1. Terminal Ballistics: Gauging the Accuracy of Empirical Formulas inthe Literature based on Numerical Simulations
- Author
-
Khalid, Shahrukh and Khalid, Shahrukh
- Abstract
A key aspect of understanding the impact of ballistic projectiles on a target is understandingthe dependence of the hole diameter and residual velocity on parameters like initial velocity,mass of the projectile, the geometry of the projectile, and thickness of the target plate.Ideally, simulation tools can be used to study this concept. Physical testing can be expensiveand slow, and it is often difficult to visualize what happens in an experiment. However, in simulation, these models can contain errors or may not account for relevantphysics, so one needs to be cautious with the results. We determined the hole diameterand residual velocity for projectile impact on steel and concrete plates. These results werecalculated by conducting simulations and independently from empirical formulas found inthe literature. The comparison reveals the accuracy of different formulas. The study reveals notable discrepancies between empirical formulas and numerical simula-tions for residual velocity in concrete, Furthermore in the case of steel the empirical formulas agrees more with numerical simulation. These formulas offer limited general applicabilityand only provide rough approximations. However, they align more closely with simulationsin predicting residual velocity, despite a small margin of error. Certain formulas, like theThor formula at an initial speed of 2000 m/s and considering the angle are notably morereliable, suggesting their potential use as affordable alternatives to numerical simulations.
- Published
- 2024