Search

Maintenance of systemic homeostasis by kidney requires the coordinated response of diverse cell types. The use of single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNAseq) for patient tissue samples remains fraught with difficulties with cell isolation, purity, and experimental bias. The ability to characterize immune and parenchymal cells during transplant rejection will be invaluable in defining transplant pathology where tissue availability is restricted to needle biopsy fragments. Herein, we present feasibility data for multiplexing approach for droplet scRNAseq (Mux-Seq). Mux-Seq has the potential to minimize experimental batch bias and variation even with very small sample input. In this first proof-of-concept study for this approach, explant tissues from six normal and two transplant recipients after multiple early post-transplant rejection episodes leading to nephrectomy due to aggressive antibody mediated rejection, were pooled for Mux-Seq. A computational tool, Demuxlet was applied for demultiplexing the individual cells from the pooled experiment. Each sample was also applied individually in a single microfluidic run (singleplex) to correlate results with the pooled data from the same sample. Our applied protocol demonstrated that data from Mux-Seq correlated highly with singleplex (Pearson coefficient 0.982) sequencing results, with the ability to identify many known and novel kidney cell types including different infiltrating immune cells. Trajectory analysis of proximal tubule and endothelial cells demonstrated separation between healthy and injured kidney from transplant explant suggesting evolving stages of cell- specific differentiation in alloimmune injury. This study provides the technical groundwork for understanding the pathogenesis of alloimmune injury and host tissue response in transplant rejection and normal human kidney and provides a protocol for optimized processing precious and low input human kidney biopsy tissue for larger scale studies.

Inflammation posttransplant is directly linked to cell death programs including apoptosis and necrosis. Cell death leads to the release of cellular contents which can promote inflammation. Targeting of these pathways should be an effective strategy to prevent transplant rejection. Toll-like receptor 3 (TLR3) is emerging as a major endogenous sensor of inflammation. In this study, we assessed the role of TLR3 on cell death and transplant rejection. We showed that TLR3 is highly expressed on mouse microvascular endothelial cell (ECs) and the endothelium of cardiac grafts. We demonstrated that TLR3 interacting with dsRNA or self-RNA triggered apoptosis and necroptosis in ECs. Interestingly, TLR3-induced necroptosis led mitochondrial damage. Inhibition of the mitochondrial membrane permeability molecule Cyclophilin D prevented necroptosis in ECs. In vivo, endothelium damage and activities of caspase-3 and mixed lineage kinase domain-like protein were inhibited in TLR3-/- cardiac grafts compared with C57BL/6 grafts posttransplant (n = 5, p

Although end-organ damage caused by AL amyloidosis historically portends a poor prognosis, advances in therapy in combination with solid organ transplantation can lead to significant improvements in survival. Immunomodulatory agents (IMiDs), such as lenalidomide and pomalidomide, are an effective class of drugs in the treatment of AL amyloidosis. However, there is growing concern that these agents may precipitate acute transplant rejection via upregulation of interleukin-2 and inhibition of immune tolerance. This case series describes three patients who underwent orthotopic heart transplantation for AL amyloidosis and later had progression of their underlying plasma cell dyscrasia, leading to treatment with IMiD therapy. Two patients subsequently developed acute allograft rejection, including the first reported case of pomalidomide-associated allograft rejection. The third patient tolerated long-term therapy without signs of rejection: the first reported case of IMiD tolerability after heart transplant. These cases, together with a review of the literature, demonstrate variable outcomes and elucidate the potential risk of organ rejection associated with the use of IMiDs. When treatment with IMiDs is necessary, close surveillance and modification of immunosuppression may mitigate risks of rejection and complications.

Transplantation is invariably associated with programmed cell death including apoptosis and necrosis, resulting in delayed graft function and organ rejection. We have demonstrated the contribution of necroptosis to mouse microvascular endothelial cell (MVEC) death and transplant rejection. Organ injury results in the opening of mitochondrial permeability transition pores (mPTPs), which can trigger apoptotic molecules release that ultimately results in cell death. The effect of mPTPs in the necroptotic pathway remains controversial; importantly, their role in transplant rejection is not clear. In this study, tumor necrosis factor-α triggered MVECs to undergo receptor-interacting protein kinase family (RIPK1/3)-dependent necroptosis. Interestingly, inhibition of mPTP opening could also inhibit necroptotic cell death. Cyclophilin-D (Cyp-D) is a key regulator of the mPTPs. Both inhibition and deficiency of Cyp-D protected MVECs from necroptosis (n = 3, P < .00001). Additionally, inhibition of Cyp-D attenuated RIPK3-downstream mixed-lineage kinase domain-like protein phosphorylation. In vivo, Cyp-D-deficient cardiac grafts showed prolonged survival in allogeneic BALB/c mice posttransplant compared with wild-type grafts (n = 7, P < .0001). Our study results suggest that the mPTPs may be important mechanistic mediators of necroptosis in cardiac grafts. There is therapeutic potential in targeting cell death via inhibition of the mPTP-regulating molecule Cyp-D to prevent cardiac graft rejection.

