Search

Dear Editor, We read with great interest the letter from Pelclova and Lach [[1]] on the efficacy of unithiol (2,3-dimercaptopropanesulfonate) and acetylcysteine in a patient with arthroplastic cobalt toxicity. Acetylcysteine increases cobalt urinary excretion and consistently maintains the serum cobalt concentration less than the threshold of 10 g/L, which we believe to be the goal in patients with metal-on-metal implants in order to minimise cobalt toxicity from the existing prosthesis [[3]]. The authors stated that chelation therapy, either with unithiol or acetylcysteine, is often clinically inefficient in patients with very elevated cobalt concentrations (greater than 100 g/L) as long as the damaged prosthesis remains I in situ i . [Extracted from the article]

We conclude that treatment with either unithiol or acetylcysteine is inefficient in patients with very elevated serum cobalt concentrations, especially greater than 100 µg/L, as long as the damaged prosthesis remains I in situ i . Dear Editor, Previously [[1]] we reported a 56-year-old man with severe cobalt poisoning from a damaged metal-on-ceramic hip prosthesis. However, her serum cobalt concentration reached 221 µg/L in February 2022 on the day of the surgery, which subsequently decreased to 51 µg/L 11 days after surgery, 10 µg/L 2.5 months after surgery, and 3 µg/L 6 months after surgery, all without further treatment. [Extracted from the article]

Context:Post-arthroplasty metallosis, which refers to metallic corrosion and deposition of metallic debris in the periprosthetic soft tissues of the body, is an uncommon complication. Systemic cobalt toxicity post-arthroplasty is extremely rare. The few known fatal cases of cobalt toxicity appear to be a result of replacing shattered ceramic heads with metal-on-metal or metal-on-polyethylene implants. Friction between residual shards of ceramic and cobalt–chromium implants allows release of cobalt into the synovial fluid and bloodstream, resulting in elevated whole blood cobalt levels and potential toxicity. Case details:This is a single patient chart review of a 60-year-old woman with prior ceramic-on-ceramic right total hip arthroplasty complicated by fractured ceramic components and metallosis of the joint. She underwent synovectomy and revision to a metal-on-polyethylene articulation. Ten months post-revision, she presented to the emergency department (ED) with right hip pain, dyspnea, worsening hearing loss, metallic dysgeusia, and weight loss. Chest CTA revealed bilateral pulmonary emboli (PE), and echocardiogram revealed new cardiomyopathy with global left ventricular hypokinesis with an ejection fraction (EF) of 35–40% inconsistent with heart strain from PE. Whole blood cobalt level obtained two days into her admission was 424.3 mcg/L and 24-h urine cobalt level was 4830.5 mcg/L. Although the patient initially clinically improved with regard to her PE and was discharged to home on hospital day 5, she returned 10 days later with a right hip dislocation and underwent closed reduction of the hip. The patient subsequently decompensated, developing cardiogenic shock, and respiratory failure. She went into pulseless electrical activity (PEA) and expired. Autopsy revealed an extensive metallic effusion surrounding the right hip prosthesis that tested positive for cobalt (41,000 mcg/L). There was also cobalt in the heart muscle tissue (2.5 mcg/g). A whole blood cobalt level obtained two days before she expired was 641.6 mcg/L. Discussion:This is a case of fatal cobalt-induced cardiomyopathy in a patient whose ceramic components of a total hip arthroplasty fractured causing metallosis with worsening cobalt toxicity. We recommend that when a fractured device is revised with a prosthesis with cobalt–chromium components, whole blood and urine cobalt measurements should be obtained and periodically monitored to evaluate for rising concentrations. Providers should be aware of clinical signs and symptoms of cobalt toxicity in patients who have prostheses with cobalt–chromium components. If suspected, toxicology and orthopedics should be involved for possible chelation and removal of the prosthesis. [ABSTRACT FROM PUBLISHER]

Introduction. There has been some recent concern regarding possible systemic health effects resulting from elevated blood cobalt concentrations in patients with cobalt containing hip implants. To date there are no blood cobalt criteria to help guide physicians when evaluating an individual hip implant patient's risk of developing systemic health effects because historically there was little or no concern about systemic cobalt toxicity in implant patients. Objective. Our purpose is to describe recently completed research regarding the relationship between blood cobalt concentrations and clinical health effects. We discuss the possibility of systemic health effects in patients with metal containing implants and propose various blood cobalt concentrations that are not associated with an increased risk of developing certain adverse effects. Methodology. The primary literature search was conducted using PubMed and Web of Science using the following search terms: cobalt AND (toxicity OR health effects OR cardiotoxicity OR hematological OR endocrine OR immunological OR reproductive OR testicular effects OR neurological OR case report OR cohort OR Roncovite). The searches identified 6786 papers of which 122 were considered relevant. The Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry toxicological profile for cobalt and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Research and Development's National Center for Environmental Assessment's documentation on the provisional peer-reviewed toxicity value for cobalt were also utilized to identify secondary literature sources. Results. Our review of the toxicology and medical literature indicates that highly elevated blood cobalt concentrations can result in certain endocrine, hematological, cardiovascular, and neurological effects in animals and/or humans. These studies, in addition to historical clinical findings involving the therapeutic use of cobalt, indicate that significant systemic effects of cobalt will not occur below blood cobalt concentrations of 300 μg/L in most persons. Some individuals with specific risk factors for increased susceptibility (e.g., severe and sustained hypoalbuminemia) may exhibit systemic effects at lower cobalt blood concentrations. This review also describes several cobalt dosing studies performed with human volunteers that consumed cobalt for 15, 30, or 90 days. Overall, the results of these dosing studies indicate that sustained blood cobalt concentrations averaging 10-70 μg/L for up to 90 days cause no significant clinical effects (maximum concentrations approached 120 μg/L). Some proposed blood criteria for assessing implant wear and local tissue damage have been suggested by several medical groups. For example, the UK Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency has proposed a blood cobalt guidance value of 7 μg/L, and the Mayo Clinic has suggested serum cobalt concentrations greater than 10 μg/L, but both of these values are primarily intended to address implant wear and to alert physicians to the possibility of an increased incidence of local effects. There is a clear lack of consensus regarding how to identify a specific numerical blood concentration of concern and whether whole blood or serum is a better matrix to assess total cobalt concentration. Conclusions. Based on currently available data, only under very unusual circumstances should a clinician expect that biologically important systemic adverse effects might occur in implant patients with blood cobalt concentrations less than 300 μg/L. Patients with metal-containing hip implants who exhibit signs or symptoms potentially related to polycythemia, hypothyroidism, neurological, or cardiac dysfunction should be clinically evaluated for these conditions. Polycythemia appears to be the most sensitive endpoint. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Introduction:Dicobalt edetate is one of a number of cobalt compounds that have been studied in the treatment of cyanide poisoning, their efficacy being based upon the fact that cyanide combines with cobalt to form relatively non-toxic complexes. Inorganic cobalt salts are quite toxic (cyanide and cobalt antagonise one another's toxicity) and complexes such as dicobalt edetate were studied with the aim of identifying compounds that were less acutely toxic, but which retained the antidotal properties of cobalt salts. The proprietary preparation, Kelocyanor™, contains free cobalt and glucose as well as dicobalt edetate. Objective:The aim of this study was to evaluate the published evidence for the efficacy and adverse effects of dicobalt edetate. Methods:A Pubmed search was undertaken for the period 1961–September 2015. The search terms were “dicobalt edetate”, “cobalt edetate” and “Kelocyanor”, which produced 24 relevant citations. A review of the references in four relevant books (L'intoxication cyanhydrique et son traitement,Clinical and Experimental Toxicology of Cyanides,Antidotes for Poisoning by CyanideandAntidotes) produced three further relevant papers, making a total of 27 papers. Efficacy of dicobalt edetate:There is evidence from animal pharmacodynamic studies that dicobalt edetate is an effective cyanide antidote in experimental animals. Some 