role of emotions in remediation and nurturing synergistic interactions between research and education.
- Published
- 2021
48. Time to reflect: How has COVID-19 transformed you? A commentary
- Author
-
Renée S. Jansen
- Subjects
COVID-19 ,Humans ,General Medicine ,Education - Published
- 2022
49. The hunter and the lion: Amplifying health care consumers' voices in health care education
- Author
-
Gabrielle Brand and Janeane Dart
- Subjects
Humans ,General Medicine ,Consumer Behavior ,Delivery of Health Care ,Health Education ,Education - Published
- 2022
50. Exploring mechanisms underlying learning from deliberate reflection
- Author
-
Rosa Malena Delbone de Faria, Henk G. Schmidt, Alexandre Sampaio Moura, Sílvia Mamede, Eliza Maria de Brito, Ligia Maria Cayres Ribeiro, and Department of Psychology, Education and Child Studies
- Subjects
Motivation ,Students, Medical ,Recall ,business.industry ,Outcome measures ,Cognition ,General Medicine ,Education ,Developmental psychology ,Subject matter ,Diagnosis, Differential ,Text mining ,Reflection (mathematics) ,Situational interest ,Humans ,Clinical Competence ,Medical diagnosis ,business ,Psychology ,Education, Medical, Undergraduate - Abstract
Introduction: Previous research suggests that, relative to generating a differential diagnosis, deliberate reflection during practice with clinical cases fosters learning from a subsequently studied scientific text and promotes interest in the subject matter. The present experiment aimed to replicate these findings and to examine whether motivational or cognitive mechanisms, or both, underlie the positive effects of reflection. Methods: A total of 101 5th-year medical students participated in an experiment containing four phases: Students (a) diagnosed two clinical cases of jaundice-related diseases either through deliberate reflection or differential diagnosis; (b) reported their situational interest and awareness of knowledge gaps; (c) studied a text about jaundice, either under free or restricted time; and (d) recalled the text. Outcome measures were text-recall, situational interest and awareness of knowledge gaps. Results: A main effect of diagnostic approach on recall of the text was found, with the reflection group recalling more studied material than the differential diagnosis group (means: 72.56 vs 58.80; P =.01). No interaction between diagnostic approach and study time (free or restricted) emerged, nor was there a main effect of the latter. Relative to the differential diagnosis group, students who reflected upon the cases scored significantly higher on both situational interest (means: 4.45 vs 3.99, P
- Published
- 2021
Catalog
Discovery Service for Jio Institute Digital Library
For full access to our library's resources, please sign in.