Regulatory T cell (Treg) therapy using recipient-derived Tregs expanded ex vivo is currently being investigated clinically by us and others as a means of reducing allograft rejection following organ transplantation. Data from animal models has demonstrated that adoptive transfer of allospecific Tregs offers greater protection from graft rejection compared to polyclonal Tregs. Chimeric antigen receptors (CAR) are clinically translatable synthetic fusion proteins that can redirect the specificity of T cells toward designated antigens. We used CAR technology to redirect human polyclonal Tregs toward donor-MHC class I molecules, which are ubiquitously expressed in allografts. Two novel HLA-A2-specific CARs were engineered: one comprising a CD28-CD3ζ signaling domain (CAR) and one lacking an intracellular signaling domain (ΔCAR). CAR Tregs were specifically activated and significantly more suppressive than polyclonal or ΔCAR Tregs in the presence of HLA-A2, without eliciting cytotoxic activity. Furthermore, CAR and ΔCAR Tregs preferentially transmigrated across HLA-A2-expressing endothelial cell monolayers. In a human skin xenograft transplant model, adoptive transfer of CAR Tregs alleviated the alloimmune-mediated skin injury caused by transferring allogeneic peripheral blood mononuclear cells more effectively than polyclonal Tregs. Our results demonstrated that the use of CAR technology is a clinically applicable refinement of Treg therapy for organ transplantation.

The need for new approaches to define HLA antibodies, in the context of organ transplantation, is intensely debated among HLA professionals. In this review, we sought to provide background and perspective to current understanding of the immunogenicity of HLA mismatches with respect to the humoral alloimmune response and the definition of B cell epitopes. Initial data suggest that epitope matching not only assists in defining better matches for the current transplant, but also minimizes the risk of developing de novo HLA-donor-specific-antibodies posttransplant. In other words, other than lowering the risk of current graft rejection, epitope matching is likely to lower overall future sensitization levels and thus increases the likelihood of finding a compatible donor when the need for a retransplantation arises. More detailed knowledge of epitopes makes it possible to investigate what constitutes permissible versus non-permissible HLA mismatches. The currently available evidence suggest that epitope matching is the most rational way to decrease the risk of HLA-linked transplant rejection. This review is aimed at stimulating further and more intense collaborative effort in this field.

Recent developments in our understanding of vitamin D show that it plays a significant role in immunological health, uniquely occupying both an anti-microbial and immunoregulatory niche. Vitamin D deficiency is widespread amongst renal transplant recipients (RTRs), thus providing one patho-mechanism that may influence the achievement of a successful degree of immunosuppression. It may also influence the development of the infectious, cardiovascular and neoplastic complications seen in RTRs. This review examines the biological roles of vitamin D in the immune system of relevance to renal transplantation (RTx) and evaluates whether vitamin D repletion may be relevant in determining immunologically-related clinical outcomes in RTRs, (including graft survival, cardiovascular disease and cancer). While there are plausible biological and epidemiological reasons to undertake vitamin D repletion in RTRs, there are few randomized-controlled trials in this area. Based on the available literature, we cannot at present categorically make the case for routine measurement and repletion of vitamin D in clinical practice but we do suggest that this is an area in urgent need of further randomized controlled level evidence.

