1. Predicting multiple conformations of ligand binding sites in proteins suggests that AlphaFold2 may remember too much.
- Author
-
Lazou M, Khan O, Nguyen T, Padhorny D, Kozakov D, Joseph-McCarthy D, and Vajda S
- Subjects
- Binding Sites, Ligands, Models, Molecular, Sequence Alignment, Software, Crystallography, X-Ray, Protein Binding, Computational Biology methods, Protein Conformation, Proteins chemistry, Proteins metabolism, Databases, Protein
- Abstract
The goal of this paper is predicting the conformational distributions of ligand binding sites using the AlphaFold2 (AF2) protein structure prediction program with stochastic subsampling of the multiple sequence alignment (MSA). We explored the opening of cryptic ligand binding sites in 16 proteins, where the closed and open conformations define the expected extreme points of the conformational variation. Due to the many structures of these proteins in the Protein Data Bank (PDB), we were able to study whether the distribution of X-ray structures affects the distribution of AF2 models. We have found that AF2 generates both a cluster of open and a cluster of closed models for proteins that have comparable numbers of open and closed structures in the PDB and not too many other conformations. This was observed even with default MSA parameters, thus without further subsampling. In contrast, with the exception of a single protein, AF2 did not yield multiple clusters of conformations for proteins that had imbalanced numbers of open and closed structures in the PDB, or had substantial numbers of other structures. Subsampling improved the results only for a single protein, but very shallow MSA led to incorrect structures. The ability of generating both open and closed conformations for six out of the 16 proteins agrees with the success rates of similar studies reported in the literature. However, we showed that this partial success is due to AF2 "remembering" the conformational distributions in the PDB and that the approach fails to predict rarely seen conformations., Competing Interests: Competing interests statement:The authors declare no competing interest.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF