1. Steps Towards a Minimalist Account of Numbers.
- Author
-
Schindler, Thomas
- Subjects
- *
MATHEMATICAL equivalence , *SENTENCES (Logic) , *MATHEMATICS , *EQUATIONS , *EQUIVALENCE relations (Set theory) - Abstract
This paper outlines an account of numbers based on the numerical equivalence schema (NES), which consists of all sentences of the form ' # x. F x = n if and only if ∃ n x F x ', where # is the number-of operator and ∃ n is defined in standard Russellian fashion. In the first part of the paper, I point out some analogies between the NES and the T-schema for truth. In light of these analogies, I formulate a minimalist account of numbers, based on the NES, which strongly parallels the minimalist (deflationary) account of truth. One may be tempted to develop the minimalist account in a fictionalist direction, according to which arithmetic is useful but untrue, if taken at face value. In the second part, I argue that this suggestion is not as attractive as it may first appear. The NES suffers from a similar problem to the T-schema: it is deductively weak and does not enable the derivation of any non-trivial generalizations. In the third part of the paper, I explore some strategies to deal with the generalization problem, again drawing inspiration from the literature on truth. In closing this paper, I briefly compare the minimalist to some other accounts of numbers. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF