Search

Findings from empirical research serve as the foundation for neuropsychological assessment of individuals suspected of exposure to formaldehyde, Insofar as conclusions regarding causal relationships between exposure and neuropsychological deficits are based on research methodologies that are reliable, findings can be informative. Unfortunately, existing research is not rooted in sound methodology and findings may mislead rather than enlighten clinicians. Two prominent shortcomings in formaldehyde research are discussed: selection bias in recruitment of research participants and unreliability of participant recall for obtaining data on important background variables and exposure levels. Selected examples illustrate the influence of these shortcomings on research showing a causal relationship between long-term, low-level exposure to formaldehyde and chronic neurobehavioral deficiencies. The implications of these weaknesses for assessment of individual patients are discussed.

The health effects of long-term. low-level exposure to organic solvents have been studied for many years. While the volume of literature is great, definitive conclusions regarding chronic neurobehavioral effects of environmental exposure are premature. Methodological shortcomings in research preclude confidence in studies allegedly supporting a causal link between chronic low-dose solvent exposure and lasting neurobehavioral deficits. In this article, the shortcomings reviewed include selection bias in recruitment of research subjects, overreliance on subjective recall in determining levels and duration of exposure, between-study variability in kinds of solvents examined, variability in tests selected to assess neurobehavioral functioning, and diversity in reported findings. The implications of these for characterizing the state of organic solvent research are discussed.

Psychologists should keep in mind the base rate of symptoms in those prone to litigation and use caution in relying on self-reports as evidence of injury when these people litigate. Personal injury claimants in a survey had more neurotoxic and neuropsychologic complaints than subjects with head trauma or toxic exposure in their medical histories.