Search

Members of the aspartase/fumarase superfamily share a common tertiary and quaternary fold, as well as a similar active site architecture; the superfamily includes aspartase, fumarase, argininosuccinate lyase, adenylosuccinate lyase, δ-crystallin, and 3-carboxy-cis,cis-muconate lactonizing enzyme (CMLE). These enzymes all process succinyl-containing substrates, leading to the formation of fumarate as the common product (except for the CMLE-catalyzed reaction, which results in the formation of a lactone). In the past few years, X-ray crystallographic analysis of several superfamily members in complex with substrate, product, or substrate analogues has provided detailed insights into their substrate binding modes and catalytic mechanisms. This structural work, combined with earlier mechanistic studies, revealed that members of the aspartase/fumarase superfamily use a common catalytic strategy, which involves general base-catalyzed formation of a stabilized aci-carboxylate (or enediolate) intermediate and the participation of a highly flexible loop, containing the signature sequence GSSxxPxKxN (named the SS loop), in substrate binding and catalysis.

Delta-crystallin, the major soluble protein component in the avian eye lens, is homologous to argininosuccinate lyase (ASL). Two delta-crystallin isoforms exist in ducks, delta1- and delta2-crystallin, which are 94% identical in amino acid sequence. While duck delta2-crystallin (ddeltac2) has maintained ASL activity, evolution has rendered duck delta1-crystallin (ddeltac1) enzymatically inactive. Previous attempts to regenerate ASL activity in ddeltac1 by mutating the residues in the 20s (residues 22-31) and 70s (residues 74-89) loops to those found in ddeltac2 resulted in a double loop mutant (DLM) which was enzymatically inactive (Tsai, M. et al. (2004) Biochemistry 43, 11672-82). This result suggested that one or more of the remaining five amino acid substitutions in domain 1 of the DLM contributes to the loss of ASL activity in ddeltac1. In the current study, residues Met-9, Val-14, Ala-41, Ile-43, and Glu-115 were targeted for mutagenesis, either alone or in combination, to the residues found in ddeltac2. ASL activity was recovered in the DLM by changing Met-9 to Trp, and this activity is further potentiated in the DLM-M9W mutant when Glu-115 is changed to Asp. The roles of Trp-9 and Asp-115 were further investigated by site-directed mutagenesis in wild-type ddeltac2. Changing the identity of either Trp-9 or Asp-115 in ddeltac2 resulted in a dramatic drop in enzymatic activity. The loss of activity in Trp-9 mutants indicates a preference for an aromatic residue at this position. Truncation mutants of ddeltac2 in which the first 8, 9, or 14 N-terminal residues were removed displayed either decreased or no ASL activity, suggesting residues 1-14 are crucial for enzymatic activity in ddeltac2. Our kinetic studies combined with available structural data suggest that the N-terminal arm in ASL/delta2-crystallin is involved in stabilizing regions of the protein involved in substrate binding and catalysis, and in completely sequestering the substrate from the solvent.

Argininosuccinate lyase (ASL) is a homotetrameric enzyme that catalyzes the reversible cleavage of argininosuccinate to arginine and fumarate. Deficiencies in the enzyme result in the autosomal, recessive disorder argininosuccinic aciduria. Considerable clinical and genetic heterogeneity is associated with this disorder, which is thought to be a consequence of the extensive intragenic complementation identified in patient strains. Our ability to predict genotype-phenotype relationships is hampered by the current lack of understanding of the mechanisms by which complementation can occur. The 3-dimensional structure of wild-type ASL has enabled us to propose that the complementation between two ASL active site mutant subunits, Q286R and D87G, occurs through a regeneration of functional active sites in the heteromutant protein. We have reconstructed this complementation event, both in vivo and in vitro, using recombinant proteins and have confirmed this hypothesis. The complementation events between Q286R and two nonactive site mutants, M360T and A398D, have also been characterized. The M360T and A398D substitutions have adverse effects on the thermodynamic stability of the protein. Complementation between either the M360T or the A398D mutant and the stable Q286R mutant occurs through the formation of a more stable heteromeric protein with partial recovery of catalytic activity. The detection and characterization of a novel complementation event between the A398D and D87G mutants has shown how complementation in patients with argininosuccinic aciduria may correlate with the clinical phenotype.

Argininosuccinate lyase (ASL) catalyzes the reversible breakdown of argininosuccinate to arginine and fumarate, a reaction involved in the biosynthesis of arginine in all species and in the production of urea in ureotelic species. In humans, mutations in the enzyme result in the autosomal recessive disorder argininosuccinic aciduria. Intragenic complementation has been demonstrated to occur at the ASL locus, with two distinct classes of ASL-deficient strains having been identified, the frequent and high-activity complementers. The frequent complementers participate in the majority of the complementation events observed and were found to be either homozygous or heterozygous for a glutamine to arginine mutation at residue 286. The three-dimensional structure of the frequently complementing allele Q286R has been determined at 2.65 A resolution. This is the first high-resolution structure of human ASL. Comparison of this structure with the structures of wild-type and mutant duck delta1 and delta2 crystallins suggests that the Q286R mutation may sterically and/or electrostatically hinder a conformational change in the 280's loop (residues 270-290) and domain 3 that is thought to be necessary for catalysis to occur. The comparison also suggests that residues other than R33, F333, and D337 play a role in maintaining the structural integrity of domain 1 and reinforces the suggestion that residues 74-89 require a particular conformation for catalysis. The electron density has enabled the structure of residues 6-18 to be modeled for the first time. Residues 7-9 and 15-18 are in type IV beta-turns and are connected by a loop. The conformation observed is stabilized, in part, by a salt bridge between the side chains of R12 and D18. Although the disease causing mutation R12Q would disrupt this salt bridge, it is unclear why this mutation has such a significant effect on the catalytic activity as residues 1-18 are disordered in all other delta-crystallin structures determined to date.

Delta-crystallins are the major structural eye lens proteins of most birds and reptiles and are direct homologues of the urea cycle enzyme argininosuccinate lyase. There are two isoforms of delta-crystallin, delta Iota and delta IotaIota, but only delta IotaIota crystallin exhibits argininosuccinate lyase (ASL) activity. At the onset of this study, the structure of argininosuccinate lyase/delta IotaIota crystallin with bound inhibitor or substrate analogue was not available. Biochemical and X-ray crystallographic studies had suggested that H162 may function as the catalytic base in the argininosuccinate lyase/delta IotaIota crystallin reaction mechanism, either directly or indirectly through the activation of a water molecule. The identity of the catalytic acid was unknown. In this study, the argininosuccinate substrate was modeled into the active site of duck delta IotaIota crystallin, using the coordinates of an inhibitor-bound Escherichia coli fumarase C structure to orient the fumarate moiety of the substrate. The model served as a means of identifying active site residues which are positioned to potentially participate in substrate binding and/or catalysis. On the basis of the results of the modeling, site-directed mutagenesis was performed on several amino acids, and the kinetic and thermodynamic properties of each mutant were determined. Kinetic studies reveal that five residues, R115, N116, T161, S283, and E296, are essential for catalytic activity. Determination of the free energy of unfolding/refolding of wild-type and mutant delta II crystallins revealed that all constructs exhibit similar thermodynamic stabilities. During the course of this work, the structure of an inactive delta IotaIota crystallin mutant with bound substrate was solved [Vallee et al. (1999) Biochemistry 38, 2425-2434], which has allowed the kinetic data to be interpreted on a structural basis.

The major soluble protein component of avian and reptilian eye lenses, delta crystallin, is highly homologous to the urea cycle enzyme, argininosuccinate lyase (ASL). In duck lenses there are two highly homologous delta crystallins, termed delta I and delta II, that are 94% identical in amino acid sequence. While delta II crystallin has been shown to exhibit ASL activity in vitro, delta I crystallin is inactive. The X-ray structure of a His to Asn mutant of duck delta II crystallin (H91N) has been determined to 2.5 A resolution using the molecular replacement technique. The overall fold of the protein is similar to other members of the superfamily to which this protein belongs, with the active site located in a cleft between three different monomers of the tetrameric protein. A reexamination of the kinetic properties of the H91N mutant reveals that the mutant has 10% wild-type activity. The Vmax of the mutant protein is identical to that of the wild-type protein, but a 10-fold increase in the Michaelis constant is seen, suggesting that His 91 is involved in binding the substrate. In an effort to determine the reasons for the loss of enzymatic activity in delta I crystallin, a structural comparison of the H91N mutant with the enzymatically inactive turkey delta I crystallin has been performed. This study revealed a remarkable similarity in the overall structures of the two proteins. Three regions of secondary structure do differ significantly between the two models; these include the N-terminal tail, a loop containing residues 76-91, and a cis versus trans peptide linkage at residue Thr 322. The cis to trans peptide variation appears to be an interspecies difference between turkey and duck and is therefore not directly involved in the loss of enzymatic activity. All the residues implicated in the catalytic mechanism are conserved in both the active and inactive proteins, and given the linearity of the relationship between the enzymatic activity of duck delta I/delta II heterotetramers and their delta II content (Piatigorsky & Horwitz, 1996), it is evident from the structure that only one of the three domains that contributes to the active site is responsible for the loss of activity in the delta I protein. Given the structural differences found in domain 1 (N-terminal tail and 76-91 loop), we postulate that these differences are responsible for the loss of catalytic activity in the delta I crystallin protein and that the delta I protein is inactive because it no longer binds the substrate.