Search

The purpose of our article is to investigate the impact of symptom experience on health related quality of life (HRQOL) in kidney transplant recipients (KTRs) and whether illness perceptions mediated this impact. Symptom experience, illness perceptions, and HRQOL were measured at transplantation and 6 weeks after transplantation in KTRs in an ongoing Dutch cohort study. Multivariable linear regression models were used for the analysis. 90 KTRs were analyzed. Fatigue and lack of energy were the most prevalent and burdensome symptoms at transplantation. Mental HRQOL at 6 weeks after transplantation was comparable to that of the general Dutch population (mean [standard deviation, SD]: 49.9 [10.7]) versus 50.2 [9.2]), while physical HRQOL was significantly lower (38.9 [9.1] versus 50.6 [9.2]). Experiencing more symptoms was associated with lower physical and mental HRQOL, and the corresponding HRQOL reduced by −0.15 (95%CI, −0.31; 0.02) and −0.23 (95%CI, −0.42; −0.04) with each additional symptom. The identified mediation effect suggests that worse symptom experiences could cause more unhelpful illness perceptions and consequently lead to lower HRQOL. Illness perceptions may explain the negative impact of symptom experience on HRQOL. Future studies at later stages after kidney transplantation are needed to further explore the mediation effect of illness perceptions and guide clinical practice to improve HRQOL.

ObjectivesPatient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) provide insight into patients’ experienced health and needs, and can improve patient–professional communication. However, little is known about how to discuss PROM results. This study aimed to provide in-depth knowledge of patients’ and healthcare professionals’ experiences with and perspectives on discussing PROM results as part of routine dialysis care.DesignA qualitative study was performed using an interpretive description approach. Individual semistructured interviews were conducted with 22 patients and healthcare professionals. Interviews focused on general and specific situations (eg, addressing sensitive topics or when no medical treatment is available). Interviews were transcribed verbatim and analysed inductively using thematic analysis.SettingParticipants were purposively sampled from eight dialysis centres across the Netherlands.ParticipantsInterviews were conducted with 10 patients receiving dialysis treatment and 12 healthcare professionals (nephrologists and nurses).ResultsPatients and healthcare professionals provided practical guidance for optimal discussion about PROM results. First, patients and healthcare professionals emphasised that PROM results should always be discussed and indicated how to create a suitable setting, adequately prepare, deal with time constraints and use PROMs as a tool for personalised holistic consultations. Second, patients should actively participate and healthcare professionals should take a guiding role. A trusting patient–professional relationship was considered a prerequisite and patient–professional interaction was described as a collaboration in which both contribute their knowledge, experiences and ideas. Third, follow-up after discussing PROM results was considered important, including evaluations and actions (eg, symptom management) structurally embedded into the multidisciplinary treatment process. These general themes also applied to the specific situations, for example: results should also be discussed when no medical treatment is available. Though, healthcare professionals were expected to take more initiative and a leading role when discussing sensitive topics.ConclusionsThis study provides insight into how to organise and conduct conversations about PROM results and lays the foundation for training healthcare professionals to optimally discuss PROM results in routine nephrology care. Further research is needed to provide guidance on follow-up actions in response to specific PROM results.

Background The Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS®) has been recommended for computerized adaptive testing (CAT) of health-related quality of life. This study compared the content, validity, and reliability of seven PROMIS CATs to the 12-item Short-Form Health Survey (SF-12) in patients with advanced chronic kidney disease. Methods Adult patients with chronic kidney disease and an estimated glomerular filtration rate under 30 mL/min/1.73 m2 who were not receiving dialysis treatment completed seven PROMIS CATs (assessing physical function, pain interference, fatigue, sleep disturbance, anxiety, depression, and the ability to participate in social roles and activities), the SF-12, and the PROMIS Pain Intensity single item and Dialysis Symptom Index at inclusion and 2 weeks. A content comparison was performed between PROMIS CATs and the SF-12. Construct validity of PROMIS CATs was assessed using Pearson's correlations. We assessed the test-retest reliability of all patient-reported outcome measures by calculating the intraclass correlation coefficient and minimal detectable change. Results In total, 207 patients participated in the study. A median of 45 items (10 minutes) were completed for PROMIS CATs. All PROMIS CATs showed evidence of sufficient construct validity. PROMIS CATs, most SF-12 domains and summary scores, and Dialysis Symptom Index showed sufficient test-retest reliability (intraclass correlation coefficient ≥ 0.70). PROMIS CATs had a lower minimal detectable change compared with the SF-12 (range, 5.7–7.4 compared with 11.3–21.7 across domains, respectively). Conclusion PROMIS CATs showed sufficient construct validity and test-retest reliability in patients with advanced chronic kidney disease. PROMIS CATs required more items but showed better reliability than the SF-12. Future research is needed to investigate the feasibility of PROMIS CATs for routine nephrology care.

Background Prospective cohort studies are challenging to deliver, with one of the main difficulties lying in retention of participants. The need to socially distance during the COVID-19 pandemic has added to this challenge. The pre-COVID-19 adaptation of the European Quality (EQUAL) study in the UK to a remote form of follow-up for efficiency provides lessons for those who are considering changing their study design. Methods The EQUAL study is an international prospective cohort study of patients ≥65 years of age with advanced chronic kidney disease. Initially, patients were invited to complete a questionnaire (SF-36, Dialysis Symptom Index and Renal Treatment Satisfaction Questionnaire) at research clinics every 3–6 months, known as “traditional follow-up” (TFU). In 2018, all living patients were invited to switch to “efficient follow-up” (EFU), which used an abbreviated questionnaire consisting of SF-12 and Dialysis Symptom Index. These were administered centrally by post. Response rates were calculated using returned questionnaires as a proportion of surviving invitees, and error rates presented as the average percentage of unanswered questions or unclear answers, of total questions in returned questionnaires. Response and error rates were calculated 6-monthly in TFU to allow comparisons with EFU. Results Of the 504 patients initially recruited, 236 were still alive at the time of conversion to EFU; 111 of these (47%) consented to the change in follow-up. In those who consented, median TFU was 34 months, ranging from 0 to 42 months. Their response rates fell steadily from 88% (98/111) at month 0 of TFU, to 20% (3/15) at month 42. The response rate for the first EFU questionnaire was 60% (59/99) of those alive from TFU. With this improvement in response rates, the first EFU also lowered errors to baseline levels seen in early follow-up, after having almost trebled throughout traditional follow-up. Conclusions Overall, this study demonstrates that administration of shorter follow-up questionnaires by post rather than in person does not negatively impact patient response or error rates. These results may be reassuring for researchers who are trying to limit face-to-face contact with patients during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Background and objectives The effect of sex on longitudinal health-related quality of life remains unknown in CKD. Here we assess differences in the sex-specific evolution of health-related quality of life in older men and women with advanced CKD.Design, setting, participants, & measurements The European Quality Study on Treatment in Advanced Chronic Kidney Disease is a European observational prospective cohort study in referred patients with CKD and an incident eGFRResults We included 5345 health-related quality-of-life measurements in 1421 participants. At baseline, women had considerably lower mean Physical Component Summary (42) and Mental Component Summary (60) compared with men (Physical Component Summary: 55; Mental Component Summary: 69; PConclusions Among older men and women with advanced CKD, women had lower health-related quality of life at baseline, but men experienced a more rapid decline in health-related quality of life over time.

Background and objectives In older people with kidney failure, improving health-related quality of life is often more important than solely prolonging life. However, little is known about the effect of dialysis initiation on health-related quality of life in older patients. Therefore, we investigated the evolution of health-related quality of life before and after starting dialysis in older patients with kidney failure. Design, setting, participants, & measurements The European Quality study is an ongoing prospective, multicenter study in patients aged >_65 years with an incident eGFR

Background Older patients with advanced chronic kidney disease are at increased risk for a severe course of the coronavirus disease-2019 (COVID-19) and vulnerable to mental health problems. We aimed to investigate prevalence and associated patient (demographic and clinical) characteristics of mental wellbeing (health-related quality of life [HRQoL] and symptoms of depression and anxiety) before and during the COVID-19 pandemic in older patients with advanced chronic kidney disease. Methods An ongoing Dutch multicentre prospective cohort study enrols patients of ≥70 years with an eGFR 2 from October 2018 onward. With additional questionnaires during the pandemic (May–June 2020), disease-related concerns about COVID-19 and general anxiety symptoms were assessed cross-sectionally, and depressive symptoms, HRQoL, and emotional symptoms longitudinally. Results The 82 included patients had a median age of 77.5 years (interquartile range 73.9–82.1), 77% were male and none had tested positive for COVID-19. Cross-sectionally, 67% of the patients reported to be more anxious about COVID-19 because of their kidney disease, and 43% of the patients stated that their quality of life was reduced due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Compared to pre-COVID-19, the presence of depressive symptoms had increased (11 to 22%; p = .022) and physical HRQoL declined (M = 40.4, SD = 10.1 to M = 36.1, SD = 10.4; p M = 50.3, SD = 9.6 to M = 50.4, SD = 9.9; p = .913) and emotional symptoms remained similar. Conclusions Older patients with advanced chronic kidney disease suffered from disease-related anxiety about COVID-19, increased depressive symptoms and reduced physical HRQoL during the COVID-19 pandemic. The impact of the pandemic on this vulnerable patient group extends beyond increased mortality risk, and awareness of mental wellbeing is important. Trial registration The study is registered at the Netherlands Trial Register (NTR), trial number NL7104. Date of registration: 06-06-2018.

Additional file 1 Table 1. Correlations of baseline characteristics and cross-sectional outcomes of mental wellbeing.

Additional file 3. Group information for the Pathway for older patients reaching end stage renal disease (POLDER) study group.

Additional file 2 Table 2. Correlations of baseline characteristics and change in longitudinal outcomes of mental wellbeing.

Additional file 1.

In evidence-based medicine, clinical research questions may be addressed by different study designs. This article describes when randomized controlled trials (RCT) are needed and when observational studies are more suitable. According to the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine, study designs can be divided into analytic and non-analytic (descriptive) study designs. Analytic studies aim to quantify the association of an intervention (eg, treatment) or a naturally occurring exposure with an outcome. They can be subdivided into experimental (ie, RCT) and observational studies. The RCT is the best study design to evaluate theintendedeffect of an intervention, because the randomization procedure breaks the link between the allocation of the intervention and patient prognosis. If the randomization of the intervention or exposure is not possible, one needs to depend on observational analytic studies, but these studies usually suffer from bias and confounding. If the study focuses onunintendedeffects of interventions (ie, effects of an intervention that are not intended or foreseen), observational analytic studies are the most suitable study designs, provided that there is no link between the allocation of the intervention and the unintended effect. Furthermore, non-analytic studies (ie, descriptive studies) also rely on observational study designs. In summary, RCTs and observational study designs are inherently different, and depending on the study aim, they each have their own strengths and weaknesses.

This dissertation aimed to identify opportunities to slow down disease progression and improve health-related quality of life (HRQOL) in patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD). Biopsychosocial, patient-centred and self-regulation perspectives were employed and enabled this dissertation to shed light on the importance of patients’ health behaviours and illness perceptions in the treatment of CKD. Taken together, this dissertation indicates that patients in early CKD stages are in need of behavioural support to cope with the broad range of barriers that they experience when reducing sodium intake. The results demonstrate that a multicomponent patient-centred self-regulation program would fit patients' needs, and can reduce risk factors for disease progression and improve psychosocial outcomes. Furthermore, this dissertation suggests that support strategies should be implemented to increase the impaired HRQOL that many patients experience during predialysis care. The results underline the need for personalized treatment approaches in light of the differences between patients in relation to their HRQOL and how their HRQOL evolves over time (e.g., differences with regard to age and cardiovascular disease). Moreover, illness perceptions were found to be key factors in HRQOL and disease progression, and therefore, treatment strategies in predialysis care should take into account patients’ illness perceptions as well.

Objective: To identify health-related quality of life (HRQOL) trajectories during 18 months of predialysis care and associated patient characteristics and illness perceptions. Method: 396 incident predialysis patients participating in the prospective PREdialysis PAtient REcord-2 study completed every 6 months the 36-item Short Form Health Survey (i.e., mental and physical HRQOL) and Revised Illness Perception Questionnaire. HRQOL trajectories were examined using latent class growth models, and associated baseline factors were identified using logistic regression. Analyses for illness perceptions were adjusted for demographic and clinical characteristics. Results: Three physical HRQOL trajectories (low-stable [34.1% of the sample], medium-declining [32.5%], and high-increasing [33.4%]) and two mental HRQOL trajectories (low-stable [38.7%] and high-stable [61.3%]) were identified. Increased odds for a low-stable physical HRQOL trajectory were detected in older patients (Odds ratio [OR] = 1.04), patients with cardiovascular disease (OR = 2.1) and patients who believed to a lesser extent they can personally control their disease (ORadj = 0.88). Increased odds for both a low-stable physical and mental HRQOL trajectory were detected in patients who believed to a higher extent that their disease is cyclical, has negative consequences, causes negative feelings, and in patients who believed to a lesser extent they understand their disease (ORadj ranged between 0.84 and 1.36). Additionally, patients who attributed more symptoms to their disease had increased odds for a medium-declining (ORadj = 1.21) and low-stable physical HRQOL trajectory (ORadj = 1.50). Conclusions: Older age and cardiovascular disease are markers for unfavorable physical HRQOL trajectories, and stronger negative illness perceptions are markers for unfavorable physical and mental HRQOL trajectories. Targeting negative illness perceptions could possibly optimize HRQOL during predialysis care.

