1. The Reinforcement Value of a Music Instrument for Beginning Instrumentalists and the Influence of Discovery Versus Teacher Approval on Achievement.
- Author
-
Dorow, Laura Gilbert and Greer, R. Douglas
- Subjects
MUSIC therapy ,MUSIC education ,MUSICAL performance ,MUSICAL instrument studies & exercises ,ACADEMIC achievement - Abstract
Twenty-eight musically-naive subjects from a third-grade classroom and a combined fourth-fifth-grade classroom were randomly assigned to either a no-instruction or an instruction group. All subjects were individually observed for 11 5-minute sessions of free activity time during which they could choose to play the recorder, use self-instructional recorder materials, or watch television. Immediately preceding the first 10 sessions, subjects in the instruction group received a 5-minute recorder lesson with a controlled high rate of teacher verbal approval for target social and music performance behaviors. A posttest recorder performance test was administered to subjects in both groups before the 11th session of free time. Observers counted the number of correct beats subjects played on the recorder while sight reading an untitled melody. There was no difference in the total number of seconds subjects in the no-instruction and instruction groups spent with the recorder during free time. For both groups the amount of time decreased across the 11 sessions indicating a decrease in the reinforcing effect of the music instrument. It was concluded that the initial reinforcement effect of the music instrument was a function of novelty. The fourth-fifth-graders in both groups spent more time with the recorder than.. the third-graders. Subjects in the instructional group performed better on the recorder with 13 of the 14 subjects in the no-instruction group receiving performance scores of zero beats correct. A high positive correlation was found between the amount of time subjects in the instructional group spent with the recorder during free time and their performance scores. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 1977
- Full Text
- View/download PDF