Long-term success of heart transplantation is hindered by humoral and cell-mediated immune responses. We studied preexisting antibodies to cardiac self-antigens, myosin and vimentin, and exosomes induced by antibodies to self-antigens in eliciting immune responses to cardiac grafts. After syngeneic heterotopic murine heart transplantation, rabbit anti-myosin or normal rabbit immunoglobulin was administered at day 0 or 7. Sera were collected after heartbeat cessation, cellular infiltration was analyzed, and exosomes were isolated from sera. Histopathologic examination of the controls' transplanted hearts demonstrated normal architecture, and their sera demonstrated neither antibodies to self-antigens nor exosomes expressing self-antigens. Administration of antibodies to cardiac myosin immediately posttransplantation (day 0) but not on day 7 triggered graft failure on day 7, and histopathologic examination revealed marked cellular infiltration with neutrophils and lymphocytes. Histopathologic examination of rejected hearts also demonstrated myocyte damage as sera had increased antibodies to myosin and vimentin and development of exosomes expressing self-antigens. Administration of exosomes isolated from failed grafts containing self-antigens induced graft dysfunction; exosomes isolated from stable mice did not induce graft failure. Antibodies to self-antigens can induce exosomes containing self-antigens, initiating an immune response and causing graft failure after cardiac transplantation.

Current therapies for transplant rejection are suboptimally effective. In an effort to discover novel immunosuppressants we used cytokine ELISPOT and ELISAs to screen extracts from 53 traditional Chinese herbs for their ability to suppress human alloreactive T cells. We identified a dichloromethane-soluble fraction (Qu Mai fraction AD [QMAD]) of Qu Mai (Dianthus superbus) as a candidate. High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis of QMAD revealed three dominant peaks, each with a MW ~600 Daltons and distinct from cyclosporine and rapamycin. When we added QMAD to human mixed lymphocyte cultures, we observed dose-dependent inhibition of proliferation and IFNγ production, by naïve and memory alloreactive T cells, and observed an increased frequency of Foxp3(+) CD4(+) T cells. To address whether QMAD induces regulatory T cells we added QMAD to anti-CD3/CD28-stimulated naïve CD4 T cells and observed a dose-dependent upregulation of Foxp3 associated with new suppressive capacity. Mechanistically, QMAD did not induce T cell IL-10 or TGFβ but blocked T cell AKT phosphorylation, a key signaling nexus required for T cell proliferation and expansion, that simultaneously prevents Foxp3 transcription. Our findings provide novel insight into the antiinflammatory effects of one traditional Chinese herb, and support the need for continued isolation, characterization and testing of QMAD-derived components as immune suppressants for transplant rejection.

The success of belatacept in late-stage clinical trials inaugurates the arrival of a new class of immunosuppressants based on costimulatory blockade, an immunosuppression strategy that disrupts essential signals required for alloreactive T-cell activation. Despite having improved renal function, kidney transplant recipients treated with belatacept experienced increased rates of acute rejection. This finding has renewed focus on costimulatory blockade-resistant rejection and specifically the role of alloreactive memory T cells in mediating this resistance. To study the mechanisms of costimulatory blockade-resistant rejection and enhance the clinical efficacy of costimulatory blockade, we developed an experimental transplant system that models a donor-specific memory CD8(+) T-cell response. After confirming that graft-specific memory T cells mediate costimulatory blockade-resistant rejection, we characterized the role of integrins in this rejection. The resistance of memory T cells to costimulatory blockade was abrogated when costimulatory blockade was coupled with either anti-VLA-4 or anti-LFA-1. Mechanistic studies revealed that in the presence of costimulatory blockade, anti-VLA-4 impaired T-cell trafficking to the graft but not memory T-cell recall effector function, whereas anti-LFA-1 attenuated both trafficking and memory recall effector function. As antagonists against these integrins are clinically approved, these findings may have significant translational potential for future clinical transplant trials.

While activation of serum complement mediates antibody-initiated vascular allograft injury, increasing evidence indicates that complement also functions as a modulator of alloreactive T cells. We tested whether blockade of complement activation at the C5 convertase step affects T cell-mediated cardiac allograft rejection in mice. The anti-C5 mAb BB5.1, which prevents the formation of C5a and C5b, synergized with subtherapeutic doses of CTLA4Ig to significantly prolong the survival of C57BL/6 heart grafts that were transplanted into naive BALB/c recipients. Anti-C5 mAb treatment limited the induction of donor-specific IFNγ-producing T cell alloimmunity without inducing Th2 or Th17 immunity in vivo and inhibited primed T cells from responding to donor antigens in secondary mixed lymphocyte responses. Additional administration of anti-C5 mAb to the donor prior to graft recovery further prolonged graft survival and concomitantly reduced both the in vivo trafficking of primed T cells into the transplanted allograft and decreased expression of T cell chemoattractant chemokines within the graft. Together these results support the novel concept that C5 blockade can inhibit T cell-mediated allograft rejection through multiple mechanisms, and suggest that C5 blockade may constitute a viable strategy to prevent and/or treat T cell-mediated allograft rejection in humans.

In murine models, mixed hematopoietic chimerism induction leads to robust immune tolerance. However, translation to primates and to patients has been difficult. In this study, we used a novel MHC-defined rhesus macaque model to examine the impact of MHC matching on the stability of costimulation blockade-/sirolimus-mediated chimerism, and to probe possible mechanisms of bone marrow rejection after nonmyeloablative transplant. Using busulfan-based pretransplant preparation and maintenance immunosuppression with sirolimus, as well as CD28 and CD154 blockade, all recipients demonstrated donor engraftment after transplant. However, the mixed chimerism that resulted was compartmentalized, with recipients demonstrating significantly higher whole blood chimerism compared to T cell chimerism. Thus, the vast majority of T cells presenting posttransplant were recipient-rather than donor-derived. Surprisingly, even in MHC-matched transplants, rejection of donor hematopoiesis predominated after immunosuppression withdrawal. Weaning of immunosuppression was associated with a surge of antigen-experienced T cells, and transplant rejection was associated with the acquisition of donor-directed T cell alloreactivity. These results suggest that a reservoir of alloreactive cells was present despite prior costimulation blockade and sirolimus, and that the post-immunosuppression lymphocytic rebound may have lead to a phenotypic shift in these recipient T cells towards an activated, antigen-experienced phenotype, and ultimately, to transplant rejection.

Decades of experiments in small animals had tipped the balance of opinion away from antibodies as a cause of transplant rejection. However, clinical experience, especially with sensitized patients, has convinced basic immunologists of the need to develop models to investigate mechanisms underlying antibody-mediated rejection (AMR). This resurgent interest has resulted in several new rodent models to investigate antibody-mediated mechanisms of heart and renal allograft injury, but satisfactory models of chronic AMR remain more elusive. Nevertheless, these new studies have begun to reveal many insights into the molecular and pathological sequelae of antibody binding to the allograft endothelium. In addition, complement-independent and complement-dependent effects of antibodies on endothelial cells have been identified in vitro. As small animal models become better defined, it is anticipated that they will be more widely used to answer further questions concerning mechanisms of antibody-mediated tissue injury as well as to design therapeutic interventions.

Patients developing posttransplant antibodies against HLA and non-HLA antigens expressed by the endothelium of the graft undergo more frequent episodes of rejection and have decreased long-term graft survival. Antibodies against the endothelium can alter/damage the cells of the graft through several mechanisms. Historically, antibodies were thought to elicit endothelial cell injury via complement-dependent mechanisms. New research has shown that antibodies can also contribute to the process of transplant rejection by stimulating proinflammatory and proproliferation signals. Antibody ligation leads to several functional alterations in EC including Weibel Palade body exocytosis, leukocyte recruitment, growth factor expression and cell proliferation. In contrast, under certain circumstances, antibodies may induce prosurvival signals and graft accommodation. The signaling events regulating accommodation vs. rejection appear to be influenced by the specificity and concentration of the anti-HLA antibody and the degree of molecular aggregation. Knowledge of the HLA and non-HLA antibody-mediated signaling pathways has the potential to identify new therapeutic targets to promote accommodation and prevent acute and chronic antibody-mediated rejection.

Chemokine-driven accumulation of lymphocytes, mononuclear and polymorphonuclear proinflammatory cells in antigenic tissue sites is a key feature of several types of T-cell-dependent autoimmunity and transplant rejection pathology. It is now clear that the immune system expends considerable energy to control this process, exemplified by the sequential layers of regulatory cell input, both innate and adaptive, designed to prevent a classical Type IV or 'delayed-type' hypersensitivity (DTH) reaction from occurring in the visual field of the eye. Yet, despite an abundance of in vitro assays currently available to the human T-cell immunologist, none of them adequately models the human DTH response and its various control features. The theme of this article is that it is relatively easy to model the effector side of the human DTH response with xenogeneic adoptive transfer models. However, we show that in order to detect inhibition of a recall DTH in response to colocalized donor antigen (linked suppression)--a characteristic feature of peripheral tolerance to an organ transplant--both the challenge site and the immunocompetence of the mouse adoptive host are critical factors limiting the sensitivity of the trans-vivo DTH test.

Diagnosis of intestinal transplant rejection depends on clinical assessment, endoscopy and most importantly, histology of intestinal biopsies. Plasma citrulline levels (P-Cit) reflect functional enterocyte mass in nontransplant patients and have been evaluated in two small series after transplant. This study was designed to determine the sensitivity and specificity of P-Cit as diagnostic tool for allograft injury, especially to distinguish between viral enteritis and rejection. We prospectively collected 403 P-Cit samples within 24 h of intestinal biopsy in 49 patients. P-Cit levels were correlated with the mucosal damage and histopathological diagnoses. P-Cit levels in bowels with significant mucosal damage (i.e. moderate or severe rejection, viral enteritis, PTLD, ischemia reperfusion injury, allergic enteritis) were significantly lower than in intestines with no or mild injury (i.e. indeterminate or mild rejection, nonspecific enteritis): 22.9 +/- 15.4 versus 38 +/- 23.2 nmol/mL (p < 0.0001). Sensitivity and specificity of the test were 80% and 58.1% for rejection, and 56.5% and 66% for viral enteritis, thereby unable to distinguish between both entities. In conclusion, P-Cit reflects the extent of mucosal injury regardless of the etiology, but does not seem to be a predictive marker for rejection or viral enteritis, as its values may decline only when diffuse mucosal damage has occurred.

The goal of this study was to determine the in vivo conditions that promote activation of the (CD4-independent) CD8+ T cell-mediated rejection pathway. We have previously noted that hepatocellular but not islet allografts readily activate this rejection pathway. In the current study, we utilized these two cell transplant models to investigate whether differences in host cell recruitment to the graft site, expression of T-cell activation markers by CD8+ graft infiltrating cells (GICs), and/or development of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) and cytotoxic T lymphocyte cell-mediated effector functions could account for the differential transplant outcomes. The collective results demonstrate that recruitment of CD8+ T cells to the site of transplant, CD103 or CD69 expression on CD8+ GICs, and activation of alloreactive DTH responses are insufficient to initiate CD4-independent, CD8-dependent transplant rejection. Instead, rejection by alloreactive (CD4-independent) CD8+ T cells correlated with expression of CD25, CD154 and CD43 by CD8+ GICs, in vitro alloproliferation by recipient CD8+ T cells, and the development of in vivo allospecific cytolytic effector function. These results suggest that tissue-derived factors influence the activation and maturation of (CD4-independent) CD8+ T cells into cytolytic effectors, which correlates with transplant rejection.

One of the defining lesions of kidney allograft rejection is epithelial deterioration and invasion by inflammatory cells (tubulitis). We examined epithelial changes and their relationship to effector T cells and to CD103/E-cadherin interactions in mouse kidney allografts. Rejecting allografts showed interstitial mononuclear infiltration from day 5. Loss of epithelial mass, estimated by tubular surface area, and tubulitis were minimal through day 7 and severe by day 21. Tubules in day 21 allografts manifested severe reduction of E-cadherin and Ksp-cadherin by immunostaining with redistribution to the apical membrane, indicating loss of polarity. By flow cytometry T cells isolated from allografts were 25% CD103+. Laser capture microdissection and RT-PCR showed increased CD103 mRNA in the interstitium and tubules. However, allografts in hosts lacking CD103 developed tubulitis, cadherin loss, and epithelial deterioration similar to wild-type hosts. The loss of cadherins and epithelial mass was also independent of perforin and granzymes A and B. Thus rejection is characterized by severe tubular deterioration associated with CD103+ T cells but not mediated by CD103/cadherin interactions or granzyme-perforin cytotoxic mechanisms. We suggest that alloimmune effector T cells mediate epithelial injury by contact-independent mechanisms related to delayed type hypersensitivity, followed by invasion of the altered epithelium to produce tubulitis.

Considerable economic and health-related costs are associated with the life-long maintenance immunosuppressive therapy required to prevent transplant rejection. Generic medications have the potential of providing equivalent therapeutic efficacy at a lower economic cost. In 2001, the American Society of Transplantation invited experts to review the data and issues associated with the approval and use of generic immunosuppressants. A summary of that meeting is reported here. The generic medication approval process has been in effect for more than 30 years. All marketed generic cyclosporin formulations have met FDA criteria demonstrating bioequivalence in healthy subjects, and some were also tested in transplant recipients. Most participants agreed that generic narrow therapeutic index immunosuppressive agents provide adequate de novo immunosuppression in low-risk transplant recipients. However, some participants expressed concern regarding the currently unquantified risk that may be associated with switching immunosuppressive agents under uncontrolled circumstances. There was broad agreement among the participants that generic medications should be clearly labeled and distinguishable from innovator drugs, and that patients should be educated to inform their physicians of any switch to or among generic alternatives. There was also strong support in favor of requiring studies to demonstrate bioequivalence in potentially at-risk patient populations, specifically African-Americans and pediatric patients.

Until recently, the vigorous T-cell response via the direct pathway has overshadowed studies involving the indirect pathway. Thus, while the direct pathway has previously been considered to be the main driving force in alloimmune responses, there is an increasing body of data to support a prominent role of the indirect pathway in transplant rejection. Most importantly, the direct antidonor alloresponse diminishes with time after transplantation, possibly due to the tolerogenic effects of alloantigen presentation by the parenchymal cells of the transplant. In contrast, the indirect alloresponse is likely to be permanently active, due to traffic of recipient dendritic cells (DCs) through the graft. The challenge that this poses in the pursuit of clinical transplant tolerance is how to induce tolerance in T cells with indirect allospecificity.

Allorecognition is initiated by CD4+ and CD8+ T cells recognizing either intact allo-MHC molecules (MHC class II and I, respectively) on donor antigen-presenting cells (APCs) (direct pathway) or allopeptides bound to self-MHC molecules on recipient APCs (indirect pathway) (1). The high precursor frequency of T cells capable of interacting directly with an allo-MHC molecule presumably accounts for the strength and polyclonality of the direct alloresponse, as observed during in vitro mixed leukocyte reactions (MLR). In contrast, T cells recognizing allopeptides on recipient MHC molecules (indirect pathway) are directed to a few dominant determinants and they display a limited T-cell receptor (TCR) Vβ gene usage (2–4). Likewise, it is traditionally accepted that direct alloreactivity represents the driving force behind early acute graft rejection. Alternatively, it is believed that the direct alloresponse rapidly subsides as donor passenger leukocytes vanish, while the indirect alloresponse persists and causes chronic rejection, presumably by promoting delayed-type hypersensitivity and the production of alloantibodies (5,6). However, these scenarios are based largely on circumstantial evidence and the actual contribution of direct versus indirect allorecognition to the alloresponse and transplant rejection remains open to question. In this issue of the American Journal of Transplantation, Brennan and colleagues have revisited these questions using a mouse model in which TCR transgenic (tg) CD4+ T cells recognizing allo-MHC antigens either directly (4C) or indirectly (TCR 75) were adoptively transferred to recipients of vascularized heart transplants. It was observed that T cells activated indirectly displayed much earlier and stronger proliferation rates and IFNγ production than T cells activated directly. Next, they assessed polyclonal CD4+ T-cell responses using an ELISPOT assay in B6 mice transplanted with BALB/c skin. They observed that the CD4+ T-cell indirect alloresponse represented 10% of the overall alloresponse 10 days posttransplantation but rose to 20% after 60 days (Table 1). Most strikingly, in recipients of allogeneic hearts, the indirect response represented up to 33% of the CD4+ T-cell-mediated alloresponse when measured using T cells recovered from the transplant itself. In another set of experiments, B6 Rag 1 KO mice, that had accepted BALB/c grafts for 100 days, were adoptively transferred with TCR tg CD4+ T cells. Strikingly, only those T cells interacting with alloantigens in an indirect fashion rejected the allografts. Co-transfer of T cells with allogeneic (donor) dendritic cells could restore allograft rejection via the direct pathway. This result suggests that the direct alloresponse becomes inoperative once the donor passenger leukocytes are no longer present, although this could also reflect tolerogenic effects of alloantigen presentation by graft parenchymal cells. Table 1 Approximate numbers and percentages of donor-reactive activated CD4+ T cells secreting IFNγ in direct and indirect fashion after allogeneic skin or heart transplantation. Modified after Brennan et al. (this issue) Upon adoptive transfer, TCR tg monoclonal T cells activated indirectly exhibited an earlier and higher proliferation rate than T cells responding through the direct pathway. If we concede that both T-cell clones share similar avidities for their corresponding antigens, this difference can be attributed only to the level of antigen presentation in the secondary lymphoid organ considered. Indeed, it may take several days for donor passenger leukocytes to reach the recipient’s spleen and trigger a direct alloresponse. In turn, it is possible that recipient APCs bearing donor antigens may traffic faster and in higher numbers to the host’s lymphoid organs. It is also possible that shed alloMHC class I proteins may represent an immediate source of antigen for processing by recipient APCs and the initiation of an early, indirect response. Since the same phenomenon is observed with vascularized heart transplants, it is unlikely that the initial lack of vascularization of skin grafts accounts for the somewhat delayed nature of the direct alloresponse. It is also noteworthy that the investigators adoptively transferred equal numbers of directly and indirectly activated T cells to graft recipients. Since the number of T cells activated indirectly is normally much lower than that with direct reactivity, this may bias the alloresponse toward the indirect allorecognition pathway. In naive mice, the authors confirm the presence of direct but not indirect alloresponses by CD4+ T cells producing IL-2 but no IFNγ. Such primary MLR responses reflect either the high precursor frequency of naive T cells or the presence of preexisting memory T cells capable of recognizing allo-MHC proteins. The absence of IFNγ production rather supports a response mediated by naive CD4+ T cells. The observed frequencies of T cells activated via direct and indirect pathways in early polyclonal alloresponses following skin grafting are similar to those reported previously using the same ELISPOT assay (7). Apparently, over time, the memory T cells recognizing allopeptides tend to represent a higher percentage of the overall alloreactive population. This may reflect a higher level of cell death among T cells activated directly or the rapid elimination of donor professional APCs. Also, a higher rate of proliferation of indirectly activated T cells may account for this phenomenon. This finding supports the view that while T cells activated directly dominate the initial alloresponse, indirect alloreactivity becomes progressively more prominent. It also suggests that, upon re-exposure of a recipient to the same alloantigens, indirect alloimmunity may play a critical role in second set rejection. Interestingly, in the case of vascularized cardiac allotransplants, T cells activated indirectly account for a third of primed T cells recovered from the graft, while they represent only 6% of activated T cells in the spleen. This could reflect the massive and early infiltration of the allograft by recipient APCs. It also suggests that some T cells may be primed in the graft itself. Previous studies by Lakkis’ group (8), using aly/aly mice devoid of lymph nodes and splenectomized, suggest that such ‘peripheral sensitization’ may take place in tertiary lymphoid structures formed in tissues after inflammation. The alternative interpretation of this observation is that T cells activated indirectly undergo faster activation and proliferation upon alloantigen presentation and infiltrate the graft at a higher pace than their directly activated T-cell counterparts. Finally, the results shown in Figure 6 in the paper by Brennan et al. further suggest that T cells activated directly cannot reject an allograft on their own once donor passenger leukocytes have disappeared. In contrast, despite the lack of inflammation and ‘danger’ signals, T cells activated in an indirect fashion could reject a healed skin allograft. Chronic inflammation present in RAG KO mice as well as homeostatic proliferation of adoptively transferred T cells may favor the activation of transferred T cells in these mice. Indeed, it would be useful to determine whether the same phenomenon can be demonstrated in normal mice. In any case, this result further supports the view that indirect alloreactivity becomes the main route of rejection by CD4+ T cells following the elimination of donor MHC class II+ professional APCs. It is also important to keep in mind that this conclusion may not pertain to directly activated CD8+ T cells, whose activation can occur in the absence of CD4+ T-cell help in certain mouse strains. In conclusion, this interesting study indicates that the direct alloresponse is short-lived, while the indirect alloresponse eventually becomes the driving force behind the rejection process. This suggests that the achievement of stable tolerance may rely primarily on therapeutic control of the indirect allorecognition pathway.

Recent developments in our understanding of vitamin D show that it plays a significant role in immunological health, uniquely occupying both an anti-microbial and immunoregulatory niche. Vitamin D deficiency is widespread amongst renal transplant recipients (RTRs), thus providing one patho-mechanism that may influence the achievement of a successful degree of immunosuppression. It may also influence the development of the infectious, cardiovascular and neoplastic complications seen in RTRs. This review examines the biological roles of vitamin D in the immune system of relevance to renal transplantation (RTx) and evaluates whether vitamin D repletion may be relevant in determining immunologically-related clinical outcomes in RTRs, (including graft survival, cardiovascular disease and cancer). While there are plausible biological and epidemiological reasons to undertake vitamin D repletion in RTRs, there are few randomized-controlled trials in this area. Based on the available literature, we cannot at present categorically make the case for routine measurement and repletion of vitamin D in clinical practice but we do suggest that this is an area in urgent need of further randomized controlled level evidence.