Search

Background & Purpose: FLASH or ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) radiation therapy (RT) has gained attention in recent years for its ability to spare normal tissues relative to conventional dose rate (CDR) RT in various preclinical trials. However, clinical implementation of this promising treatment option has been limited because of the lack of availability of accelerators capable of delivering UHDR RT. We established a framework for the acceptance, commissioning, and periodic quality assurance (QA) of electron FLASH units and present an example of commissioning. Methods: A protocol for acceptance, commissioning, and QA of UHDR linear accelerators was established by combining and adapting standards and professional recommendations for standard linear accelerators based on the experience with UHDR at four clinical centers that use different UHDR devices. Non-standard dosimetric beam parameters considered included pulse width, pulse repetition frequency, dose per pulse, and instantaneous dose rate, together with recommendations on how to acquire these measurements. Results: The 6 and 9 MeV beams of an UHDR electron device were commissioned by using this developed protocol. Measurements were acquired with a combination of ion chambers, beam current transformers (BCTs), and dose rate independent passive dosimeters. The unit was calibrated according to the concept of redundant dosimetry using a reference setup. Conclusions: This study provides detailed recommendations for the acceptance testing, commissioning, and routine QA of low-energy electron UHDR linear accelerators. The proposed framework is not limited to any specific unit, making it applicable to all existing eFLASH units in the market. Through practical insights and theoretical discourse, this document establishes a benchmark for the commissioning of UHDR devices for clinical use., Comment: 22 Pages, 8 Figures

The aim of this study was to optimize the design and performance of parallel plate ion chambers for use in ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) dosimetry applications, and evaluate their potential as reference class chambers for calibration purposes. Three chambers were designed and produced: the A11-VAR (0.2-1.0 mm electrode gap, 20 mm diameter collector), the A11-TPP (0.3 mm electrode gap, 20 mm diameter collector), and the A30 (0.3 mm electrode gap, 5.4 mm diameter collector).The chambers underwent full characterization using an UHDR 9 MeV electron beam with individually varied beam parameters of pulse repetition frequency (PRF, 10-120Hz), pulse width (PW, 0.5-4us), and pulse amplitude (0.01-9 Gy/pulse). The response of the ion chambers was evaluated as a function of the dose per pulse (DPP), PRF, PW, dose rate, electric field strength, and electrode gap. The chamber response was found to be dependent on DPP and PW, whose dependencies were mitigated with larger electric field strengths and smaller electrode spacing. At a constant electric field strength, we measured a larger charge collection efficiency (CCE) as a function of DPP for ion chambers with a smaller electrode gap in the A11-VAR. For ion chambers with identical electrode gap (A11-TPP and A30), higher electric field strengths were found to yield better CCE at higher DPP. A PW dependence was observed at low electric field strengths (500 V/mm) for DPP values ranging from 1-5 Gy at PWs ranging from 0.5-4 {\mu}s, but at electric field strengths of 1000 V/mm and higher, these effects become negligible. This study confirmed that the charge collection efficiency of ion chambers depends strongly on the electrode spacing and the electric field strength, and also on the DPP and the PW of the UHDR beam. The new finding of this study is that the PW dependence becomes negligible with reduced electrode spacing and increased electric field., Comment: 29 pages, 9 figures

Background: Scintillation dosimetry has promising qualities for ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) radiotherapy (RT), but no system has shown compatibility with mean dose rates ($\bar{DR}$) above 100 Gy/s and doses per pulse ($D_p$) exceeding 1.5 Gy typical of UHDR (FLASH)-RT. The aim of this study was to characterize a novel scintillator dosimetry system with the potential of accommodating UHDRs. Methods: A thorough dosimetric characterization of the system was performed on an UHDR electron beamline. The system's response as a function of dose, $\bar{DR}$, $D_p$, and the pulse dose rate ${DR}_p$ was investigated, together with the system's dose sensitivity (signal per unit dose) as a function of dose history. The capabilities of the system for time-resolved dosimetric readout were also evaluated. Results: Within a tolerance of $\pm$3% the system exhibited dose linearity and was independent of $\bar{DR}$ and $D_p$ within the tested ranges of 1.8-1341 Gy/s and 0.005-7.68 Gy, respectively. A 6% reduction in the signal per unit dose was observed as ${DR}_p$ was increased from 8.9e4-1.8e6 Gy/s. Additionally, the dose delivered per integration window of the continuously sampling photodetector had to remain between 0.028 and 11.64 Gy to preserve a stable signal response per unit dose. The system accurately measured $D_p$ of individual pulses delivered at up to 120 Hz. The day-to-day variation of the signal per unit dose at a reference setup varied by up to $\pm$13% but remained consistent (<$\pm$2%) within each day of measurements and showed no signal loss as a function of dose history. Conclusions: With daily calibrations and ${DR}_p$ specific correction factors, the system reliably provides real-time, millisecond-resolved dosimetric measurements of pulsed conventional and UHDR beams from typical electron linacs, marking an important advancement in UHDR dosimetry., Comment: 15 pages, 6 figures