39 cases of human poisoning treated with dicobalt edetate have been reported, but in only nine cases were blood cyanide concentrations measured, although administration of dicobalt edetate procured survival in four of the seven patients with concentrations in the lethal range (>3.0 mg/L). It is unlikely that death in any of the adequately documented fatal cases was attributable to treatment failure with dicobalt edetate, as it is probable that they all had suffered anoxic brain damage before treatment could be initiated. Furthermore, in one case, acute gold toxicity contributed substantially to death. Adverse effects of dicobalt edetate:Adverse effects reported have included hypertension, tachycardia, nausea, retrosternal pain, sweating, palpebral, facial and laryngeal oedema, vomiting, urticaria and/or a feeling of impending doom. Such effects appear to be more prevalent where the antidote has been administered without evidence of substantial systemic poisoning or where other antidotes have been used which might have been expected also to combine with cyanide. Although the adverse effects observed were doubtless unpleasant, and some were severe, no fatal reactions were found. Conclusions:Dicobalt edetate is an effective cyanide antidote when given to patients with systemic cyanide poisoning, but it has the potential to give rise to adverse reactions, particularly when administered in the absence of intoxication. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Context. With regard to biological effects, the increasing number of early failure of metal-on-metal (MoM) hip arthroplasties and possible parenteral exposure to orthopedic metal alloys have caused concern for patients and providers alike. Objective. We sought to characterize our outpatient clinical experience of patients with MoM and other forms of hip implants and associated serum/blood chromium and cobalt levels, with a focus on possible systemic sequelae. Methods. This was an observational and retrospective chart review of consecutive patients presenting to two outpatient medical toxicology clinics from January 1, 2010-June 1, 2012 with history of hip implants. Presenting signs, symptoms, and interventions were reviewed. Available cobalt and chromium levels were summarized as median concentration with interquartile range. Results. A total of 39 patients were analyzed; of the 39 patients, 26 had MoM hip implants while 13 did not. Twelve patients exhibited no symptoms and nine sought evaluation for fatigue while two other patients had been previously diagnosed with fibromyalgia. Tinnitus/hearing loss was also a frequent complaint noted in 12 patients (one presenting complaint), however there was no difference between the incidence of this symptom between the MoM and non-MoM groups. Three patients were provisionally diagnosed with demyelinating neuropathy with one patient demonstrating marked (subjective and objective) improvement after revision. Patients with MoM arthroplasties generally exhibit an approximately tenfold increase in metal ion levels than traditional arthroplasties. Finally, 20 (51.2%) patients had replacement or revision of their hip implant with subsequent decreases in metal ion levels. Discussion. A majority of our patients had minor symptoms (fatigue and muscle aches) or no symptoms (n = 23 or 59%). Documented peripheral neurotoxicity is uncommon. The decision for hip revision solely for toxicologic reasons is rare and usually involves a multidisciplinary approach. Conclusion. Most patients seeking toxicologic referral may be minimally symptomatic and seek guidance regarding elevated blood or serum metal ions; however, solely toxicologic-based interventions are unusual. Revision was associated with a decrease in metal ion levels; however, subjective complaints did not correlate with metal ion levels. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Context. Cobalt intoxication has become more frequent due to the wide use of metal hip implants. Case details. A 56-year-old male patient underwent total hip prosthesis, with a ceramics-on-ceramics implant. Almost 3 years later, it was replaced by metal implant containing cobalt, chromium, and titanium. He developed weight loss, heart, thyroid, and neurological toxicity, with severe hearing loss. He was treated with 2,3-dimercaptopropane-1-sulfonate (DMPS), and cobalt excretion increased. Clinical symptoms apart from deafness gradually resolved. Conclusion. We report significant cobalt poisoning from a damaged hip replacement with cobalt containing implant and a slow abrasion of the metal by residual ceramic particles. Chelation therapy resulted in apparent benefit. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]