1. Meta-analysis of treatment outcomes for patients with m.11778G>A MT-ND4 Leber hereditary optic neuropathy.
- Author
-
Newman NJ, Biousse V, Yu-Wai-Man P, Carelli V, Vignal-Clermont C, Montestruc F, Taiel M, and Sahel JA
- Abstract
Our aim was to assess the visual outcomes of patients with Leber hereditary optic neuropathy (LHON) harboring the m.11778G>A MT-ND4 mutation who had no treatment (natural history) or received idebenone or lenadogene nolparvovec. Efficacy outcomes included clinically relevant recovery (CRR) from nadir and final best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA). For the natural history and idebenone groups, we performed a systematic review of the literature and available clinical/regulatory reports. For the lenadogene nolparvovec group, all data from phase 3 studies were included. The overall effect and its 95 % confidence interval (CI) were estimated using a random effects model. For each meta-analysis, patients had a mean age of approximately 30 years at vision loss and were mostly (≥78 %) men. The CRR from nadir [95 % CI] at eye level was 17 % [7 %; 30 %] (n=316 eyes), 31 % [24 %; 40 %] (n=313) and 59 % [54 %; 64 %] (n=348) in untreated, idebenone-treated and lenadogene nolparvovec-treated patients, respectively. This gradient of efficacy was also observed with CRR at the patient level and final BCVA. There was a gradient of efficacy in all assessed visual outcomes, more marked for CRR than for final BCVA, with lenadogene nolparvovec gene therapy superior to idebenone treatment, and both superior to the natural history of the disease., Competing Interests: Declaration of Competing Interest The authors declare the following financial interests/personal relationships which may be considered as potential competing interests: Financial support was provided by GenSight Biologics SA. Newman reports a relationship with GenSight Biologics SA that includes: consulting or advisory. Newman reports a relationship with Chiesi Pharmaceuticals Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Newman reports a relationship with Wuhan Neurophth Biotechnology Co., Ltd. that includes: consulting or advisory. Newman reports a relationship with Stoke Therapeutics Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Newman reports a relationship with Neurophoenix that includes: consulting or advisory. Newman reports a relationship with GenSight Biologics SA that includes: funding grants. Biousse reports a relationship with GenSight Biologics SA that includes: consulting or advisory. Biousse reports a relationship with Neurophoenix that includes: consulting or advisory. Yu-Wai-Man reports a relationship with GenSight Biologics SA that includes: consulting or advisory. Yu-Wai-Man reports a relationship with Chiesi Pharmaceuticals Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Yu-Wai-Man reports a relationship with Wuhan Neurophth Biotechnology Co., Ltd. that includes: consulting or advisory. Yu-Wai-Man reports a relationship with Stoke Therapeutics Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Carelli reports a relationship with GenSight Biologics SA that includes: consulting or advisory. Carelli reports a relationship with Chiesi Pharmaceuticals Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Carelli reports a relationship with Stoke Therapeutics Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Carelli reports a relationship with Pretzel Therapeutics, Inc. that includes: consulting or advisory. Vignal-Clermont reports a relationship with GenSight Biologics SA that includes: consulting or advisory. Vignal-Clermont reports a relationship with Chiesi Pharmaceuticals Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Vignal-Clermont reports a relationship with Neurophoenix that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with eXYSTAT that includes: board membership. Montestruc reports a relationship with AbbVie Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Arcagy that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with ARTIC that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Biocodex SA that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Bioprojet that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Carely that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with CEVA Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Cureety that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Eurofins that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with GeNeuro SA that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with GenSight Biologics SA that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with IFM that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with ImCheck Therapeutics that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Mapreg that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Orphelia Pharma Sas that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with OSE Immunotherapeutics that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Pfizer Inc that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with PTC that includes: consulting or advisory. Montestruc reports a relationship with Takeda Pharmaceutical Company Limited that includes: consulting or advisory. Taiel reports a relationship with GenSight Biologics SA that includes: employment. Sahel reports a relationship with Avista Therapeutics that includes: consulting or advisory. Sahel reports a relationship with Tenpoint that includes: consulting or advisory. Sahel reports a relationship with GenSight Biologics SA that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with Sparing Vision that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with Prophesee that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with Chronolife SAS that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with Tilak Healthcare that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with VegaVect Inc. that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with Avista that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with Tenpoint that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with SharpEye that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with Celanese that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel reports a relationship with Netramind that includes: equity or stocks. Sahel has patent Allotopic expression licensed to ‘not applicable’. Sahel has patent Rod-derived Cone Viability factor licensed to INSERM and CNRS. Sahel is owner/co-owner/founder/co-founder of GenSight Biologics, Sparing Vision, Avista, Tenpoint, Prophesee, Chronolife, Tilak Healthcare, SharpEye, Celanese, Vegavect, Netramind. Sahel participates in scientific advisory board for Gilbert Foundation, Foundation Fighting Blindness, Institute of Ophthalmology Basel and Senses Institute Lausanne. Sahel is an observer at Gensight Biologics, SparingVision, Avista and Vegavect. Sahel is President of Fondation Voir et Entendre (Paris) and StreetLab (Paris). Sahel is a recipient for patent royalties and GenSight Biologics., (Copyright © 2024 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF