1. Citizens' values and tough trade-off choices in road infrastructure planning:developing tools and methods to enrich intelligence and improve context-sensitive road infrastructure design
- Author
-
Hilbers, Anne Marel and Hilbers, Anne Marel
- Abstract
In today's road infrastructure projects, the idea of creating “added value” by integrating infrastructure and spatial development often remains all talk and no action. The challenge generally lies in public resistance, which is fueled by a lack of understanding of what matters to citizens and the trade-offs involved in road infrastructure projects. Responding to this challenge, this thesis aims to develop concepts and tools that better support context-sensitive road infrastructure designs by considering citizens’ values and their perspectives on necessary trade-off choices. Two new tools are developed: the Place Value Identifier (PVI) and the Conjoint Analysis (CA) survey. The PVI is an online tool that uses Public Participation Geographic Information System (PPGIS) to map both the 'soft' value of places and 'hard' land use data. By systematically identifying the values of landscapes from large groups of citizens, PVI helps planners to identify potential areas of public resistance and develop more context-sensitive project designs. The CA survey was found to be a valuable method to better understand citizens' trade-off choices in road infrastructure projects and has helped to identify discrepancies between citizens and policy preferences for project alternatives. Results show the substantial value placed by a large group of citizens on green spaces and the prevention of fragmentation of agricultural and natural areas. Contrarily, travel time gain – often a focal point for project initiation – emerges as the least important factor for these citizens. Understanding these priorities of citizens offers enriched intelligence for planners. This intelligence can be used as input for more context-sensitive designs and planning choices, in order to enhance public approval and their awareness of the decision-making task a planner is faced with.
- Published
- 2024