Search

To verify the clinical efficacy of the Desmet classification of chronic hepatitis C we reviewed 801 liver biopsies from patients with HCV-chronic hepatitis (CH). The diagnosis of chronic hepatitis was assessed according to the Desmet classification based on the Knodell Histological Activity Index (HAI) (minimal CH=score 1-3; mild CH= 4-8; moderate CH= 9-12; severe CH= 13-18). Liver fibrosis was assessed according to the Scheuer scoring system. One hundred forty-eight patients had cirrhosis and 653 CH. Of these 653, according to the Desmet classification 145 patients showed minimal, 424 mild, 73 moderate and 11 severe chronic hepatitis. Since the classification underestimated the moderate and severe forms of HCV-related chronic hepatitis, we evaluated the possibility of improving the Desmet classification of chronic hepatitis C using our classification: minimal CH= score 1-3; mild CH= 4-6; moderate CH= 7-8; severe CH= 9-18. According to our classification 145 showed minimal CH, 363 mild CH, 61 moderate CH and 84 severe CH. All the 61 patients who crossed over from mild CH under the Desmet to moderate CH under our classification showed a periportal inflammation of grade 3, and all the 73 patients but 8 who crossed over from moderate to severe showed a grade of periportal inflammation higher than 3. The Desmet classification of HCV-related chronic hepatitis underestimated the severe forms of HCV-CH, while our classification seems to be suitable also for chronic hepatitis C.

This case-control study evaluated the real need for liver biopsy in subjects with persistently normal aminotransferase values over a long period by comparing the histological features of these subjects with those of patients with abnormal aminotransferase values. We considered as "Cases" all 32 consecutive anti-HCV/HCV-RNA positive subjects with at least eight normal serum ALT values during the last twelve months; for each "Case", we selected as a "Control" one anti-HCV/HCV-RNA positive patient with at least two abnormal serum ALT values during the last twelve months. The Cases and Controls were matched for age ( 5 years) and sex. In the Case group, 1 subject showed normal liver tissue, 18 minimal chronic hepatitis (CH) and 13 mild CH. In the Control group, 7 subjects showed minimal CH, 19 mild CH, 3 moderate CH, 1 severe CH and 2 cirrhosis. The subjects in the Control group showed a significantly higher HAI score (5.39+2.81) than those in the Case group (2.96+1.62, p < 0.001). The subjects in the Control group more frequently showed a fibrosis score greater than 1 (28.1%) compared to the Case group (9.4%; p<0.05). Finally, steatosis was more frequent and more severe in the Control group than in the Case group (respectively, 78.1% vs 50%, p < 0.05; and 1.47+1.16 vs 0.6+0.71, p < 0.001). The HAI and fibrosis scores did not correlate with the ALT value, HCV genotype or HCV viral load in either the Case or Control group. Our findings showed that the subjects with a persistently normal serum ALT value had minimal or mild chronic hepatitis, thus demonstrating that a liver biopsy is not indicated for these subjects.