We characterized the dosimetric properties of a clinical linear accelerator configured to deliver ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation to mice and cell-culture FLASH radiobiology experiments. UHDR electron beams were controlled by a microcontroller and relay interfaced with the respiratory gating system. We produced beam collimators with indexed stereotactic mouse positioning devices to provide anatomically specific preclinical treatments. Treatment delivery was monitored directly with an ionization chamber, and charge measurements were correlated with radiochromic film at the entry surface of the mice. The setup for conventional (CONV) dose rate irradiation was similar but the source-to-surface distance was longer. Monte Carlo simulations and film dosimetry were used to characterize beam properties and dose distributions. The mean electron beam energies before the flattening filter were 18.8 MeV (UHDR) and 17.7 MeV (CONV), with corresponding values at the mouse surface of 17.2 MeV and 16.2 MeV. The charges measured with an external ion chamber were linearly correlated with the mouse entrance dose. Use of relay gating for pulse control initially led to a delivery failure rate of 20% ($+/-$ 1 pulse); adjustments to account for the linac latency improved this rate to <1/20. Beam field sizes for two anatomically specific mouse collimators (4x4 $cm^2$ for whole-abdomen and 1.5x1.5 $cm^2$ for unilateral lung irradiation) were accurate within <5% and had low radiation leakage (<4%). Normalizing the dose at the center of the mouse (~0.75 cm depth) produced UHDR and CONV doses to the irradiated volumes with >95% agreement. We successfully configured a clinical linear accelerator for increased output and developed a robust preclinical platform for anatomically specific irradiation, with highly accurate and precise temporal and spatial dose delivery, for both CONV and UHDR applications., Comment: Jinghui Wang and Stavros Melemenidis are co-first authors, and Emil Sch\"uler and Peter G. Maxim are co-senior/co-corresponding authors

We conducted a multi-institutional audit of dosimetric variability between FLASH and conventional dose rate (CONV) electron irradiations by using an anatomically realistic 3D-printed mouse phantom. A CT scan of a live mouse was used to create a 3D model of bony anatomy, lungs, and soft tissue. A dual-nozzle 3D printer was used to print the mouse phantom using acrylonitrile butadiene styrene ($~1.02 g/cm^3$) and polylactic acid ($~1.24 g/cm^3$) simultaneously to simulate soft tissue and bone densities, respectively. The lungs were printed separately using lightweight polylactic acid ($~0.64 g/cm^3$). Hounsfield units (HU) and densities were compared with the reference CT scan of the live mouse. Print-to-print reproducibility of the phantom was assessed. Three institutions were each provided a phantom, and each institution performed two replicates of irradiations at selected mouse anatomic regions. The average dose difference between FLASH and CONV dose distributions and deviation from the prescribed dose were measured with radiochromic film. Compared to the reference CT scan, CT scans of the phantom demonstrated mass density differences of $0.10 g/cm^3$ for bone, $0.12 g/cm^3$ for lung, and $0.03 g/cm^3$ for soft tissue regions. Between phantoms, the difference in HU for soft tissue and bone was <10 HU from print to print. Lung exhibited the most variation (54 HU) but minimally affected dose distribution (<0.5% dose differences between phantoms). The mean difference between FLASH and CONV from the first replicate to the second decreased from 4.3% to 1.2%, and the mean difference from the prescribed dose decreased from 3.6% to 2.5% for CONV and 6.4% to 2.7% for FLASH. The framework presented here is promising for credentialing of multi-institutional studies of FLASH preclinical research to maximize the reproducibility of biological findings., Comment: 29 Pages, 5 Figures, 2 Tables

