Search

Electricity consumption and anaerobic reactions cause direct and indirect greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions within domestic sewage treatment systems (DSTSs). GHG emissions in DSTSs were influenced by the sewage quantity and the efficacy of treatment technologies. To address combined effects of these variables, this study presented an approach for identifying pathways for GHG mitigation within the DSTSs of cities under climate change and socio-economic development, through combining life cycle analysis (LCA) and the Hierarchical Archimedean copula (HAC) methods. The approach was innovative in the following aspects: 1) quantifying the GHG emissions of the DSTSs; 2) identifying the correlations among temperature changes, socioeconomic development, and domestic sewage quantity, and 3) predicting the future fluctuations in GHG emissions from the DSTSs. The effectiveness of the proposed approach was validated through its application to an urban agglomeration in the Pearl River Delta (PRD), China. To identify the potentials of GHG mitigation in the DSTSs, two pathways (i.e., general and optimized) were proposed according to the different technical choices for establishing facilities from 2021 to 2030. The results indicated that GHG emissions from the DSTS in the PRD were [3.01, 4.96] Mt CO 2 eq in 2021, with substantial contributions from Shenzhen and Guangzhou. Moreover, GHG emissions from the sewage treatment facilities based on Anaerobic-Anoxic-Axic (AAO) technology were higher than those based on other technologies. Under the optimized pathway, GHG emissions, contributed by the technologies of Continuous Cycle Aeration System (CASS) and Oxidation Ditch (OD), were the lowest. Through the results of correlation analysis, the impact of socioeconomic development on domestic sewage quantities was more significant than that of climate change. Domestic sewage quantities in the cities of the PRD would increase by 4.10%–28.38%, 17.14%–26.01%, and 18.15%–26.50% from 2022 to 2030 under three Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) 2.6, 4.5, and 8.5. These findings demonstrated that the capacities of domestic sewage treatment facilities in most cities of the PRD should be substantially improved from 0.12 to 2.99 times between 2022 and 2030. Under the optimized pathway, the future GHG emissions of the CASS method would be the lowest, followed by the OD method. • The correlations between domestic sewage quantity, socioeconomic development, and climate change were focused on. • A hybrid approach based on LCA and HAC was proposed for GHG mitigation in domestic sewage treatment systems. • A typical region of China was adopted for illustrating applicability of the developed approach. • Two pathways were proposed according to the different choices for technical facilities from 2022 to 2030. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• The method of compiling the multi-regional input output is optimized. • Carbon emissions of urban agglomerations (UAs) are studied from multiple perspectives. • Carbon flows within the UA driven by final demand and primary inputs are identified. • Carbon emissions of the UA are predicted when considering uncertainty. Urban agglomerations (UAs) play a momentous role in carbon reduction. The prerequisites for achieving carbon reduction goals in UAs are accounting and predicting their carbon emissions. When considering carbon reduction goals in China, it is crucial to pay attention to the joint influence of carbon emissions and economic benefits. Hence, in this study, an improved multi-regional input–output (MRIO) approach was established to quantify and predict carbon emissions for the UA, incorporating a biproportional scaling method (RAS) and Latin hypercube sampling (LHS). Specifically, a) the carbon emissions of UAs were quantified using the MRIO model from the perspectives of production, consumption and income; b) the carbon flows between cities in UAs were identified based on final demand and primary inputs, and c) the features of UAs' carbon emissions in the future were predicted using RAS and LHS. To verify the effectiveness of the approach, a case study of a typical UA region in China [i.e., the Pearl River Delta (PRD)] was proposed. The results showed that the contribution of sectors to carbon emissions could be identified from multiple perspectives, and carbon flows can help regions coordinate emissions reductions. The majority of future carbon emissions would be generated from the areas of population and economic agglomeration (i.e., Guangzhou and Shenzhen), although the growth trend of carbon emissions of those would keep lower. The policy of carbon reduction should be urgently carried out in locations with high carbon emissions growth rates (e.g., Zhaoqing and Zhuhai). To improve the ability for carbon reduction in the PRD, cooperation in multiple cities to promote energy efficiency is advocated. The government should also increase technical support for carbon reduction and consider the balanced development of the economy, population, and resources in the PRD. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• A systematic framework was proposed to assess urban flood resilience (UFR). • Each resilience phase (e.g., resistance, adaptation, & recovery) were considered. • The system framework incorporated hybrid flood model and system performance curve. Urban flooding can seriously threaten urban ecological security and human life, and therefore urban flood resilience (UFR) is important for urban safety and stability. To comprehensively evaluate urban system performance during the entire process of rainfall, runoff, flooding, and drainage, we developed a systematic framework for UFR assessment covering runoff simulation, flood estimation, and resilience assessment, which broadly corresponded to the phases of resistance, adaptation, and recovery. The UFR in the phases of resistance, adaptation, and recovery was simulated and assessed using a system performance curve (SPC) and technically combining with the hybrid flood model while mainly considering the total simulation time and inundated urban proportion in SPC. Because the extent of urban flooding can be influenced by climate change and the rate of urbanization, we chose the corresponding representative factors of precipitation and infiltration rate and considered 21 simulation scenarios (seven rainfall return periods and three infiltration rates) for which UFR was quantified according to urban system performance. The effectiveness of this framework was demonstrated in application to a typical highly urbanized area (i.e., Dongguan, China). The following results were derived: (1) The inundated area under the pessimistic scenario (i.e., S19) would be nearly four times greater than that under the optimistic scenario (i.e., S3); (2) The values of UFR in Dongguan were 0.9494–0.9863, locating at the high and very high level; (3) The lowest UFR value was 0.6552 in the Shuixiang New City district; and (4) The rainfall return period was the main factor influencing UFR under relatively short rainfall return periods (i.e., S1–S9), while infiltration rate was the principal influencing factor under relatively long rainfall return periods (i.e., S10–S21). The proposed systematic framework could be applied in other cities and large-scale regions like urban agglomerations and provinces. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

In this study, a hybrid approach was established to identify future heterogeneity of urban ecosystem health (UEH) transferred by variations of land-use, socio-economic development, and ecological function in lower scales of cities (i.e., districts), incorporating uncertainty analysis into a multi-criteria decision assessment framework. In consideration of multiple driving factors of UEH scores, the contribution of the main indicators to UEH scores was identified by geographical detector model. To verify effectiveness of the approach, a case study was applied in Dongguan City of China. The results indicated that UEH scores of Dongguan didn't greatly change during 2010–2020. Conversely, the scores would increase from 2023 to 2030, influenced by socio-economic development and ecological function under the district scale. Concurrently, the heterogeneity of urban ecosystem health ranks (UEHRs) in 32 districts occurred during 2010–2020, further influencing UEH scores of Dongguan. Owing to inconsistent of land-use, ecological function, and socio-economic development of districts, the heterogeneity of UEHRs was intensified in 2025–2030. From 2010 to 2020, the spatial variations of UEH scores in Dongguan City depended on the synergy of land-use intensity and economic growth. The joint influence from economic development, energy consumption and land-use patterns would contribute greatly to the variations of UEH scores in Dongguan City from 2023 to 2030. Thus, heterogeneity of UEHRs under district scale as well as promotion for sustainable economic development should be paid attention to by decision-makers, to identify internal characteristics in urban ecosystems. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

In highly urbanized areas, domestic water consumption and wastewater discharge are affected by several dynamic factors, such as economy, population, and environment, which further influence the greenhouse gas (GHG) mitigation potential of urban domestic water systems (UDWSs). To analyze GHG emission features of the UDWSs and their interactions with urban economic development, a hybrid approach of correlation analysis and a programming model was incorporated in a life-cycle framework to provide decision-making support for GHG mitigation strategies in the UDWSs. To verify the applicability of the method, Shenzhen city in Guangdong Province was chosen to analyze the potential of the UDWS for mitigating GHG emissions. The GHG emissions from the UDWS in Shenzhen was 747.82 kt CO 2 eq in 2020. Compared with 2020, domestic water consumption would increase by 11.35 % and 18.67 % in 2025 and 2030, and wastewater discharge would increase by 12.88 % and 19.73 % in 2025 and 2030, respectively. In the trend of socio-economic development, the amount of water demand and wastewater discharge of urban residents would increase by 11.49 % to 18.75 % and 12.88 % to 19.75 % from 2020 to 2030, respectively. Optimum strategies of technologies for wastewater treatment and energy mix for electricity generation were obtained, with consideration of GHG mitigation goals in the future. As energy consumption contributed more than 25 % of GHG emissions in the USDWs of Shenzhen, the contributions of new energy sources for electricity production (i.e., offshore wind, solar photovoltaic, biomass, and nuclear) would increase by 0.58–1.02 times and 0.68–1.20 times from 2020 to 2025 and 2025 to 2030, respectively. The capacity of wastewater treatment would increase by 53.33 % to 80.00 % and 27.44 % to 29.82 % of the SBR and AAO technologies, respectively. Thus, it is suggested that decision makers should pay close attention to optimizing energy mix of electricity production. • Urban domestic water systems (UDWSs) were focused on. • Domestic water consumption and wastewater discharge were affected by socio-economic factors. • A hybrid approach was proposed, incorporating LCA, copula functions, and a programming model. • Potential of GHG mitigating in the UDWS was analyzed. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Water scarcity tends to be aggravated by increase in water demand with the trend of socio-economic development. Thus, non-stationary characteristics of water demand should be identified in water resources allocation (WRA) to alleviate the potential influences from water shortages. In this study, a Copula-based interval linear programming model was established for regional WRA. Through combining correlation analysis and an interval linear programming model, this model can: 1) identify interactions between water demand and socio-economic development levels based on Copula functions, 2) explore variations in water shortage with consideration of multiple risk tolerance levels of decision-makers based on Copula sampling, and 3) obtain desired strategies for WRA through an interval linear programming model. Also, Dalian City in China was selected as a case study area to verify the effectiveness of the model for WRA to five water users (i.e., agricultural sector, industrial sector, public service sector, domestic residents, and ecological environment). Considering multiple tolerance levels of decision-makers to water shortage risk, three scenarios (i.e., S1 to S3), indicating 20%, 40%, and 60% of their low, medium, and high tolerance levels, were proposed. The results showed that the correlation between the amount of water demand and indicators of socio-economic development can be described by Clayton and Gaussian Copula functions. The total water supply of Dalian in 2030 would increase by 2.06%–2.65%, compared with the one in 2025. The allocation of water resources across districts was influenced by varied water demand, energy consumption, and risk tolerance levels. Compared with the amount of water allocation in 2025, the contribution of transferred water sources would increase by 6.71% and 7.04% under S1 and S2 in 2030, respectively, and decrease by 14.31% under S3. With the increase of risk tolerance levels of decision-makers, the amount of water supply in Dalian City would gradually decrease. • A Copula-based programming model is developed for water allocation management. • Decision-makers' tolerance to water shortage risk is incorporated. • Variations of water demand along with socio-economic development are identified. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

As an effective measure to promote socio-economic development, industrial transformation indirectly changes the characteristics of urban underlying surfaces, leading to the complexity of controlling nonpoint source (NPS) pollution in cities. However, the relationship between industrial transformation and urban NPS pollution, as well as the critical socioeconomic factors influencing the characteristics of urban NPS pollution during the period of industrial transformation, is still unclear, seriously affecting urban water environment management. In this research, indicator systems for the estimation of industrial transformation and urban NPS pollution were first established. Then, the characteristics of industrial transformation and urban NPS pollution were analyzed through an entropy weight method and a volume–concentration model. In addition, critical socioeconomic factors affecting urban NPS pollution during periods of industrial transformation were identified using Pearson correlation analysis and a grey correlation model. Using Dongguan City in South China as the study area, the results showed that the level of industrial transformation in this city shows an upward trend, and the towns with relatively high level of industrial transformation gradually gathered around Songshan Lake. The four urban NPS pollution index (i.e., chemical oxygen demand, suspended solids, total nitrogen, and total phosphorus) significantly increased during the slow transformation period (2000–2010), then slightly decreased during the rapid transformation period (2010–2020). The pollution loads exhibited significant spatiotemporal heterogeneity. A significantly negative correlation (p < 0.05) was observed between industrial transformation and urban NPS pollution levels during the transformation period. It was found that fertilizer, electricity, and water consumptions, as well as permanent population were the critical socioeconomic factors affecting urban NPS pollution. Control of the application amounts of fertilizers and improvement in the efficiencies of urban water and electricity use are the effective methods for preventing and controlling urban NPS pollution during the period of industrial transformation. In addition, industrial enterprises should increase their investment in research and development activities to accelerate industrial transformation and reduce the urban NPS pollution load. This research contributes to urban NPS pollution control in the area undergoing industrial transformation. • A comprehensive method was proposed for evaluating urban NPS pollution during the period of industrial transformation. • The relationship between industrial transformation and urban NPS pollution was analyzed for the first time. • A significant negative correlation was observed between the levels of industrial transformation and NPS pollution. • Critical socioeconomic factors affecting urban NPS pollution during the industrial transformation period were identified. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Urban non-point source (NPS) pollution management is receiving increased attention because of the environmental and ecological consequences of urbanization. We developed a Storm Water Management Model (SWMM)-based interval double-sided chance-constrained programming (SWMM–IDCCP) model for the optimal design of low impact development (LID) during urban NPS pollution management at a community scale. Pollution control efficiency and economic costs related to LID practices were considered in the SWMM–IDCCP model, simultaneously addressing uncertainties in pollutant output and decision-making processes. Specifically, by combining SWMM, Monte Carlo simulation, interval linear programming, and double-sided chance-constrained programming, the SWMM–IDCCP model can evaluate export loads of urban NPS pollutants and pollution control efficiencies of LID practices and analyze the corresponding uncertainties. Concurrently, the proposed model can provide reliable and optimal implementation schemes for LID practices under different scenarios, dealing with uncertainties such as discrete intervals and double-sided random parameters. The proposed model was applied to the Dongguan University of Technology in Dongguan City, South China. The random distribution characteristics of pollution load were identified. The ranges of pollution load for total suspended solids, chemical oxygen demand, total nitrogen, and total phosphorus were 76,430–165,698, 44,366–74,155, 2118–3,830, and 97–177 kg in 2021, respectively. Probability distribution characteristics of pollution control efficiencies of three LID practices (i.e., bio-retention cell, green roof, and permeable pavement) for the four urban NPS pollutants were obtained. Using the SWMM-IDCCP model, LID configuration schemes were obtained under diverse pollution control targets and confidence levels, taking into account variations in the decision preference of different administrators. This research indicates that the SWMM-IDCCP model can be used to manage urban NPS pollution at a community scale under uncertainty. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• Interactions of water resources in adjacent regions was examined. • Variations in water supply and demand were analyzed through autoregressive models. • Interaction relationship between multi-regional nexus water shortage was solved. • Water resources allocation strategies were obtained through the optimization model. • The models were applied in Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei urban agglomeration of China. Growing agricultural and economic activities have brought tremendous pressure to regional water resources management. Considering the interactions of water resources allocation among adjacent regions with connected water systems, it is necessary to pay attention to the unification of socio-economic development and environmental protection between the regions. This is of significance to many agglomeration areas that are composed of multiple large cities such as the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei urban agglomeration (BTH) in China. In this research, an ensemble approach was proposed to tackle water resources allocation problems under the constraints of water resources to reflect interdependence of the composed three areas, i.e., Beijing, Tianjin and Hebei. The approach included ARIMA (Autoregressive Integrated Moving Average) method, ANN (Artificial Neural Network) modelling, copula functions, and multi-objective chance-constrained programming model. It can 1) reflect the variations characteristic of regional water supply and demands, 2) solve the interactions between multi-regional water resources, and 3) obtain desired water resources allocation strategies under multi- scenario and scale conditions. Then, the approach was applied in typical regions of China, i.e., Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei urban agglomeration. Considering 27 scenarios of the nexus water shortage risk, multi-objective joint opportunity constraint programming model aimed at maximizing economic benefits and ecological benefits, in combination with economic, agricultural, water resources and environmental constraints. As the optimal strategies indicated, the maximum GDP in BTH would remain at 8514 billion yuan. The minimum amount of water allocation and wastewater discharge would be 24–26 billion m3 and 2100–2101 million m3 respectively. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• A novel uncertainty analysis method of agricultural grey water footprint was proposed. • Impacts of production conditions on agricultural grey water footprint were reflected. • Interval characteristics of agricultural grey water footprint can be obtained. • The proposed method can help identify water pollution risk more accurately. Agricultural grey water footprint (GWF) is an important index for quantitatively describing the impact of agricultural production on water environment, which can help evaluate regional water pollution risk (WPR). However, changes in agricultural production conditions lead to strong uncertainties in agricultural GWF. Therefore, advanced methods to deal with these uncertainties for improving the accuracy of regional WPR assessment are required. By combining min–max/max-max programming models with a GWF assessment framework, an integrated uncertainty analysis method for agricultural GWF affected by production conditions was proposed in this study. Based on the method, extreme scenarios of GWF evaluation were established to obtain lower and upper bounds of agricultural GWF. The proposed method was applied in the Guangdong Province in South China, and the following results were obtained. Agricultural GWFs in the Guangdong Province were [124.67, 237.37], [110.63, 204.90], and [104.04, 178.01] Gm3 in 2005, 2010, and 2015, respectively. Different contributing factors of agricultural GWF were shown in the minimum and maximum GWF scenarios. For crop planting, the contribution of dryland and paddy fields to GWF was larger than that of garden land in the minimum GWF scenario, whereas the contribution of garden land was greatest in the maximum GWF scenario. For livestock and poultry breeding, the contribution of livestock raised under dry cleaning condition to the GWF was larger than that under flushing condition in the minimum GWF scenario, whereas the opposite situation was observed in the maximum GWF scenario. Based on the interval values of agricultural GWF, the WPR of the cities of Zhanjiang, Maoming, Yunfu, Chaozhou, Foshan, and Dongguan were identified as unacceptable. By identifying the uncertainties within agricultural GWF evaluation induced by the variability of production conditions, the proposed method can provide helpful information for agricultural planning in the context of sustainable agricultural development. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The urbanization process has seen an accelerated increase in recent decades, leading to urban runoff pollution becoming more prominent. However, uncertainty of the pollution output and complexity of management systems have made controlling urban runoff pollution challenging. Therefore, it is necessary to propose advanced modeling methods for these challenges. This research presents an integrated urban runoff pollution management (IURPM) model for optimal configuration of low impact development (LID) practices under multiple uncertainties. The IURPM model combines the hybrid land-use prediction and improved pollution estimation models with interval parameter, stochastic parameter, and multi-objective programming. The proposed IURPM model can not only predict the output characteristics, but also provide optimal configuration schemes for the LID practices in the management of urban runoff pollution under multiple scenarios. In addition, uncertainties expressed as discrete intervals and probability density function in the management systems can be effectively addressed. A case study of the IURPM model was conducted in Dongguan City, South China. Results show that considerable amounts of urban runoff pollutants would export from Dongguan City by 2025. The export loads and pollution output flux per unit area would have significant spatial heterogeneity. The results further indicate that population size, gross domestic product, and regional area size are expected to play important roles in the pollution export, while impervious surface coverage and population density would likely have great influences on the output flux of urban runoff pollution. Based on the model findings, multiple LID practices should be adopted in Dongguan City to reduce the urban runoff pollution loads. Using the IURPM model, multiple LID implementation schemes can be obtained under different pollution reduction scenarios and significance levels, that can provide decision-making support for urban water environmental management, considering variations in the policymaker's decision-making preferences. This study demonstrates that the IURPM model can be applied to the optimal configuration of LID practices for the management of urban runoff pollution under uncertainty. • An integrated urban runoff pollution management model was proposed. • The model can predict the loads of urban runoff pollution. • The model can provide optimal configuration schemes of low impact development practices. • Interval and stochastic uncertainties in urban runoff pollution systems can be handled. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Socioeconomic development, leading to significant changes in land-use patterns, has further influenced the output of regional nonpoint-source (NPS) pollution. Multiple uncertainties exist in the processes of land-use changes and NPS pollution export. These uncertainties can deeply affect the management of regional land-use patterns and control of NPS pollution. In this research, an integrated land-use prediction and optimization (ILUPO) model based on system dynamics, export coefficient, interval linear programming, and fuzzy parameter programming models was proposed. The ILUPO model can provide future land-use patterns and NPS pollution loads, and also help optimize the patterns under multiple pollution reduction scenarios. Interval and fuzzy uncertainties in the processes of land-use changes and NPS pollution output can be effectively addressed. The developed model was applied to a water source area in the central part of northern Guangdong Province in South China. For the prediction period 2020–2030 under the high-speed development scenario, results show that cropland area would decrease, while grassland and waterbody areas would increase. In contrast, these three types of land-use would show opposite variation trends under the low-speed development scenario. Construction land area would decrease, while forestland area would increase under both the low-speed and high-speed development scenarios. Variation of the predicted land-use patterns would lead to an increase of total nitrogen loads under each of the scenario, while the total phosphorus loads would show relatively complex variation trends. Regional land-use patterns should be further optimized to mitigate NPS pollution. However, the pollution loads in the study area cannot be reduced by >5% through land-use adjustment. Because cropland would still be the critical source of NPS pollution after optimization, strictly controlling the areas of cropland would be important for the management of such pollution in the research area. In addition, certain areas of grassland and waterbody would need to be converted into cropland and construction land to balance the economic benefit of the system and NPS pollution control. Multiple results obtained from the model under different scenarios of pollution reduction targets and α-cut levels can provide decision-making supports for the local policy makers. The developed ILUPO model can yield insights useful for the planning and adjustment of regional land-use patterns while considering NPS pollution control under conditions of uncertainty. • An integrated model is proposed for land-use prediction and optimization. • System dynamics of land-use patterns affected by multiple factors can be reflected. • Uncertainties in land-use change and NPS pollution export processes can be addressed. • Optimal land-use patterns can be obtained to support land-use decision-making. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

[Display omitted] • Patch complexity and urban compactness indexes were developed to assess urban form. • The impact of urban form on PM 2.5 was explored in GBA by spatial panel models. • The complexity of urban patches had a negative effect on PM 2.5 concentrations. • The impact of urban compactness on PM 2.5 concentrations was positive. • A more complex and less compact urban form was adoptable in terms of reducing PM 2.5. Given the serious threat of PM 2.5 pollution to the environment and public health in China, reducing PM 2.5 concentrations through urban planning practices has become a common interest of urban planners and policymakers. In this regard, identifying the relationship between urban form and PM 2.5 concentrations has been a matter of much concern. This paper seeks to investigate how urban form influences PM 2.5 concentrations by taking the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area (GBA) as a case study. First, the urban form was assessed by two indicators, i.e., the patch complexity index (PCI) and urban compactness index (UCI), which were developed based on multiple landscape metrics and the principal component analysis. Then, the relationship between PM 2.5 concentrations and the two urban form indicators was revealed by spatial panel models. Our results mainly showed that PCI and UCI were negatively and positively associated with PM 2.5 concentrations, respectively, indicating that less compact urban forms with high patch complexity had advantages in reducing the PM 2.5 concentrations. According to these empirical results, the mixed-use urban development with high green coverage, which is conducive to constructing a more complex and less compact urban form, would be adoptable in terms of mitigating PM 2.5 concentrations in the GBA urban agglomeration. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• An integrated modeling approach is developed. • Multiple modeling methods were combined. • The approach is applied in a City Cluster of China. • Coordination for WEF and economy is analyzed under multiple scenarios. In this research, an integrated approach is developed through the incorporation of systems dynamics (SD), catastrophe progression (CP), and coupled coordination degree (CCD) analysis within a general modelling framework. The developed SD-CP-CCD is then employed to simulate and evaluate relationships among the water-energy-food (WEF) and the economic systems. It will improve traditional methods for WEF nexus analysis through a) incorporating urban WEF connections and changes into the cross-system coupling analysis framework, b) evaluating its coordination with economic growth and a multi-scale and regional disparity, and c) promoting policy recommendations to ensure the guarantee of urban WEF under economic growth. The approach is then verified through WEF nexus system of Urban Agglomerations of Pearl River Delta City Cluster (PRDCC) in China. Temporal and spatial characteristics of CCD in the region were analyzed. The results revealed their performance in cities with multiple economic backgrounds. Also, the fragile factors of each city were reflected by multi-scale exploration. Regional inequality and spatial agglomeration effects were considered. The results showed that CCD has noticeable temporal and spatial differences. Geographically, CCD varied from uncoordinated to high-level coordination. The eastern cities were much better coordinated than the western cities. Due to the increasing pressure of population and economic growth in the future, the upward trend of CCD would occur in most cities. The vulnerability factors of each city were explored. Simultaneously, apparent spatial inequality and agglomeration patterns were observed, with a downward trend over time. The temporal and spatial patterns of CCD revealed in this study indicated that PRDCC policymakers should formulate policies that suit the characteristics of cities and reduce the targeted regional imbalances. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]