1. Screening tools for adult ADHD patients in primary care
- Author
-
Johanna Louise Ganzenmüller, Cora Ballmann, Regina Margarethe Wehrstedt von Nessen-Lapp, Marcel Schulze, Linda Sanftenberg, Mathias Berger, Alexandra Philipsen, and Jochen Gensichen
- Subjects
ADHD ,Primary care ,Adult ,Diagnosis ,Screening ,Mental healing ,RZ400-408 - Abstract
Background: General practitioners play a pivotal role in the diagnosis attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in adults. This systematic review aims to determine the effectivity and feasibility of screening tools for ADHD in adults in primary care. Method: A literature search was performed in PubMed, Cochrane Library, Ovid, ERIC, PsycInfo, PSYNDEX and Embase in November 2022. Sensitivity and specificity were considered as primary outcomes. Further psychometric properties, feasibility in general practice as well as digital practicability were evaluated as secondary outcomes. Risk of bias was assessed via QUADAS-2/C. A narrative data synthesis and meta-analysis was performed (PROSPERO: CRD42022374597). Results: A total of fifty-eight studies were included in data analysis. These studies referred to eighty-four various screening tools. ASRS-6 (DSM-V), WURS-25, CAARS-s:sV and TRAQ10 are suitable instruments for screening of ADHD in adults in primary care. The highest test accuracy was shown by ASRS 6 (DSM-V) (Sensitivity=0.83 [0.67–0.92], Specificity=0.87 [0.93–0.8], AUC=0.92, I2=8.6–12.3 %). Limitations: Included studies used rating scales as reference standard. Some studies compared study groups to control groups with an unknown ADHD status and there is a large degree of heterogeneity between the populations. Some studies referred to the best-balanced results of sensitivity and specificity under a certain cut-off, that has not been determined before. Conclusion: Feasibility studies are needed to provide more evidence for WURS-25 and CAARS-s:sV. The determination of sufficient cut-offs is important, to improve the identification of ADHD in adults by general physicians.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF