Search

Background: Although a daily supplement of 400 micrograms folic acid has been shown to prevent neural-tube defects (NTD), most women do not take the recommended supplement. Thus, food fortification is to be introduced in the USA and is being considered in the UK. Because of safety concerns, the USA has chosen a level of fortification that will increase the average woman's intake by only 100 micrograms. Such an increase, although safe, may be ineffective; but a trial to assess its efficacy would be unethical. Because women with red-cell folate concentrations above 400 micrograms/L have a very low risk of NTD, we undertook a randomised trial of several folic acid doses to find out how much is needed to reach this protective concentration., Methods: We screened 323 women. 172 with red-cell folate between 150 micrograms/L and 400 micrograms/L were invited to take part in the trial. 121 women were randomly assigned placebo or 100 micrograms, 200 micrograms, or 400 micrograms daily of additional folic acid. Compliance was monitored by having the women sign a dated sheet when taking the tablet. 95 women completed the 6-month study., Findings: There were significant increases in red-cell folate in all folic acid groups. The placebo group showed no significant change. The median incremental changes and median post-treatment concentrations were 67 micrograms/L (95% CI 43-120) and 375 micrograms/L (354-444) in the 100 micrograms/day group, 130 micrograms/L (108-184) and 475 micrograms/L (432-503) in the 200 micrograms/day group, and 200 micrograms/L (125-312) and 571 micrograms/L (481-654) in the 400 micrograms/day group., Interpretation: A fortification programme that delivered 400 micrograms folic acid daily to women would protect against NTD, but at the expense of unnecessarily high exposure for many people. Delivery of 200 micrograms daily is also effective against NTD and safer for the general population. Based on projections from the positive folate balance in the group that received 100 micrograms daily, this dose taken continually, as it will be in fortified food, will also produce an important decrease in NTD.

Background: The dietary reference values for folate, as for other nutrients, are targeted to the general and supposedly normal population, not people with special needs, such as those with genetic or metabolic abnormalities or diseases. However, 5-15% of general populations are homozygous for a thermolabile variant of 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (C677T) which causes mild hyperhomocysteinaemia and is positively associated with the development of vascular disease and the risk of neural-tube defects. If tissue-folate status is compromised in large sectors of the population by this or other genetic variants, the present dietary reference values may need to be changed., Methods: We identified the C677T genotype and measured red-cell folate concentrations in two groups of healthy women (pregnant, 242, not pregnant, 318). We then analysed the effect of genotype on red-cell folates, which are a reliable marker for tissue folate stores., Findings: In the pregnant group there were 20 TT homozygotes, 114 wild-type CC homozygotes, and 108 CT heterozygotes. In the non-pregnant group, the numbers were 41, 148, and 129. In both pregnant and non-pregnant groups, red-cell folate was significantly lower among TT homozygous than CC homozygous women (mean 252 [95% CI 202-317] vs 347 [321-372] micrograms/L, p = 0.002 for pregnant women; 284 [250-327] vs 347 [342-372] micrograms/L, p = 0.01 for non-pregnant women). Plasma folate was also significantly lower in TT homozygous than in CC homozygous women in the pregnant group (p = 0.009) but not in the non-pregnant group., Interpretation: These results suggest that a substantial minority of people in general populations may have increased folate needs. Future studies may show the presence of other common genetic variants that interact with particular nutrients and place doubts on the validity of assuming "normality" for nutrient requirements in any general population.

Folic acid taken around the time of conception can prevent many neural-tube defects. Women with low-normal vitamin B12 values may also be at increased risk. We considered whether homocysteine metabolism via the enzyme methionine synthase, which requires both folate and B12, could be the critical defect in folate-related neural tube defects. Blood was obtained during pregnancies that produced 81 infants with neural-tube defects and 323 normal children. Samples were assayed for homocysteine, methylmalonic acid, plasma folate, red-cell folate, and B12. Mothers of children with neural-tube defects had significantly higher homocysteine values (8.62 [SD 2.8] mumol/L) than did B12-matched controls (7.96 [2.5] mumol/L, p = 0.03). The difference was significant (p = 0.004) in the lower half of the B12 distribution after adjusting for plasma folate. Our study shows that an abnormality in homocysteine metabolism, apparently related to methionine synthase, is present in many women who give birth to children with neural-tube defects. Overcoming this abnormality is likely to be the mechanism by which folic acid prevents neural-tube defects. These findings suggest that the most effective periconceptional prophylaxis to prevent neural-tube defects may require B12 as well as folic acid.