1. Prenatal alcohol prevention in the UK:mapping the landscape through systematic collaborative review
- Author
-
Mcquire, Cheryl, Zuccolo, Luisa, Frennesson, Felicia, Butcher, Sandra, Carel, Havi, Cook, Penny, Tadeáš Dvořák, Gilham, Ellie, Hurt, Lisa, Langford, Rebecca, Misell, Andrew, Mukherjee, Raja, Porter, Alice, Susoy, Oliver, Taylor-Robinson, David, Troy, David, and Vocht, Frank
- Subjects
Adult ,Adolescent ,England ,Pregnancy ,Prenatal Exposure Delayed Effects ,Humans ,COVID-19 ,Female ,General Medicine ,Northern Ireland ,Alcoholism/prevention & control - Abstract
BackgroundUK policy makers have called for urgent action to reduce prenatal alcohol exposure (PAE), but evidence on what is effective is scarce. We aimed to identify, evaluate, and synthesise evidence on content, process aspects, and effectiveness of UK PAE prevention initiatives.MethodsWe conducted a systematic search of published and grey literature on UK PAE prevention (PROSPERO: CRD42020209460); consultations with 61 academic, practice, policy, third sector, and public stakeholders; and semi-structured 12 interviews with pregnant people (who were aged ≥18 years and ≥12 weeks' gestation) and service providers to discuss experiences of PAE prevention. Participants were purposively sampled to cover each UK region and identified through maternity sites, social media and, for stakeholder consultees, researcher networks. Information from relevant PAE prevention initiatives from the literature was independently extracted by two reviewers. Ethical approval and informed consent were obtained for interviews, which were recorded and transcribed. Qualitative evidence was synthesised using thematic analysis. Quantitative data will be summarised using descriptive statistics and meta-analysis.FindingsWe identified 14 PAE prevention initiatives through literature searches (22 of 4064 results were eligible), stakeholder consultation, and interviews. Initiatives included screening and intervention, campaigns, and education or training. Seven initiatives were identified in the north of England. Two initiatives were identified in Scotland and two in Wales. The East of England, West Midlands, and South East of England had one each. None were identified in Southwest of England or Northern Ireland. Barriers to prevention included absence of resources, excessive workload, concerns around blame, and COVID-19. Enablers included workforce training and trust between pregnant people and service providers. Effectiveness of evidence was scarce.InterpretationKey strengths include extensive searches and multidisciplinary consultation. Data collection and analyses are ongoing and will be finalised before November, 2022. This research will provide a comprehensive analysis of current provision, providing crucial evidence to inform research and practice.FundingThe National Institute for Health and Care Research.ContributorsCM conceived of the study. CM wrote the study protocol with input from LZ, TD, AP, FdV, SB, HC, PC, RL, AM, RM, and DTR. CM designed interview schedules with input from LZ, SB, PC, RL, AM, RM, FdV, and the study public involvement panel. CM and FF conducted participant interviews. CM, LZ, SB, HC, PC, LH, AM, RM, DTR, and OS contributed to the identification of contacts and initiatives. CM, TD, and EG carried out literature searches and data extraction. CM and TD conducted analyses. CM wrote the abstract. All authors have seen and approved the final version of the abstract for publication.Declaration of interestsSB is chief executive of The National Organisation for Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders. She is sometimes paid for providing presentations. This money goes back into the organisation. The National Organisation for Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders accepts funding from the alcohol industry, government, private foundations, and trusts and individuals, but has a strict policy that funders have no influence on substance. PC was an expert contributor to the Department of Health and Social Care's report, ‘Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder: Health Needs Assessment’. She has received funding from the Greater Manchester Health and Social Care Partnership to estimate the prevalence of Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders in Greater Manchester, and from the Medical Research Council to develop an intervention for families affected by Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders. She is an unpaid member of the Steering Board to oversee Greater Manchester's Preventing Alcohol Exposed Pregnancy Programme. RM is an unpaid advisor to various FASD charities and runs the National Clinic for Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders.AcknowledgmentsThe study was funded by The National Institute for Health and Care Research School for Public Health Research Postdoctoral Launching Fellowship/ResNet ECR funding (McQuire). We would like to thank the members of our Public Participation and Involvement panel, who assisted with the design of the interview materials, study information sheets, and consent forms.
- Published
- 2022