Search

This paper analyzes the conceptions of Ibero-American secondary school teachers about the role of history teaching in creating collective identities, and how heritage can impact history classes. We applied a peer validated questionnaire to 283 history teachers from seven countries, analyzing their answers using a deductive-inductive method supported by IBM SSPS software (version 23). The analysis reveal that heritage continues to have little presence in lessons, mostly used as an example of historical narratives that highlight the national identity over others.

Even though recent decades have borne witness to an increased educational interest in teaching the Holocaust, academic stances on why the topic should be taught still vary significantly. The aim of this paper is to present teaching interventions that would help educators to navigate through one of the most important open questions in Holocaust education: the question of aims. Three Holocaust-related teaching interventions, which themselves use open questions as the basis for teaching and learning, are presented and analysed. The open questions, as the background, allow the educators to simultaneously shift between various teaching aims. The interventions addressing the question of heroes, victims and bystanders, causal analysis of the Holocaust, and the responsibility of the Allies for the escalation of the Holocaust, are arranged in such a way so as to lead students from their day-to-day knowledge, through historical concepts, finally ending up addressing more abstract concepts. The analysis draws on literature related to both Holocaust education and the teaching of controversial issues, and covers a range of topics; from practical to more philosophical

After the 1991 separatist region of Transnistria developed its own education system, provided with normative acts, including curriculum and textbooks. History education is part of the official discourse and focuses on Transnistrian interests. In many cases, textbooks are based on Soviet historiography, and Western neighbors are treated as enemies. The author of the present article analyzes, in particular, Chapter IX of the textbook for the ninth grade, which deals with the formation of the separatist republic and the Dniester War of 1992, which is described by the authors of the textbook as “Moldova’s military aggression against the Transnistrian people.” The facts presented in this textbook are unilateral, trying to demonstrate the “aggression of Moldova” on the districts on the left bank of the Dniester. Although, at the end of the topic, the authors consider that this military conflict was “a bloody war”, they insist more on the “sufferings, losses and victims” of the inhabitants of this region. There is a total lack of critical, comparative, and balanced approach to these sensitive events for the recent history of the Republic of Moldova. The discourse is aggressive and hateful, which is not acceptable, it is against international conventions and agreements between the representatives of the warring parties. The main problem in relations between Chisinau and Tiraspol is the lack of effective communication. But education should be one of the most important tools in conflict resolution.

This article provides an in-depth analysis and discussion of the global-historical theory of the so-called Rise of the West during the Early Modern Age and the commonly named Age of Discovery. This theory is covered from the point of view of history education in order to question and provide a criticial examination of the framework. On the one hand, the controversial state of research of the topic is outlined, focusing on the main theoretical debates and some of the most noteworthy ideas under discussion. On the other hand, a discussion is also provided regarding some of the special requirements and essential conditions for an implementation of the idea of the Rise of the West in the curriculum. These notions are linked to both the traditional and current narratives that can be found in the German and Spanish national contexts. From this point of view, the politics of history of both nations are outlined, and, in addition, in order to provide some exemplifications, a selection of history textbooks from previous decades have been also examined in order to analyze the way some of the narratives and these themes are presented. A series of categories, including historical myths, and the Rise of the West as a special category, as well as its institutional dimensions are also discussed in order to showcase the potential of the theory and some of the shortcomings that were detected from the perspective of history education.

Some education practices can impede learning democratic citizenship agency by reinforcing injustices or omitting dis­senting perspectives. Other practices may help address con­flict issues through problem-posing inquiry activities. This literature review explores the ways social sciences’ curriculum practices can select knowledges that enhance peace or exa­cerbates violence. Considering peace and conflict theories, I highlight the limitations and possibilities for peacebuilding of Colombia’s citizenship and social sciences’ curricula. Also, I discuss the ways certain social studies curriculum decisions (selections and omissions) may reproduce violence, injustice and passivity. Finally, I discuss how certain practices may de­velop critical citizenship capacities to handle conflicts.

Hızlı teknolojik gelişmelerle birlikte hızlı bir değişimin yaşandığı günümüzde değerler eğitimine daha da ihtiyaç duyulmaktadır. İyi bir değer eğitimi almamış bireyler ailelerine, çevrelerine ve insanlığa zararlı davranışlarda bulunabilmektedir. Değer eğitimi ailede kazandırılmaya başlayıp, çevre ve okul yaşantısı ile devam etmektedir. Değer eğitimi yaşam boyu devam etmesine rağmen okul planlı bir eğitimin verilmesi sebebiyle değer eğitiminde önemli bir yere sahiptir. Okuldaki derslerden biri olan tarih dersleri değer eğitiminin verilebileceği önemli derslerden biridir. Tarih eğitiminin amaçları içerisinde değer eğitimi, her dönemde yerini korumuş ve tarih değer eğitiminde önemli bir araç olarak görülmüştür. Günümüzde ise gerek dünyada gerekse ülkemizde tarih derslerinde değer eğitimine daha büyük bir önem verilmektedir. Ülkemizde yenilenen ortaöğretim tarih programlarını incelediğimizde değer eğitimine ayrı bir önem verildiği açıkça görülmektedir. Son yıllarda tarih eğitiminde görsel araçların kullanımı çabaları artmasına rağmen yine de yeterince kullanılmadığı bilinmektedir. Bu görsel araçlardan biri de tarihi filmlerdir. Tarihi filmler değer eğitimi için önemli bir kaynaktır. Tarihi filmlerin öğrenciler üzerinde önemli etkileri olmaktadır. Öğrencilere tarihi filmlerle değer eğitiminin kazandırılmasının öğrenciler üzerinde bırakacağı olumlu etkilerin göz ardı edilmemesi ve değer eğitiminde işlevsel olarak kullanılması önem arz etmektedir. Bu bakımdan tarih eğitiminde değer eğitimi kazandırılmasında tarihi filmlerin kullanılması son derece önemlidir. Bu çalışmanın amacı tarih eğitimi ve değerler ilişkisi üzerinde durmak ve ortaöğretimde tarihi filmler ile öğrencilere değer eğitiminin nasıl verilebileceğini ortaya koymaktır.

Review on two books - Asociația Europeană a Profesorilor de Istorie EUROCLIO, La intersecția culturilor. Țările regiunii Marii Negre și schimbările politice din sec. XIX-XX, 2015

Review on book - Adrian DOLGHI, Istorie și politică în communism (1917-1965). Cazul R(A)SS Moldovenești (1917-1965), Monografii ANTIM XV, Chișinău: Pontos, 2016

Para explorar de forma aprofundada as conceções de mudança para lá de análises do presente, importa relembrar algumas discussões de caráter epistemológico em que perpassam visões diversas acerca da Mudança em História, algumas já ultrapassadas mas que permanecem a nível do senso comum. Perante uma intensa produção historiográfica permanentemente em renovação e aberta a diversos pontos de vista e enfoques. Pode-se inferir que a mudança em História, num quadro de reconhecimento de multiperspectiva, é concebida de forma complexa e problemática, sem um sentido fixo ou uma direção determinada. Em educação histórica, as conceções de alunos sobre o conceito de Mudança têm sido já objeto de alguns estudos que podem fornecer pistas frutuosas para a ação educativa. Neste sentido, apresentam-se e discutem-se os fundamentos teóricos, métodos e resultados de alguns desses estudos sobre ideias de alunos de vários países acerca da mudança em História. Algumas implicações destes estudos pretendem constituir-se como pistas que ajudem a desenvolver um tipo de orientação temporal eventualmente mais adequada aos tempos de incerteza que hoje se vivem.To deeply explore the conceptions about historical change beyond presentist analyses some relevant epistemological debates among diversified views on the issue must be reminded. Although some of them are now outofdate, they still have remained at a commonsense level. In the light of an intensive, permanently renovated historiographical production, open to different perspectives and foci, we might infer that, under a framework of multi perspectivism acknowledgement, change in History is conceived in a complex and problematic manner, with no fixed meaning or predetermined direction. In History Education, the students' conceptions on change have been explored in some studies with fruitful clues for educational action. Accordingly, in this paper the theoretical background, methods and results from those studies in several countries on students' ideas about change in history will be given. Some of their implications are intended to contribute as clues to help developing a type of temporal orientation eventually more appropriate to these times of uncertainty we currently live in.

This paper discusses the nature of argument and its role and importance in historical learning. The paper describes pedagogic strategies developed to help school pupils understand what argument is, model how arguments work and think about how arguments can be evaluated. These strategies are explained as generic critical thinking strategies and the article then demonstrates how these strategies can be applied in history education contexts. The strategies that the article describes aim to make the logical relationships that are embodied in arguments clear to students through the use of analogies and active learning strategies that seek, first, to enable students to represent logical relationships in concrete ways and, second, to help students manipulate and explore these relationships.Este trabalho discute a natureza do argumento e seu papel e importância na aprendizagem histórica. Este trabalho descreve as estratégias pedagógicas desenvolvidas para auxiliar os alunos a compreender o que é o argumento, a estabelecer modelos de como os argumentos funcionam e a pensar como os argumentos podem ser avaliados. Estas estratégias são explicadas enquanto estratégias genéricas de pensamento crítico; e o artigo demonstra, então, como elas podem ser aplicadas em contextos de educação histórica. As estratégias descritas objetivam tornar claras, para os alunos, as relações lógicas incorporadas pelos argumentos, através do uso de analogias e estratégias de aprendizagem ativa. Estas procuram, primeiramente, possibilitar que os alunos representem relações lógicas de maneira concreta e, em segundo lugar, auxiliar os alunos a manipular e explorar estas relações.

By 2016, all schools across Australia will have transitioned from state-based to national curricula. Given the current dynamic period of curriculum change that schools are undergoing, there is a need to investigate how this change is implemented by and impacts on teachers. This research investigates the implementation of Australian History and Geography curriculum initiatives by a junior secondary school department (Years 7-10) in North Queensland. It systematically and critically reviews the Australian curriculum implementation processes and outcomes, within one Social Science department, through a case study methodology (Koshy, 2010; Yin, 2003). Actor Network Theory (ANT) (Fenwick & Edwards, 2010) will be utilised as the theoretical framework for this research. The Actor Network theoretical framework will identify the actors (including lead researcher, teachers, administrators and objects such as Curriculum into the Classroom (C2C) materials) in the curriculum translation network and how the interactions between them shape the network and its processes. This article explores the historical context of curriculum change, maps the network of History curriculum actors and then details some of the implications that have emerged such as redefining the place of the History and Geography disciplines, the place of particular actors and the enabling and constraining factors in actors’ engagement and agency during the implementation. Researcher observations, interview and survey data provide insights into the ways in which teachers shape their own professional practices in response to curriculum change.

ResumoEste texto tem como objetivo apresentar os percursos do ensino de História da América no Brasil nos cur- rículos de História para educação básica, em especí- fico, para o espaço escolar, hoje, denominado Ensino Médio. Para tanto tomaremos, à guisa de investigação, uma longa temporalidade: do final do século XIX ao início século XXI, por meio de uma revisão histórica das propostas curriculares oficiais.ResumenEste texto tiene como objetivo pre- sentar la trayectoria de la enseñanza de Historia de América Latina en Bra- sil, en los currículos de Historia para educación básica, especialmente en el espacio escolar conocido como En- señanza Media. Para ello, con fines investigativos, tomaremos una larga temporalidad: del final del siglo XIX al inicio siglo XXI, por medio de una revisión histórica de las propuestas cu- rriculares oficiales.AbstractThis article aims to describe the tea- ching of Latin American History in Bra- zil, in the history curriculum for basic education, especially in what is known in Brazil as Middle School. For research purposes, we will take an extensive period —from the late 19th century until the early 21st— for which we will review the official curriculum po- sitions.RésuméCe texte a l'objectif de présenter la trajectoire de l'enseignement de l'Histoire d'Amérique Latine au Brésil, dans les curriculums d'Histoire pour l'éducation basique, notamment dans l'espace connu comme l'enseignement au collège. Pour cela, avec les fins de la recherche, nous prendront une lon- gue temporalité: de la fin du XIX siècle au commencement du XXI siècle, au moyen d'un bilan historique des pro- positions officielles du curriculum.