Search

Purpose: The Pediatric Normal Tissue Effects in the Clinic (PENTEC) hearing loss (HL) task force reviewed investigations on cochlear radiation dose-response relationships and risk factors for developing HL. Evidence-based dose-response data are quantified to guide treatment planning., Methods and Materials: A systematic review of the literature was performed to correlate HL with cochlear dosimetry. HL was considered present if a threshold exceeded 20 dB at any frequency. Radiation dose, ototoxic chemotherapy exposure, hearing profile including frequency spectra, interval to HL, and age at radiation therapy (RT) were analyzed., Results: Literature was systematically reviewed from 1970 to 2021. This resulted in 739 abstracts; 19 met inclusion for meta-analysis, and 4 included data amenable to statistical modeling. These 4 studies included 457 cochleas at risk in patients treated with RT without chemotherapy, and 398 cochlea treated with chemotherapy. The incidence and severity of cochlear HL from RT exposure alone is related to dose and age. Risk of HL was <5% in cochlea receiving a mean dose ≤35 Gy but increased to 30% at 50 Gy. HL risk ranged from 25% to 40% in children under the age of 5 years at diagnosis, declining to 10% in older children for any radiation dose. Probability of similar severe HL occurred at doses 18.3 Gy higher for children <3 versus >3 years of age. High-frequency HL was most common, with average onset occurring 3.6 years (range, 0.4-13.2 years) after RT. Exposure to platinum-based chemotherapies added to the rates of HL at a given cochlear dose level, with 300 mg/m 2 shifting the dose response by 7 Gy., Conclusions: In children treated with RT alone, risk of HL was low for cochlear dose <35 Gy and rose when dose exceeded 35 Gy without clear RT dose dependence. High-frequency HL was most prevalent, but all frequencies were affected. Children younger than 5 years were at highest risk of developing HL, although independent effects of dose and age were not fully elucidated. Future reports with more granular data are needed to better delineate time to onset of HL and the effects of chemoradiotherapy., (Published by Elsevier Inc.)

Purpose: The PENTEC (Pediatric Normal Tissue Effects in the Clinic) task force aimed to quantify effects of radiation therapy (RT) dose to the female reproductive organs after treatment for childhood cancer., Methods and Materials: Relevant studies published 1970 to 2017 were identified systematically through PubMed, Medline, and Cochrane databases with additional articles before 2021 identified by the group. Two large studies reported sufficient data to allow modeling of acute ovarian failure (AOF; loss of function ≤5 year from diagnosis) and premature ovarian insufficiency (POI; loss of function at attained age <40 years) based on maximum dose to least affected ovary. Although normal tissue complication probability modeling was not feasible for the uterus due to limited data, the relationship between ultrasound-measured uterine volume and estimated amount of RT was plotted. Limited data regarding vaginal toxicity were available., Results: The risk of AOF increases with RT dose to least affected ovary, alkylating agent cumulative dose (cyclophosphamide equivalent dose [CED] in g/m 2 ), age at RT, and stem cell transplantation: Two Gy to the least affected ovary resulted in AOF risk of 1% to 5% (CED = 0, risk increasing with age), 4% to 7% (CED = 10 g/m 2 , risk increasing with age), and 6% to 13% (CED = 30 g/m 2 , risk increasing with age). For patients aged 1 and 20 years at time of RT, AOF risk was ≥50% at doses of 24 Gy and 20 Gy with no alkylating chemotherapy, 22.5 Gy and 17 Gy with intermediate alkylator dose (10 g/m 2 ), and 17 Gy and 13 Gy with high alkylator dose (30 g/m 2 ). Risk of POI increases with survivor (attained) age (rather than age at time of RT), radiation dose to least affected ovary, and alkylator dose. Data review suggested that higher radiation doses to the uterus are associated with uterine toxicity, with uterine size considerably restricted after 12 Gy. Vaginal radiation in children is associated with high toxicity risk, although dose-volume data are not available for quantification., Conclusions: Risk of AOF increases with age at RT, CED exposure, and RT dose; risk of POI likewise increases with RT dose, CED exposure, and survivor age. Both AOF and POI are expected to affect fertility and estrogen production. Data suggest that RT uterine dose >12 Gy may be associated with uterine size restriction. Adult literature suggests that maintaining vaginal dose <5 Gy may limit toxicity. Treatment of life-threatening malignancy remains a priority over reproductive preservation; however, when possible, radiation and surgical techniques should be considered to minimize dose to least affected ovary, uterus, and vagina. Survivors should receive endocrine and gynecologic support; those desiring pregnancy should be counseled early to maximize reproductive options., (Copyright © 2023 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)

At its very core, radiation oncology involves a trade-off between the benefits and risks of exposing tumors and normal tissue to relatively high doses of ionizing radiation. This trade-off is particularly critical in childhood cancer survivors (CCS), in whom both benefits and risks can be hugely consequential due to the long life expectancy if the primary cancer is controlled. Estimating the normal tissue-related risks of a specific radiation therapy plan in an individual patient relies on predictive mathematical modeling of empirical data on adverse events. The Pediatric Normal-Tissue Effects in the Clinic (PENTEC) collaborative network was formed to summarize and, when possible, to synthesize dose-volume-response relationships for a range of adverse events incident in CCS based on the literature. Normal-tissue clinical radiation biology in children is particularly challenging for many reasons: (1) Childhood malignancies are relatively uncommon-constituting approximately 1% of new incident cancers in the United States-and biologically heterogeneous, leading to many small series in the literature and large variability within and between series. This creates challenges in synthesizing data across series. (2) CCS are at an elevated risk for a range of adverse health events that are not specific to radiation therapy. Thus, excess relative or absolute risk compared with a reference population becomes the appropriate metric. (3) Various study designs and quantities to express risk are found in the literature, and these are summarized. (4) Adverse effects in CCS often occur 30, 50, or more years after therapy. This limits the information content of series with even very extended follow-up, and lifetime risk estimates are typically extrapolations that become dependent on the mathematical model used. (5) The long latent period means that retrospective dosimetry is required, as individual computed tomography-based radiation therapy plans gradually became available after 1980. (6) Many individual patient-level factors affect outcomes, including age at exposure, attained age, lifestyle exposures, health behaviors, other treatment modalities, dose, fractionation, and dose distribution. (7) Prospective databases with individual patient-level data and radiation dosimetry are being built and will facilitate advances in dose-volume-response modeling. We discuss these challenges and attempts to overcome them in the setting of PENTEC., (Copyright © 2023 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)