Purpose: To propose a theory for the differential tissue sparing of FLASH ultra high dose rates (UHDR) through inter-track reaction-diffusion mechanism. Methods: We calculate the time-evolution of particle track-structures using a system of coupled reaction-diffusion equations on a random network designed for molecular transport in porous and disordered media. The network is representative of the intra- and inter-cellular diffusion channels in tissues. Spatial cellular heterogeneities over the scale of track spacing have been constructed by incorporating random fluctuations in the connectivity among network sites. Results: We demonstrate the occurrence of phase separation among the tracks as the complexity in intra- and inter-cellular structural increases. At the weak limit of disorder, such as in water and normal tissue, neighboring tracks melt into each other and form a percolated network of nonreactive species. In contrast, at the strong limit of disorder, tracks evolve individually like isolated islands with negligible inter-track overlap. Thus, the spatio-temporal correlation among the chemical domains decreases as the inter-cellular complexity of the tissue increases (e.g. from normal tissue to fractal-type malignant tissue). Conclusions: The differential sparing of FLASH UHDR in normal and tumor tissue may be explained by differences in inter- and intra-cellular structural complexities between the tissue types. The structural complexities of cancerous cells prevent clustering and chemical interaction of tracks, whereas this interaction prevails and thus leads to sparing in normal tissue.

The mechanism responsible for the FLASH effect, normal tissue sparing by ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) irradiation with isoeffective tumor control compared to conventional dose rate (CDR) irradiation, remains undetermined. Here we investigate the contribution of interspur interactions (interactions between radiolytic species of individual particle tracks) to overall radiochemical interactions as a function of irradiation parameters, and suggest an increase in interspur interaction as a potential mechanism for tissue sparing in FLASH radiation therapy. We construct a model that analytically represents the spatiotemporal distribution of spurs in a target volume as a function of irradiation parameters (e.g. dose, dose rate, linear energy transfer), and quantifies the effect of interspur interactions on the ongoing radiochemistry. Spurs evolve under a simplified reaction-diffusion equation with parameters based on Monte Carlo simulations, and interspur interaction is quantified by calculating the expected values of interspur overlap in the target. The model demonstrates that for any set of irradiation parameters, a minimum critical dose and dose rate are necessary to induce significant interspur interaction, and that interspur interactions correlate negatively with beam linear energy transfer at a fixed dose. The model suggests optimal beam parameters, including dose, dose rate, linear energy transfer, and pulse structure, to maximize interspur interactions. Depending on the rate of radical scavenging in the target, which limits interspur interaction, this model predicts that the irradiation parameters necessary to elicit the FLASH effect may coincide with an onset of significant interspur interactions, suggesting that interspur interaction may be the underlying mechanism of the FLASH effect., Comment: 23 pages, 8 figures

Background and purpose: To propose a novel machine learning-based method for reliable and accurate modeling of linac beam data applicable to the processes of linac commissioning and QA. Materials and methods: We hypothesize that the beam data is a function of inherent linac features and percentage depth doses (PDDs) and profiles of different field sizes are correlated with each other. The correlation is formulated as a multivariable regression problem using a machine learning framework. Varian TrueBeam beam data sets (n=43) acquired from multiple institutions were used to evaluate the framework. The data sets included PDDs and profiles across different energies and field sizes. A multivariate regression model was trained for prediction of beam specific PDDs and profiles of different field sizes using a 10x10cm$^2$ field as input. Results: Predictions of PDDs were achieved with a mean absolute percent relative error (%RE) of 0.19-0.35% across the different beam energies investigated. The maximum mean absolute %RE was 0.93%. For profile prediction, the mean absolute %RE was 0.66-0.93% with a maximum absolute %RE of 3.76%. The largest uncertainties in the PDD and profile predictions were found at the build-up region and at the field penumbra, respectively. The prediction accuracy increased with the number of training sets up to around 20 training sets. Conclusions: Through this novel machine learning-based method we have shown accurate and reproducible generation of beam data for linac commissioning for routine radiation therapy. This method has the potential to simplify the linac commissioning procedure, save time and manpower while increasing the accuracy of the commissioning process., Comment: 36 pages, 9 figures, 4 tables; Accepted by Radiotherapy and Oncology, references were added to reflect the latest advances