Search

B-cell receptor (BCR)-mediated signals provide the basis for B-cell differentiation in the BM and subsequently into follicular, marginal zone, or B-1 B-cell subsets. We have previously shown that B-cell-specific expression of the constitutive active E41K mutant of the BCR-associated molecule Bruton's tyrosine kinase (Btk) leads to an almost complete deletion of immature B cells in the BM. Here, we report that low-level expression of the E41K or E41K-Y223F Btk mutants was associated with reduced follicular B-cell numbers and significantly increased proportions of B-1 cells in the spleen. Crosses with 3-83 mu delta and VH81X BCR Tg mice showed that constitutive active Btk expression did not change follicular, marginal zone, or B-1 B-cell fate choice, but resulted in selective expansion or survival of B-1 cells. Residual B cells were hyperresponsive and manifested sustained Ca(2+) mobilization. They were spontaneously driven into germinal center-independent plasma cell differentiation, as evidenced by increased numbers of IgM(+) plasma cells in spleen and BM and significantly elevated serum IgM. Because anti-nucleosome autoantibodies and glomerular IgM deposition were present, we conclude that constitutive Btk activation causes defective B-cell tolerance, emphasizing that Btk signals are essential for appropriate regulation of B-cell activation.

Accumulation of plasma cells and autoantibodies against nuclear antigens characterize both human and murine lupus. Understanding how these processes are controlled may reveal novel therapeutic targets for this disease. Mice deficient in Lyn, a negative regulator of B and myeloid cell activity, develop lupus-like autoimmune disease. Here, we show that lyn(-) (/) (-) mice exhibit increased splenic plasmablasts and plasma cells and produce IgM against a wide range of self-antigens. Both events require Btk, a target of Lyn-dependent inhibitory pathways. A Btk-dependent increase in the expression of the plasma cell survival factor IL-6 by lyn(-) (/) (-) splenic myeloid cells was also observed. Surprisingly, IL-6 was not required for plasma cell accumulation or polyclonal IgM autoreactivity in lyn(-/-) mice. IL-6 was, however, necessary for the production of IgG autoantibodies, which we show are focused towards a limited set of nucleic acid-containing and glomerular autoantigens in lyn(-) (/) (-) mice. A similar uncoupling of plasma cell accumulation from IgG autoantibodies was seen in lyn(+/-) mice. Plasma cell accumulation and polyclonal IgM autoreactivity are therefore controlled separately from, and are insufficient for, the production of IgG against lupus-associated autoantigens. Regulators of either of these two checkpoints may be attractive therapeutic targets for lupus.

Anti-DNA knock-in mice serve as models for studying B cell tolerance mechanisms to a ubiquitous antigen. We have constructed six strains of double transgenic (C57BL/6xBALB/c)F1 mice, each expressing an unmutated or somatically mutated anti-DNA heavy (H) chain, combined with one of three different light (L) chains, namely V(kappa)1-J(kappa)1, V(kappa)4-J(kappa)4 and V(kappa)8-J(kappa)5. In vitro analysis of the various Ig H/L chain combinations showed that all had a similar specificity for single-stranded DNA and double-stranded DNA, but that antibodies encoded by the mutated H chain had higher affinities for the autoantigen. None of the targeted mouse strains exhibited significant levels of serum anti-DNA activity. However, while B cells from mice carrying the V(kappa)1-J(kappa)1 transgenic L chains were tolerized almost exclusively by L chain receptor editing in an affinity-independent manner, the mice expressing V(kappa)8-J(kappa)5 L chains have utilized affinity-dependent clonal anergy as their sole mechanism of B cell tolerance. V(kappa)4-J(kappa)4 targeted mice exhibited an intermediate phenotype with respect to these two mechanisms of B cell tolerance. Our results suggest that receptor editing is the preferred mechanism of B cell tolerance and that the efficiency of L chain editing is directly related to the number of available J(kappa) segments on the expressed V(kappa) allele.

To determine the contribution of the somatic point mutations and that of the complementarity-determining region (CDR)3 Arg to DNA binding, we engineered the germline V(H) and V(kappa) gene revertant and site-mutagenized the CDR3 Arg residues of the mutated and "antigen-selected" mAb 412.67. This anti-DNA autoantibody was derived from B-1 cells of a lupus patient and bore two H-CDR3 Arg, Arg105 and Arg107, encoded by N segment additions, and one kappa-CDR3 Arg, Arg97, resulting from a point mutation (Kasaian et al. 1994. J. Immunol. 152: 3137-3151; Kasaian et al. 1995. Ann. N.Y Acad. Sci. 764: 410-423). The germ-line revertant bound double-stranded (ds) DNA and single-stranded (ss) DNA as effectively as its wild-type counterpart (relative avidity: 6.4x10(-7) and 9.9x10(-9) vs. 6.7x10(-7) and 9.1 x10(-9) g/microl), raising the possibility that an antigen other than DNA was responsible for the selection of the mAb 412.67 V(H) and V(kappa) point mutations. H-CDR3 Arg105 and Arg107 were both required for dsDNA binding, but either Arg105 or Arg107 was sufficient for ssDNA binding. The central role of Arg105 and Arg107 in DNA binding reflected their solvent-exposed orientation at the apex of the H-CDR3 main loop. Consistent with its inward orientation afar from the antigen-binding surface, the kappa-CDR3 Arg97 played no role in either dsDNA or ssDNA binding.

The importance of microbial infection as a trigger for the induction of systemic lupus erythematosus is frequently debated. Clinical observations indicate that anti-viral and antibacterial responses are often accompanied by self reactivity, and anti-pneumococcal antibodies elicited in non-autoimmune individuals by pneumococcal vaccine express lupus-associated anti-DNA idiotypes. To explore the relationship between protective and pathogenic antibodies in humans, we have used the phage display immunoglobulin expression system to generate a combinatorial library from spleen cells of a lupus patient immunized with a polyvalent pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine prior to splenectomy. From this library, monovalent antigen-binding fragments expressing the 3I Vkappa1-associated idiotype were isolated. This idiotype is expressed on up to 90% of anti-DNA antibodies in the serum of lupus patients and on anti-pneumococcal antibodies in the serum of non-autoimmune individuals. Eight 3I+ monovalent antigen-binding fragments reacting with pneumococcal polysaccharide, DNA or both were analyzed. Four of these fragments were cross-reactive with both foreign and self antigen, demonstrating that a high percentage of anti-bacterial antibodies produced in a patient with lupus bind double-stranded DNA. These studies provide support at the molecular level for a potential role of molecular mimicry in the generation of anti-DNA antibodies. In addition, this is, to our knowledge, the first panel of fully sequenced human anti-pneumococcal antibodies.

One of the challenges in the study of autoimmunity is to understand which autoreactive cells are subject to regulation and what mechanisms of regulation are operative. In mice transgenic for the R4A-gamma2b heavy chain of an anti-double stranded (ds) DNA antibody, the gamma2b heavy chain can pair with the full spectrum of endogenous light chains to produce a multitude of antibodies, including anti-dsDNA antibodies of different affinities and fine specificities. We have previously demonstrated the existence of two populations of anti-DNA B cells in non-autoimmune hosts: a high-affinity population which is rendered anergic in vivo, and a second high-affinity population which is deleted. We have now identified a third population of dsDNA-binding B cells. These cells produce germ-line-encoded antibodies with an apparent affinity for dsDNA that is 1 to 4 logs lower than the apparent affinities of antibodies made by anergic or deleted B cells, and represent a non-tolerized population which escapes regulation. Based on its characterization, we can define a molecular threshold for tolerance induction, and can speculate on the fate of these B cells when they are recruited to an immune response and undergo somatic mutation to become high-affinity anti-DNA B cells.

Antibodies binding to double-stranded (ds) DNA are strongly associated with renal involvement in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). We have generated two new IgG DNA-binding monoclonal antibodies (mAb), RH-14 and DIL-6, from the peripheral blood lymphocytes of two SLE patients with glomerulonephritis using the heteromyeloma cell line CB-F7. RH-14 is an IgG1 lambda antibody which also bound to single-stranded DNA, histones and nucleosomes. DIL-6 is an IgG3 lambda antibody with restricted antigen binding specificity. cDNA encoding the variable regions of the heavy (V(H)) and light (V(L)) chains of RH-14 was sequenced and the antigen binding site of this mAb was computer modelled. Sequence analysis of V(H) and V(L) regions of RH-14 showed that V(H) is derived from germ-line gene V3-7, a member of the V(H)3 family, and V(L) is derived from DPL 11, a member of the V(lambda)2 family. Somatic mutations and basic amino acid residues are identified in the complementarity-determining regions of both V(H) and V(L) regions. The nephritogenic properties of these mAb were analyzed by implanting and growing the hybridoma cells secreting the mAb in the peritoneum of SCID mice. The animals that received the RH-14 hybridoma produced higher levels of proteinuria (3 to > or = 4) (p < 0.001) compared to the groups that received DIL-6 (trace to > or = 1) or CB-F7 (trace). Electron microscopy of kidney sections from all the RH-14-implanted animals showed granular immunoglobulin deposition in the renal glomerular capillaries and mesangium. In this study we have shown for the first time using electron microscopy that a human IgG anti-dsDNA mAb, RH-14, is nephritogenic and that deposition of such an antibody alone is sufficient to induce renal damage.

To investigate the molecular properties of anti-DNA from lpr mice that express high levels of anti-DNA without immune-mediated nephritis, the sequences of VH and V kappa genes encoding 11 monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies derived from C3H-lpr/lpr (C3H-lpr) mice were studied. All of the C3H-lpr monoclonal anti-DNA bound single-stranded DNA while five also bound double-stranded DNA. Two of the hybridomas were clonally related as determined by Southern analysis and sequencing. Sequence analysis of C3H-lpr anti-DNA revealed the use of VH genes that encode anti-DNA from the MRL-lpr/lpr and (NZB X NZW) F1 mouse models of lupus, although differences occurred in the VH CDR3 amino acid content. In contrast, the V kappa genes from C3H-lpr mice lacked significant identity with previously reported V kappa genes for anti-DNA from lupus models. These results indicate that anti-DNA from C3H-lpr mice differ from anti-DNA from lupus mice with nephritis in patterns of V gene expression and suggest a molecular basis for the lack of pathogenicity of anti-DNA in these mice.

Four monoclonal antibodies (mAb) derived from an (NZB x NZW)F1 mouse bound to nucleosomes, total histones and to the H2A-H2B dimers but not to individual histones or DNA. Sequencing of their heavy (H)- and light (L)-chain variable region genes showed that they derived by somatic mutations from the same B cell precursor. The distribution of negatively and positively charged amino acids in the H-chain complementarity-determining regions was very similar to that observed not only in anti-H2A-H2B mAb derived from different lupus-prone mouse strains but also in anti-DNA mAb. Combined analysis of the mAb structures and their interactions with immobilized H2A-H2B dimer or total histones by plasmon resonance allowed us to assign the H-chain mutations a major role in the binding profiles of these anti-nucleosome mAb. Interestingly, four of the five H-chain mutations that distinguished mAb 3F6 from 2E1 generated negatively or positively charged amino acid residues, and two of them occurred at positions 56 and 76, which are frequently involved in the maturation process of anti-DNA antibodies. A modeling study of the 3F6 variable fragment (Fv) predicted that acidic residues occupy the cleft of the Ab combining site and have the potential to participate in electrostatic interactions. Thus, the demonstration that (NZB x NZW)F1-derived anti-H2A-H2B antibodies share certain structural features and mutation patterns with anti-DNA mAb suggest that common selection and maturation processes account for the production of these lupus-related autoantibodies.

Autoantibodies to ribonucleoproteins (RNP) occur prominently in human systemic lupus erythematosus and murine lupus models. In previous studies we demonstrated a relationship in MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr (MRL/lpr) mice between antibodies to Sm, an RNP autoantigen, and antibodies to DNA. Thus, many anti-Sm monoclonals bound DNA and expressed the same V region genes as anti-DNA. In addition, many had multiple VHCDR3 Arg residues suggestive of selection by DNA, and some had somatic mutations suggesting selection for mutant B cells by DNA. To determine whether autoantibodies to other RNP antigens are also associated with the anti-DNA response, we have analyzed the response to the La RNP. Six anti-La B cell hybridomas were generated from a single MRL/lpr mouse. Southern blot analysis of Ig V gene rearrangements and V gene sequences indicated two clonally related pairs, suggesting an oligoclonal response. Antibodies from all six hybridomas bound single-stranded DNA, while antibodies from five hybridomas bound double-stranded DNA. Two hybridomas expressed a VH7183 gene which is used by members of two previously reported anti-DNA clones and two anti-Sm/DNA clones of MRL/lpr origin. These data demonstrate an association between the anti-La and anti-DNA responses in MRL/lpr mice, suggesting that cross-reactive anti-RNP and anti-DNA responses are a general feature of autoimmunity in this lupus model.

Ten percent of human lupus syndromes occur in patients as a result of treatment with certain medications. H-2s mice can produce autoantibodies following treatment with various drugs or heavy metals and they are a potential animal model of drug-induced lupus. We have examined nine anti-chromatin monoclonal antibodies (mAb) from A.SW mice that had been treated with either D-penicillamine or quinidine, two lupus-inducing drugs in humans. These mAb are specific either for DNA or histone-DNA complexes corresponding to nucleo-specific either for DNA or histone-DNA complexes corresponding to nucleosomes or subnucleosome particles. Only one mAb reacts with an unknown chromatin antigen. The V region sequences of six of these mAb were studied and are notable by several features. As previously observed in spontaneous autoantibodies to DNA or histone-DNA complexes, arginine or asparagine residues are found at critical locations throughout the V regions. Many of these residues, potentially important for binding to DNA or DNA-histone complexes, result either from somatic mutations or atypical VH-D-JH rearrangements. Another significant characteristic is that the VH genes of several D-penicillamine- or quinidine-induced mAb are most similar to those of anti-nucleolar mAb obtained from mercury-injected A.SW mice. The implications of these findings for the pathogenesis of spontaneous or induced autoimmunity are discussed.

Molecular events occurring during the process of generation of pathogenic immunoglobulin (Ig)G anti-DNA antibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) were studied using a newly established method. We analyzed the Ig variable (V) region gene sequence and DNA-binding activity of IgM and IgG anti-DNA monoclonal antibodies (mAb) from individual SLE-prone (NZB x NZW) F1 mice. The first event appeared to be clonal selection and expansion of IgM anti-DNA clones, in which several clones had intraclonal V gene mutations. Although the number of mutations was small, the mutated IgM clones were associated with an increase in DNA-binding activity. The somatic mutations located in complementarity-determining regions (CDR) and in framework regions (FR) of V genes were apparently related to changes in DNA-binding activity. IgG anti-DNA clones that progressively increased in number with aging had numerous somatic mutations in the V region genes and there was a pair of clones which showed an intraclonal accumulation of mutations, in association with increase in the DNA-binding activity. All these findings show that somatic mutations associated with affinity maturation of the V region begin immediately before isotype-switching from IgM to IgG of the clones that have been selected and expanded, in an antigen-driven manner and/or by other forces. We propose that further accumulations of intraclonal somatic hypermutation, in association with selection and expansion of high affinity IgG clones, may lead to formation of highly pathogenic anti-DNA antibodies.

The molecular mechanisms leading to anti-double-stranded (ds) DNA antibody production in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) are poorly understood. We describe here the immunoglobulin variable region genes of six human hybridomas secreting IgG anti-dsDNA antibodies derived from three SLE patients. The monoclonal IgG anti-dsDNA antibodies have been shown to be of high affinity and no multireactivity was observed (Winkler et al., Clin. Exp. Immunol., 1991. 85: 379). The comparison of the variable region genes expressed in the hybridomas with known germ-line genes as well as with the germ-line counterparts from one patient shows that the VH and VL sequences are somatically mutated. The pattern and extent of the observed somatic mutations are suggestive for an antigen-driven selection of at least four of these B cell clones. Several VH and VL genes used by the hybridomas were found to be expressed in the natural antibody repertoire, in the restricted fetal repertoire and in B cell malignancies expressing the CD5 antigen.

Among 15 anti-DNA antibody-producing hybridomas derived from a single NZB X NZW F1 mouse, an IgM and an IgG were shown to use the same VH gene of the Q52 family. Using a combination of two primers both consisting of a mixture of oligonucleotides (one complementary to the 5' end of VH segment and one to the 3' end of VH segment of Q52 family) we determined the sequences of several members of germ-line VH genes in the Q52 family derived from NZB and NZW strains. Comparison of the sequences with those of cloned VH cDNA obtained from the hybridomas revealed that the VH sequence of the IgM anti-DNA antibody was identical to that of a cloned NZW germ-line VH gene, except for the priming sites. In contrast, the VH sequence of the IgG counterpart contained somatically mutated nucleotides. Because the IgG anti-DNA antibody showed a higher DNA binding activity than did the IgM antibody, we conclude that these changes in nucleotide sequences were induced and selected through an antigen-driven mechanism as is the case in a normal immune response. It is tempting to speculate that the germ-line encoded, low-affinity IgM autoantibody undergoes somatic mutations and isotype switching, resulting in generation of pathogenic, high-affinity autoantibodies in autoimmune diseases.

The F1 progeny of autoimmune NZB and normal SWR mice uniformly develop severe and accelerated lupus nephritis. The (SWR x NZB)F1 mice produce an oligoclonally expanded population of nephritogenic anti-DNA autoantibodies that share a recurrent cross-reactive idiotype (Id564), use highly homologous VH genes and surprisingly have the CH region allotype of the normal SWR parent. From extensive library analyses, we isolated 15 SWR germ-line genes which are most closely related to the pathogenic autoantibody VH564 gene and which also belong to the NPb subfamily of J558 VH genes. We found that the pathogenic VH genes are probably somatic variants of a SWR germ-line VH gene, SW6-3, and they have several basic amino acid substitutions, in addition to those already present in the SW6-3 germ-line gene. Since these pathogenic autoantibodies are not detectable in the sera of the normal SWR mice despite the presence of the SW6-3 gene, strong selection and expansion of B cells expressing the SW6-3 VH gene is probably occurring in (SWR x NZB)F1 lupus-prone mice. We also isolated eight germ-line genes from the NZB mouse which are homologous to SW6-3. The autoimmune NZB parent that rarely develops nephritis lacks the SW6-3 gene, but has several highly homologous germ-line VH genes that would encode less cationic antibodies. These results establish a correlation between structure and pathogenic potential of VH genes.