1. Combining historical and ethnographic methods: Theoretical, methodological, and ethical implications
- Author
-
Steinberger, Sofie, Rüßing, Lena, Kuiper, Gerda, Fehlings, Susanne, Tappe, Oliver, Münch, Ole, Steinberger, Sofie, Rüßing, Lena, Kuiper, Gerda, Fehlings, Susanne, Tappe, Oliver, and Münch, Ole
- Abstract
This working paper discusses theoretical, methodological, and ethical questions researchers encounter when combining historical and ethnographic research approaches. In 2021, a group of historians and cultural and social anthropologists formed the interdisciplinary working group Entanglements of Historical and Ethnographic Research (Approaches). The group members share an interest in combining historical and anthropological research methods and approaches. This publication is a result of their discussions. The working paper contains contributions by Susanne Fehlings (Frobenius Institute/Goethe University Frankfurt), Oliver Tappe (University of Heidelberg), Lena Rüßing (Head Office of the German Science and Humanities Council), Ole Münch (German Historical Institute London), Sofie Steinberger (University of Cologne), and Gerda Kuiper (University of Cologne). Based on the fields of ethnohistory, historical anthropology as well as oral history and archival research within the field of historical research, the contributions show that anthropologists and historians face similar methodological challenges and encounter comparable questions and uncertainties during the research process. The papers address topics such as the use of the histoire croisée approach for anthropologists, ethnographic multi-sited archival fieldwork, various aspects of oral history research in terms of positionality, power structures, language use and secondary analysis of interviews, as well as remote data collection. Although the contributions focus on very individual subject matters related to the research topics of the group members and although the contributors have carried out research in different regions (the Caucasus, Laos, Canada, the United Kingdom, Morocco, and Tanzania), they also share similar concerns and interests. Questions and concerns addressed throughout the working paper are the question how to give voice to marginalized people, the role of historiography in contested and exclus
- Published
- 2024