In predialysis patients, the optimal treatment choices for controlling haemoglobin (Hb) are unknown, because targeting high Hb levels has negative effects--poorer survival--but possible positive effects as well--better health-related quality of life (HRQOL). Moreover, these effects may be different in specific subgroups (e.g. young versus elderly).In the PREPARE-2 follow-up study, incident predialysis patients were included (2004-2011) when referred to 1 of the 25 participating Dutch outpatient clinics. HRQOL was assessed at 6-month intervals with the short form-36 (SF-36) questionnaire [physical/mental summary measure and eight subscales (range 0-100)]. A linear mixed model was used to associate Hb [11, ≥ 11 to12 (reference), ≥ 12 to13 and ≥ 13 g/dL] with HRQOL, stratified by prescription of anaemia medication (erythropoietin-stimulating agent (ESA)/iron) and age (young:65 years and elderly: ≥ 65 years).Only elderly patients (n = 214) not prescribed ESA/iron and with a high Hb (≥ 13 versus ≥ 11 to12 g/dL) had a statistically significant (P0.05) and/or clinically relevant (3-5 points) higher physical [11.9, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.7, 22.2] and mental (6.4, 95% CI -1.7, 14.6) summary score. High Hb was not associated with a higher HRQOL in elderly patients who were prescribed ESA/iron. However, only young patients (n = 157) prescribed ESA/iron and with a high Hb (≥ 13 versus ≥ 11 to12 g/dL) had a higher physical (8.9, 95% CI 2.1, 15.8) and mental (6.2, 95% CI -0.4, 12.8) summary score.The association of Hb levels with HRQOL differs by age and use of ESA/iron medication on predialysis care. Therefore, medical care should aim for shared decision-making regarding the appropriate Hb target leading to more individualized care.

Healthcare is shifting towards a more person-centred approach, aiming at a personalised treatment that fits the patient’s preferences and needs⁠. The use of patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) to systematically assess outcomes such as health-related quality of life and symptom burden can facilitate the process of adapting to what is important to the patient⁠. But, how to integrate PROMs into a routine care setting and how to use PROMs to achieve this personalised treatment? This dissertation provides insight into and practical knowledge of the implementation and use of PROMs in routine nephrology care⁠. Research was performed within the different steps for implementation of PROMs into routine care, including the selection of PROMs, pilot testing PROMs, and nationwide implementation and use of PROMs, using a broad variety of quantitative and qualitative research methods⁠. The use of PROMs was investigated both at individual patient level and at population level, with the potential to facilitate personalised treatment and evaluation of healthcare quality⁠. Patients and healthcare professionals considered the PROM-results relevant additional information in routine practice, complementary to traditional clinical measures⁠. In addition, discussing individual PROM results proved to be of great added value and directly applicable in routine care⁠.

This dissertation aimed to broaden our understanding of patient-relevant outcomes after kidney transplantation with a special focus on the patients’ perspectives. By conducting different studies in Dutch kidney transplant recipients and by synthesizing existing evidence, we explored several post-transplant patient-relevant outcomes (e.g. health-related quality of life, symptom burden, illness perceptions, medication non-adherence and hospital readmission) and investigated pathways to improve these outcomes, hereby adding to the existing body of knowledge in kidney transplantation. In Chapter 1, we briefly introduced the status quo of patient-relevant outcomes in kidney transplant recipients, discussed potential pathways to improve patient-relevant outcomes in kidney transplant recipients, and provided an overview of the studies presented in this dissertation. In Chapter 7, we provided a summary of our main findings from different studies described in Chapter 2 - 6, the clinical implication of our main findings, and suggestions for future research.

Background Depressive symptoms are associated with adverse clinical outcomes in patients with end-stage kidney disease; however, few small studies have examined this association in patients with earlier phases of chronic kidney disease (CKD). We studied associations between baseline depressive symptoms and clinical outcomes in older patients with advanced CKD and examined whether these associations differed depending on sex. Methods CKD patients (≥65 years; estimated glomerular filtration rate ≤20 mL/min/1.73 m2) were included from a European multicentre prospective cohort between 2012 and 2019. Depressive symptoms were measured by the five-item Mental Health Inventory (cut-off ≤70; 0–100 scale). Cox proportional hazard analysis was used to study associations between depressive symptoms and time to dialysis initiation, all-cause mortality and these outcomes combined. A joint model was used to study the association between depressive symptoms and kidney function over time. Analyses were adjusted for potential baseline confounders. Results Overall kidney function decline in 1326 patients was –0.12 mL/min/1.73 m2/month. A total of 515 patients showed depressive symptoms. No significant association was found between depressive symptoms and kidney function over time (P = 0.08). Unlike women, men with depressive symptoms had an increased mortality rate compared with those without symptoms [adjusted hazard ratio 1.41 (95% confidence interval 1.03–1.93)]. Depressive symptoms were not significantly associated with a higher hazard of dialysis initiation, or with the combined outcome (i.e. dialysis initiation and all-cause mortality). Conclusions There was no significant association between depressive symptoms at baseline and decline in kidney function over time in older patients with advanced CKD. Depressive symptoms at baseline were associated with a higher mortality rate in men.