1. Situated Conversation: The Role of Attention in Communication
- Author
-
De Leon, Christian Martin, Greenberg, Gabriel J1, Cumming, Samuel J, De Leon, Christian Martin, De Leon, Christian Martin, Greenberg, Gabriel J1, Cumming, Samuel J, and De Leon, Christian Martin
- Abstract
Regular, everyday conversations do not occur in a vacuum. The physical and social context in which a conversation takes place is utilized through the course of that conversation—it is situated. The ways in which a context can be used vary. Sometimes we implicitly and unconsciously utilize context in interpreting others. While at a restaurant, you would effortlessly interpret “What are you going to have?” not as a general question disconnected from the current situation, but as a question about that particular restaurant’s menu. Other times we overtly utilize context to aid in communication. While out on a walk in the city, I might point to an ice cream cone that has fallen onto the street and say “Somebody’s having a bad day”, and it would be clear what I am talking about.I argue in this dissertation that the psychological category of attention is key for understanding how situated conversations operate. In contrast to viewing communication as a process of pure information exchange, I argue that communication is helpfully analyzed as a process of attention management. Our utterances, gestures, and facial expressions do not serve to merely convey information, but serve to coordinate our attentional states. I begin by focusing on a particular communicative phenomenon that I call rich demonstration. It is, roughly, a deictic (pointing) gesture that functions to communicate an entire thought, in contrast to fixing the reference of a demonstrative expression such as ‘that’. Just by making something salient, one can seemingly say something. I argue that rich demonstration is a speech act in its own right, and provide a formal semantic framework for modeling its communicative effect in discourse.I then proceed to analyze salience itself. The notion has proven useful for understanding a number of communicative phenomena, including reference resolution, certain kinds of pragmatic inference, quantifier domain restriction, and more. Focusing on cases of reference, I argue that
- Published
- 2022