1. Real-world application of ATA Guidelines in over 600 aspirated thyroid nodules: is it time to change the size cut-offs for FNA?
- Author
-
Stamatina Ioakim, Akheel A Syed, George Zavros, Michalis Picolos, Luca Persani, and Angelos Kyriacou
- Subjects
thyroid nodules ,ultrasound risk stratification ,fine-needle aspiration biopsy ,size limits ,size cut-offs ,thyroid malignancy ,thyroid cancer ,thyroid carcinoma ,papillary thyroid carcinoma ,Diseases of the endocrine glands. Clinical endocrinology ,RC648-665 - Abstract
Background: The 2015 American Thyroid Association (ATA) Guidelines recommend the following size cut-offs based on sonographic appearances for subjecting nodules to fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy: low risk: 15 mm and inte rmediate risk and high risk: 10 mm. Objective: We conducted a ‘real-world’ study evaluating the diagnostic performance of the ATA cut-offs against increased thresholds, in the interest of sa fely limiting FNAs. Methods: We performed a retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data on 604 nodules which were sonographically risk-stratified as per th e ATA Guidelines and subsequently subjected to ultrasound-guided FNA. Nodules were c ytologically stratified into ‘benign’ (Bethesda class 2) and ‘non-benign’ (Bethesda cla sses 3–6). We obtained the negative predictive value (NPV), accuracy, FNAs that could be spared, missed ‘non-benign’ cytologies and missed carcinomas on histology, according to the ATA cut-offs compared to higher cut-offs. Results: In low-risk nodules, the high performance of NPV (≈91%) is unaffected by increasing the cut-off to 25 mm, and accuracy improves by 39.4%; 46.8% of FNAs could be spared at the expense of few missed B3–B6 cytologies ( 7.9%) and no missed carcinomas. In intermediate-risk nodules, a 15 mm cut-off increa ses the NPV by 11.3% and accuracy by 40.7%. The spared FNAs approach 50%, while B3–B 6 cytologies are minimal, with no missed carcinomas. In high-risk nodules, low N PV (
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF