1. Kaplan and Marti on Definite Descriptions: Non-Standard Cases of Referential Use
- Author
-
E. V. Borisov
- Subjects
kaplan ,marti ,definite description ,proper name ,referential use of definite descriptions ,non-standard cases of referential use ,History (General) and history of Europe ,Economics as a science ,HB71-74 ,Newspapers ,AN - Abstract
Donnellan’s distinction between referential and attributive uses of definite descriptions has two explanations — the semantic and the pragmatic one. A version of semantic explanations was outlined by Kaplan and elaborated in detail by Marti. They construe a referentially used definite description as a proper name in the Millian sense. In a recent paper, I showed that the evidence Kaplan–Marti theory relies on is inappropriate with respect to the standard case of referential use, which makes the pragmatic theory preferable. This paper is a continuation of the cited one. Here I examine a number of non-standard cases of referential use and demonstrate that, with respect to them, Kaplan–Marti theory has no advantage over the pragmatic account either.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF